Determination of the <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" altimg="si1.gif" overflow="scroll"><mml:msup><mml:mrow><mml:mi>η</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mo>′</mml:mo></mml:mrow></mml:msup></mml:math>-nucleus optical potential

M. Nanova, V. Metag, É. Ya. Paryev, D. Bayadilov, B. Bantes, R. Beck, Y. A. Beloglazov, S. Böse, Kai-Thomas Brinkmann, Th. Challand, V. Credé, Taylor Dahlke, F. Dietz, P. Drexler, H. Eberhardt, D. Elsner, R. Ewald, K. Fornet-Ponse, S. Friedrich, F. Frommberger, M. Gottschall, A. Gridnev, M. Grüner, E. Gutz, Ch. Hammann, D. Hammann, J. Hannappel, J. Hartmann, W. Hillert, P. Hoffmeister, Ch. Honisch, I. Jaeglé, David Kaiser, H. Kalinowsky, S. Kammer, I. Keshelashvili, V. Kleber, F. Klein, E. Klempt, B. Krusche, Μ. Lang, I. Lopatin, Y. Maghrbi, K. Makónyi, J. Müller, Tim Odenthal, D. Piontek, S. Schaepe, Christian Schmidt, H. Schmieden, R. Schmitz, T. Seifen, A. Thiel, U. Thoma, H. van Pee, D. Walther, Ch. Wendel, U. Wiedner, A. Wilson, A. Winnebeck, Friedemann ZenkePhysics 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In the field of subatomic physics, the $\eta'$ (eta-prime) meson is considered an "oddball" due to its significantly higher mass compared to other members of the pseudoscalar meson family. This mass anomaly is widely attributed to the $U_A(1)$ symmetry breaking in Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), linked to the complex vacuum structure of the theory. A fundamental question is how the properties of the $\eta'$ meson, particularly its mass, are modified when it is immersed in dense nuclear matter.

Theoretical models, such as those based on the partial restoration of chiral symmetry, predict a substantial drop in the $\eta'$ mass—potentially up to 200 MeV—at normal nuclear density. To investigate this, the CBELSA/TAPS Collaboration conducted experiments to determine the $\eta'$-nucleus optical potential. This potential consists of a real part ($V$), which describes the mass shift (attractive if negative), and an imaginary part ($W$), which characterizes the absorption of the meson within the nucleus.

Experimental Methodology

The study utilized the ELSA electron accelerator in Bonn, Germany, to produce a "tagged" photon beam with energies between 1250 and 2600 MeV. These photons were directed at a solid carbon ($^{12}C$) target. To establish a baseline for $\eta'$ production off a free nucleon, reference data were also collected using a liquid hydrogen ($LH_2$) target.

The experimental setup featuring the Crystal Barrel and MiniTAPS detectors, alongside the reconstructed $\eta'$ mass peak from carbon data.

The detection system comprised the Crystal Barrel and TAPS calorimeters, which together provided nearly $4\pi$ (full spherical) coverage. This was essential for identifying the specific decay chain $\eta' \to \pi^0 \pi^0 \eta \to 6\gamma$, requiring the simultaneous detection of six photons. The researchers analyzed the excitation function—the variation of the production cross-section with beam energy—and the momentum distribution of the escaping $\eta'$ mesons.

Results and Discussion

A primary indicator of an in-medium mass drop is the observation of "subthreshold" production. On a free proton, $\eta'$ production is kinematically forbidden below a certain energy threshold. However, if the meson's mass is reduced inside a nucleus, this threshold is effectively lowered. The experimental results showed an appreciable yield of $\eta'$ mesons at energies where production would be impossible if the mass remained constant.

Comparison of total cross-sections for $\eta'$ photoproduction on hydrogen and carbon. The right panel shows hydrogen data scaled to highlight the subthreshold behavior in carbon.

To quantify the potential, the data were compared with simulations from the GiBUU transport model, testing various potential depths from 0 to -150 MeV. The best fit to the experimental data yielded an attractive potential of $V = -(37 \pm 10_{stat} \pm 10_{syst})$ MeV at normal nuclear density. This corresponds to a mass shift of approximately 40 MeV.

Crucially, the magnitude of this real potential ($|V| \approx 37$ MeV) is significantly larger than the imaginary part ($|W| \approx 10$ MeV) determined in previous transparency ratio measurements. In nuclear physics, the condition $|V| > |W|$ is the "green light" for the existence of bound states, suggesting that the $\eta'$ meson can be captured by the nucleus to form an $\eta'$-mesic nucleus.

Conclusion

The determination of an attractive $\eta'$-nucleus potential of $-37$ MeV provides strong evidence for an in-medium mass shift and confirms the feasibility of searching for $\eta'$-mesic bound states. While the study identifies a total systematic uncertainty of about 20%—arising from fitting procedures, photon flux, and shadowing effects—the results clearly rule out scenarios with no mass shift or extremely deep potentials.

Future research will focus on "missing mass spectroscopy" at facilities like GSI or the BGO-Open Dipol setup at ELSA. Finding a bound $\eta'$-nucleus state would provide a direct and clean probe into the role of the $U_A(1)$ anomaly in defining the mass of hadronic matter.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{nanova2013determination,
  author = {M. Nanova and V. Metag and É. Ya. Paryev and D. Bayadilov and B. Bantes and R. Beck and Y. A. Beloglazov and S. Böse and Kai-Thomas Brinkmann and Th. Challand and V. Credé and Taylor Dahlke and F. Dietz and P. Drexler and H. Eberhardt and D. Elsner and R. Ewald and K. Fornet-Ponse and S. Friedrich and F. Frommberger and M. Gottschall and M. Gottschall and A. Gridnev and M. Grüner and E. Gutz and Ch. Hammann and D. Hammann and J. Hannappel and J. Hartmann and W. Hillert and P. Hoffmeister and Ch. Honisch and I. Jaeglé and David Kaiser and H. Kalinowsky and S. Kammer and I. Keshelashvili and V. Kleber and F. Klein and E. Klempt and B. Krusche and Μ. Lang and I. Lopatin and Y. Maghrbi and K. Makónyi and J. Müller and Tim Odenthal and D. Piontek and S. Schaepe and Christian Schmidt and H. Schmieden and R. Schmitz and T. Seifen and A. Thiel and U. Thoma and H. van Pee and D. Walther and Ch. Wendel and U. Wiedner and A. Wilson and A. Winnebeck and Friedemann Zenke},
  title = {{Determination of the <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" altimg="si1.gif" overflow="scroll"><mml:msup><mml:mrow><mml:mi>η</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mo>′</mml:mo></mml:mrow></mml:msup></mml:math>-nucleus optical potential}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2013.10.062},
}
Figure