Designing core ontologies

Ansgar Scherp, Carsten Saathoff, Thomas Franz, Steffen Staab

TL;DR

This paper introduces a design approach for "core ontologies" – reusable, domain-independent knowledge models – and demonstrates their application in a complex emergency response scenario. By emphasizing formal precision, modularity, and extensibility, these core ontologies enable seamless integration of diverse information systems, paving the way for more effective communication and data exchange in critical situations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Integrating disparate, heterogeneous information systems is a persistent challenge, especially in domains requiring the exchange of complex, structured knowledge. A key bottleneck is the lack of a formal, standardized way to model this knowledge, leading to inefficient communication and potential errors. The authors argue that this problem is exacerbated by the absence of well-defined, reusable knowledge models that can bridge the gap between different application domains. They propose "core ontologies" as a solution, aiming to provide a robust and flexible foundation for representing complex knowledge that can be shared across various systems and contexts.

Methods

The paper proposes a design approach for core ontologies characterized by several key properties:

  • Axiomatization and Formal Precision: Core ontologies are built upon a foundational ontology (specifically, DOLCE+DnS Ultralight) to ensure a solid, machine-readable semantic basis. This involves rigorous definition of concepts and relations using description logics.
  • Modularity: Ontologies are designed using "ontology design patterns," which are reusable solutions to recurring modeling problems. This modularity allows for selecting and combining specific parts of an ontology as needed.
  • Extensibility: The pattern-oriented design allows for adding new patterns or extending existing ones without disrupting the overall structure, accommodating evolving requirements.
  • Reuseability: Core ontologies are designed to be reused across different applications and domains, both in terms of their internal structure and by incorporating existing domain knowledge.
  • Separation of Concerns: Core ontologies focus on providing the structured knowledge, while domain-specific knowledge is kept separate and integrated as needed. This ensures that the core ontologies remain general and adaptable.

The authors developed three core ontologies: Event-Model-F (for events and objects), COMM (for multimedia annotations), and X-COSIMO (for personal information management and communication). These ontologies were applied to model a complex emergency response scenario.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Beautiful Ontologies": The authors introduce the concept of "beautiful ontologies" to describe core ontologies that are not only formally precise but also elegantly designed for flexibility and interoperability. This beauty lies in their ability to formally capture specific fields while being easily combined to address complex application needs.
  • The Power of Design Patterns: The paper strongly advocates for the use of ontology design patterns as a fundamental building block for core ontologies. This approach leads to modularity, reusability, and a more systematic development process.
  • Foundational Ontology as a Cornerstone: Basing core ontologies on a well-established foundational ontology like DOLCE provides a strong semantic grounding and facilitates alignment and integration with other ontologies.
  • Interoperability Through Combination: The core insight is that by adhering to a consistent design approach and leveraging a common foundational ontology, diverse core ontologies can be seamlessly combined to model highly complex scenarios, such as emergency response, where information needs to flow between many different entities and systems.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the successful application of their three core ontologies (Event-Model-F, COMM, and X-COSIMO) in modeling a detailed emergency response scenario. This scenario involved:

  • Representing events like power outages and snapped power poles using Event-Model-F.
  • Documenting calls and media (audio recordings) with COMM.
  • Modeling communication and tasks between emergency personnel using X-COSIMO.

The authors show how these ontologies and their patterns (e.g., participation, documentation, communication) interoperate and share common real-world entities (like audio recordings or individuals) to create a comprehensive model of the scenario. They highlight how this approach enables effective information exchange between different emergency response entities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Foundational Ontologies: The authors acknowledge that designing core ontologies based on foundational ontologies is a "cumbersome and tedious task" requiring deep knowledge.
  • Alignment Challenges: While their approach facilitates integration, aligning ontologies from different domains can still be a challenge, especially if they don't follow a systematic development approach.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that in the future, more "beautiful core ontologies" will emerge, and the need to combine them for complex applications will increase. They believe their approach contributes to advancing ontology engineering from an "art to an engineering discipline." The ontologies and supporting tools are available online.

Summary updated

Abstract

One of the key factors that hinders integration of distributed, heterogeneous information systems is the lack of a formal basis for modeling the complex, structured knowledge that is to be exchanged. To alleviate this situation, we present an approach based on core ontologies. Core ontologies are characterized by a high degree of axiomatization and formal precision. This is achieved by basing on a foundational ontology. In addition, core ontologies should follow a pattern-oriented design approach. By this, they are modular and extensible. Core ontologies allow for reusing the structured knowledge they define as well as integrating existing domain knowledge. The structured knowledge of the core ontologies is clearly separated from the domain-specific knowledge. Such core ontologies allow for both formally conceptualize their particular fields and to be flexibly combined to cover the needs of concrete, complex application domains. Over the last years, we have developed three independent core ontologies for events and objects, multimedia annotations and personal information management. In this paper, we present the simultaneous use and integration of our core ontologies at the example of a complex, distributed socio-technical system of emergency response. We describe our design approach for core ontologies and discuss the lessons learned in designing them. Finally, we elaborate on the beauty aspects of our core ontologies.
BibTeX
@article{scherp2011designing,
  author = {Ansgar Scherp and Carsten Saathoff and Thomas Franz and Steffen Staab},
  title = {{Designing core ontologies}},
  journal = {Appl. Ontology},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.3233/ao-2011-0096},
}
Figure