TL;DR
This paper introduces and validates the COMI-B (Converter CO2 Oxygen Mixed Injection-Bottom Blowing) technology for steelmaking. By injecting CO2 alongside oxygen in converters, the process significantly improves dephosphorization, reduces slag impurities and nitrogen content in steel, enhances gas recovery, and decreases soot production, offering a novel route for CO2 utilization in the steel industry.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The iron and steel industry is a major contributor to global CO2 emissions, accounting for a substantial portion of industrial energy consumption and greenhouse gas output. While strategies like Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) and Carbon Capture and Utilization (CCU) are explored, the direct utilization of CO2 within existing high-temperature industrial processes remains a key challenge. Specifically, in converter steelmaking, which is a critical step in producing steel, there's a need for technologies that not only reduce emissions but also enhance process efficiency and product quality. Existing methods for CO2 reduction often focus on capture and storage, or separate utilization pathways. This paper addresses the gap by investigating the direct application of CO2 as a reactive gas within the converter smelting process itself, aiming to leverage its chemical properties to improve steelmaking outcomes and simultaneously utilize captured CO2.
Methods
The study employed a combination of laboratory experiments and industrial-scale tests to evaluate the COMI-B technology.
- Laboratory Experiments: Thermodynamic calculations using "FactSage 7.1" software were performed to understand the reaction mechanisms of CO2 with key elements in molten steel (C, Si, Mn, P) at high temperatures. Additionally, high-temperature experimental tube furnace tests were conducted to specifically study the dephosphorization efficiency of CO2-O2 mixed blowing under controlled conditions.
- Industrial Tests: A 120-ton converter at Yongxin Iron and Steel Group was used for industrial trials. The COMI-B technology involved top blowing with a mixture of O2 and CO2, and bottom blowing with various gases (N2, Ar, or CO2). Two distinct CO2 injection modes (Mode-1 and Mode-2) were compared against a conventional N-Mode (using only N2 for bottom blowing). The tests involved a total of 400 furnace runs.
- Data Analysis: The collected data included molten steel and slag compositions, end-point nitrogen content, gas recovery, and soot production. These parameters were statistically analyzed and compared across the different modes to quantify the benefits of COMI-B technology.
Datasets
The study utilized data from:
- Thermodynamic Software: FactSage 7.1 was used for theoretical calculations of reaction thermodynamics.
- Industrial Test Data: Data was collected from 400 industrial smelting runs in a 120-ton converter. This included measurements of molten steel and slag composition, gas flow rates, nitrogen content, and dust production.
- Laboratory Furnace Data: Experimental data from a high-temperature tube furnace was used to assess dephosphorization efficiency under varying CO2 proportions.
No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study compared the performance of the COMI-B technology against the established N-Mode in the same industrial setting.
Key Insights and Ideas
- CO2 as a Reactive Gas: The core idea is that CO2 isn't just an inert gas or a waste product to be captured, but can actively participate in high-temperature metallurgical reactions. Its ability to react with carbon to form CO (an endothermic reaction) offers a unique cooling effect, which is counterintuitive but beneficial for controlling the molten pool temperature.
- Bubble Proliferation for Enhanced Kinetics: The reaction of CO2 with molten steel elements produces CO gas, leading to significant bubble proliferation. This bubbling action dramatically improves the stirring of the molten pool, enhancing mass transfer and thus accelerating reactions like dephosphorization and denitrification.
- Thermodynamic Advantage: While O2-based processes are exothermic and can lead to overheating and iron evaporation, CO2's endothermic reaction with carbon helps to moderate the temperature. This controlled temperature is crucial for optimizing dephosphorization and reducing unwanted side reactions that lead to dust formation.
- Synergistic Effect of Top and Bottom Blowing: The combination of top-blown CO2/O2 and bottom-blown gases (including CO2) creates a more dynamic and controlled environment within the converter, leading to improved overall process efficiency and product quality.
Key Results
The COMI-B technology demonstrated significant improvements over the conventional N-Mode:
- Dephosphorization: Dephosphorization rate increased by 4.2%.
- Slag Quality: Slag (FeO) content was reduced by 2.04%, and slag basicity increased, indicating a cleaner slag.
- Steel Quality: End-point nitrogen content in molten steel was reduced by 20%. The carbon-oxygen product also decreased.
- Gas Recovery: Per ton of steel, gas recovery increased by 8.29 Nm³/t, with a higher CO content in the recovered gas, improving its calorific value.
- Soot Reduction: Soot production was reduced by 14.7%, with a notable decrease in large particle size dust.
Limitations and Future Work
- CO2 Injection Ratio Optimization: While the study showed benefits, the paper suggests that the "appropriate CO2 mixing ratio" is crucial for optimal dephosphorization. Further fine-tuning of these ratios for different steel grades and process conditions could yield even better results.
- Industrial Scale-Up: The study was conducted on a 120-ton converter. While successful, scaling this technology to even larger converters or different types of steelmaking furnaces might present unique engineering challenges.
- Economic Viability: The paper highlights the potential for CO2 utilization, but a detailed techno-economic analysis comparing the cost-effectiveness of COMI-B versus traditional methods, considering CO2 sourcing and handling, would be valuable.
- Long-Term Effects: The study focused on immediate smelting outcomes. Long-term impacts on refractory lining wear, equipment lifespan, and the overall sustainability of the process could be areas for future investigation.
The authors suggest that COMI-B technology offers a promising path for the resource utilization of CO2 in the iron and steel industry, enabling the production of high-quality steel grades with reduced environmental impact.
Summary updated