Designing Supportive Soundscapes for Nursing Home Residents with Dementia

Paul Devos, Francesco Aletta, Pieter Thomas, Mirko Petrović, Tara Vander Mynsbrugge, Dominique Van de Velde, Patricia De Vriendt, Dick BotteldoorenInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a framework for designing supportive soundscapes in nursing homes for residents with dementia. By leveraging acoustic stimuli, the goal is to positively influence mood, enhance feelings of safety, and trigger desired behaviors, ultimately improving the residents' well-being and reducing challenging behaviors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the global population ages, dementia is becoming an increasingly significant health challenge, affecting millions worldwide. Nursing homes are crucial environments for providing care to individuals with dementia, but these settings can often be monotonous and lack stimulating elements, potentially exacerbating cognitive decline and behavioral issues. While music therapy has shown promise, this paper focuses on the broader concept of a "soundscape" – the entire acoustic environment – and how it can be intentionally designed to support residents with dementia. The challenge lies in creating a sonic environment that is not only pleasant but also actively beneficial, considering the unique cognitive and sensory processing differences in individuals with dementia, who may rely more heavily on auditory cues due to visual impairments.

Methods

The authors propose a framework for designing supportive soundscapes based on a narrative review of existing literature. This review covers:

  • Sonic Perception and Soundscape: Understanding how individuals perceive and interpret sounds, and how this differs with age and cognitive impairment.
  • Perceived Safety Theory: How auditory cues can influence feelings of safety and reduce stress.
  • Effects of Sound on Behavior: How both attended (e.g., music) and subliminal sounds can impact mood and behavior.
  • Auditory Processing and Cognition with Age and Dementia: The specific changes in hearing and sound processing that occur with aging and dementia, including impaired recognition, localization, and increased distractibility.

Based on this review, the paper outlines a framework for soundscape composition that aims to achieve three primary effects:

  1. Mood Changers: Using sounds to positively influence emotional states, addressing common issues like depression.
  2. Safety Enhancers: Employing sounds that provide clear temporal and spatial orientation, reducing anxiety and promoting a sense of security.
  3. Response Triggers: Utilizing specific, clear sounds to elicit desired behaviors or actions, such as announcing meal times.

The framework suggests a daylong pattern of added acoustic stimuli, tailored to diurnal rhythms and potentially personalized through a "persona" approach to account for varying levels of cognitive ability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a conceptual framework and a review of existing literature, rather than empirical data collection or model training.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Soundscape as a Therapeutic Tool: The paper elevates soundscape design beyond mere acoustic comfort to a proactive therapeutic intervention for individuals with dementia.
  • Beyond Music Therapy: While acknowledging music therapy's benefits, the framework emphasizes the continuous, pervasive nature of a soundscape as a more integrated approach.
  • Cognitive Deficits as Design Drivers: The authors explicitly link the design of soundscapes to the specific cognitive deficits associated with dementia (e.g., impaired recognition, temporal processing) to ensure effectiveness.
  • The "Persona" Approach: Recognizing the heterogeneity of dementia, the proposal of using "personas" to categorize residents based on interpreting and reacting capabilities offers a practical way to personalize soundscape design.
  • Dual Pathways of Influence: The framework considers both the "meaning" (foreground) and "core affect" (background) pathways of sound influence, suggesting a comprehensive approach.
  • Importance of Context and Timing: The diurnal pattern and specific context (e.g., sleeping room vs. living room) are highlighted as critical factors for effective soundscape composition.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results from an intervention study. Instead, it offers a conceptual framework and a qualitative discussion of potential outcomes. The key "results" are the proposed framework itself and the insights derived from the literature review, which suggest that:

  • Appropriate soundscape design can positively influence mood, increase perceived safety, and trigger desired responses in residents with dementia.
  • Specific acoustic stimuli (e.g., birdsong, church bells, music, ambient sounds) can be categorized and deployed to achieve these effects.
  • A pilot study mentioned in the discussion found soundscapes to be experienced positively, impacting the atmosphere and behavior of residents, particularly through their "orientating" function.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Detailed Diagnosis Hindrance: The burden of dementia often makes detailed diagnosis difficult, hindering precise personalization of soundscape approaches.
  • Habituation: While residents may habituate to added sounds, the authors suggest this is not necessarily negative and can confirm safety. However, the extent of habituation in individuals with dementia compared to healthy individuals is uncertain.
  • Personalization Challenges: As individuals with dementia may not be able to express preferences or modify playback systems, a suitable, accessible feedback system and caregiver involvement are crucial for evaluation and adaptation.
  • Need for Expertise: Designing effective soundscapes requires not only knowledge of acoustics and psychoacoustics but also insight into the specific context and residents' states. The authors emphasize the importance of involving acoustical experts.
  • Future Work: The paper calls for further research and implementation of the proposed framework, including co-creation sessions with staff and residents, and the development of technology to support feedback and tuning of sound playback systems. The authors also suggest that such interventions could reduce pharmaceutical use and improve staff working conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sound and its resulting soundscape is a major appraisal component of the living environment. Where environmental sounds (e.g., outdoor traffic sounds) are often perceived as negative, a soundscape (e.g., containing natural sounds) can also have a positive effect on health and well-being. This supportive effect of a soundscape is getting increasing attention for use in practice. This paper addresses the design of a supportive sonic environment for persons with dementia in nursing homes. Starting from a review of key mechanisms related to sonic perception, cognitive deficits and related behavior, a framework is derived for the composition of a sonic environment for persons with dementia. The proposed framework is centered around using acoustic stimuli for influencing mood, stimulating the feeling of safety and triggering a response in a person. These stimuli are intended to be deployed as added sounds in a nursing home to improve the well-being and behavior of the residents.
BibTeX
@article{devos2019designing,
  author = {Paul Devos and Francesco Aletta and Pieter Thomas and Mirko Petrović and Tara Vander Mynsbrugge and Dominique Van de Velde and Patricia De Vriendt and Dick Botteldooren},
  title = {{Designing Supportive Soundscapes for Nursing Home Residents with Dementia}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph16244904},
}
Figure