Abstract
The theory on autopilot design of non-rolling missile has been well developed, but the perfect theory on autopilot design of rolling missile has not come into being. Aiming at this problem, the coherence research on autopilot is carried out based on the analysis of scope and frequency area. And the primary coherence condition is given. With the research work, it is expected that the answer can be gotten about with which condition controller design of rolling missile can be translated into controller design of non-rolling missile. Finally, the actuator delay problem of rolling missile is researched, too.
Introduction
In the field of aerospace engineering, designing an autopilot for a non-rolling missile is a well-understood problem with a mature theoretical toolkit. However, many missiles roll during flight to improve stability or compensate for manufacturing asymmetries. This rotation introduces complex cross-coupling and signal modulation that significantly complicate direct autopilot design. Engineers often attempt to simplify the process by designing for a non-rolling scenario and then adding compensation for the rotation. However, until now, there has been no rigorous theoretical framework to determine when such a simplification is valid. This paper defines "coherence conditions" to evaluate when a rolling missile's control performance matches its non-rolling counterpart.
Methodology
The study employs frequency-domain analysis combined with coordinate transformations to bridge the gap between the rotating missile body and the fixed inertial frame.
- Coordinate Transformation: A "quasi-body" coordinate system is defined to relate the rotating body to the fixed frame.
- Coherence Definition: Coherence is defined as a state where the system's response to a command is identical regardless of whether the missile is rolling. Mathematically, this requires the amplitude $A(\omega)$ and phase $\phi(\omega)$ of the closed-loop transfer function at the roll frequency ($\omega_0$) to match the values at zero frequency (steady state).
- Structural Analysis: The paper analytically tests common architectures, including open-loop systems, angular rate feedback systems, and overload feedback systems (both Proportional and Integral types).
- Actuator Compensation: A lead-corrector algorithm is derived to negate the phase delay caused by the actuator when the rudder signal is modulated by the missile's rotation.
Analysis of Control Architectures
The research identifies that for open-loop and rate-feedback systems, coherence depends heavily on the product of the actuator time constant ($T_d$) and the roll rate ($\omega_0$). Specifically, the condition $T_d \omega_0 \ll 1$ must be met. Angular rate feedback facilitates coherence by effectively reducing the system's time constant.
A critical finding involves the comparison of overload feedback structures. Proportional-type overload feedback naturally satisfies the coherence condition, making it the most robust choice for simplified design methods.
In contrast, Integral-type overload feedback is inherently unsuitable for the non-rolling design approach. The integration adds a significant phase delay (often exceeding $45^\circ$ at the roll frequency) that violates the coherence condition, leading to poor control performance.
Key Results and Insights
The study provides explicit approximate conditions for coherence: $|A(0) - A(\omega_0)| \leq \epsilon_A$ and $|\phi(0) - \phi(\omega_0)| \leq \epsilon_\phi$.
- Architecture Performance: Proportional overload is highly coherent ($\phi(s) \approx 1$ under ideal conditions), while integral overload fails due to excessive phase delay.
- Delay Compensation: The authors provide a specific formula for a lead corrector that uses the roll frequency and the actuator's phase delay to calculate necessary parameters for real-time compensation.
Conclusion
This research establishes the mathematical groundwork for treating rolling missile autopilot design as a simplified non-rolling problem. While proportional feedback architectures support this shortcut, integral-type structures do not maintain performance under high roll rates. Future work should involve applying these coherence conditions to high-fidelity 6-DOF simulations to verify how well these theoretical bounds hold up against real-world non-linearities like actuator saturation.
Summary updated