Development and Application of a Comprehensive Measure of Access to Health Services to Examine COVID-19 Health Disparities

Fathima Wakeel, Haiyan Jia, Lifang He, Karmel S. Shehadeh, Lucy E. NapperHealthcare 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, comprehensive measure of access to health services that includes not only traditional healthcare access but also access to community resources. The study uses this measure to reveal significant disparities in healthcare access during the COVID-19 pandemic, particularly among vulnerable sociodemographic and health groups, offering crucial insights for public health interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Access to healthcare has long been a recognized challenge in the U.S., with persistent disparities linked to sociodemographic factors like race, ethnicity, gender, and age. The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated these issues, highlighting existing inequities and introducing new barriers. While research has explored various facets of healthcare access, a significant gap exists in conceptualizing and measuring access that comprehensively includes essential community resources, which play a vital role in individual well-being, especially during crises. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and validating a measure that captures access to medicine/equipment, healthcare visits, and community resources, and then examining how sociodemographic and health factors influence these different dimensions of access during the pandemic.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel "access-to-health-services" measure by synthesizing existing literature and evaluating it with a multidisciplinary team. The measure comprises three components:

  1. Access to Medicine and Medical Equipment: Assessed through items related to obtaining equipment/supplies and medications.
  2. Access to Healthcare Visits: Measured by items concerning office closures, postponed appointments, and skipped appointments.
  3. Confidence in Accessing Community Resources: Evaluated using a Likert scale assessing confidence in accessing various resources like food support, housing, mental health services, and LGBTQ+ support.

A Principal Components Analysis (PCA) was used to validate the healthcare access items, resulting in two factors for this component. For community resources, PCA indicated a unidimensional construct. The study then employed linear regression models to analyze the relationships between sociodemographic and health-related variables and the three components of the access-to-health-services measure.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a nationwide online survey of 1491 respondents conducted in August 2021. Participants were recruited through Prolific, a web-based survey recruitment platform. The dataset includes detailed sociodemographic information (race/ethnicity, gender identity, income, age, marital status, region of residence, having children under 18) and health-related variables (chronic physical health condition, mental health condition, disability, health insurance, COVID-19 diagnosis).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Access Measure: The most significant contribution is the development of a measure that moves beyond traditional healthcare access to incorporate crucial community resources, recognizing their importance, especially during crises.
  • Pandemic's Amplifying Effect: The COVID-19 pandemic significantly impacted access to healthcare, with postponing appointments being the most common issue reported.
  • Disparities Persist and Evolve: The study confirms that sociodemographic factors (race, gender, age) and health factors (chronic illness, mental health, disability) are strongly associated with disparities in healthcare access.
  • Community Resource Gaps: Lower-income individuals and certain racial/ethnic minority groups (e.g., Asian individuals) reported significantly lower confidence in accessing community resources, highlighting a critical area for intervention.
  • Vulnerable Populations Identified: The research pinpoints specific groups, such as those with children under 18, who experienced greater challenges in accessing healthcare during the pandemic.

Key Results

  • Healthcare Access Impacts: Postponing healthcare appointments (34.7%) was the most frequently reported impact of the pandemic on healthcare access, followed by office closures (25.0%) and skipped appointments (22.4%). Access to medicine and medical equipment was less frequently impacted (7.6% and 7.4%, respectively).
  • Community Resource Confidence: Participants reported the highest confidence in accessing spiritual resources (mean score 2.78/4) and food access support (2.71/4), while confidence was lowest for housing (2.06/4) and LGBTQ+ resources (2.06/4).
  • Sociodemographic and Health Correlates:
    • Medicine/Equipment Access: Individuals with chronic physical health conditions, disabilities, a COVID-19 diagnosis, and those with children under 18 reported significantly higher impacts on access to medicine and medical equipment.
  • Healthcare Visits Access: Multiracial individuals, cisgender females, and those with pre-existing health conditions, health insurance, or a COVID-19 diagnosis experienced higher impacts on access to healthcare visits. Older adults (65+) and those living in the Midwest, South, and West reported less impact.
  • Community Resource Confidence: Asian individuals and those who preferred not to state their race/ethnicity, lower-income individuals, and those identifying as "other gender identity" reported significantly lower confidence in accessing community resources. Older adults (65+) and those with health insurance reported higher confidence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Recall Bias: The survey was conducted in August 2021, asking about events over the past 17 months, which may lead to recall bias.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature prevents establishing causality and understanding how access evolved over different pandemic stages. Longitudinal research is recommended.
  • Online Survey Bias: Reliance on an online survey may have excluded individuals with limited internet access or digital literacy, potentially underestimating disparities.
  • Potential for Survey Fraud: While attention checks were used, the possibility of missing data and survey fraud exists.

Future work should focus on longitudinal studies to track temporal relationships between access and health outcomes. Further research is also needed to explore the mediating and moderating mechanisms of sociodemographic and health characteristics on access to health services and community resources. Additionally, incorporating the quality of care into access measures is suggested for a more comprehensive understanding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Research on access to health services during the COVID-19 pandemic is limited, and the conceptualization of access has not typically included access to community resources. We developed and tested an access-to-health-services measure and examined disparities in access among individuals in the U.S. during the pandemic. Data are from a U.S. sample of 1491 respondents who completed an online survey in August 2021. Linear regression models assessed the relationships between the access-to-health-services-measure components, including impact on access to medicine and medical equipment, impact on access to healthcare visits, and confidence in accessing community resources, and predictor variables, including sociodemographic- and health-related factors. Disparities in access to healthcare during the pandemic were associated with sociodemographic characteristics (i.e., race, gender, and age) and health-related characteristics (i.e., chronic illness, mental health condition, and disability). Factors such as race, gender, income, and age were associated with individuals' degree of confidence in accessing community services. Our study presents a new access-to-health-services measure, sheds light on which populations may be most vulnerable to experiencing reduced access to health services, and informs the development of programmatic interventions to address the salient needs of these populations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wakeel2023development,
  author = {Fathima Wakeel and Haiyan Jia and Lifang He and Karmel S. Shehadeh and Lucy E. Napper},
  title = {{Development and Application of a Comprehensive Measure of Access to Health Services to Examine COVID-19 Health Disparities}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare11030354},
}
Figure