TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel 3D geological suitability evaluation (3D UGEE) software system designed to overcome the limitations of traditional 2D methods. By integrating advanced 3D spatial analysis and comprehensive evaluation modules, the system provides a more accurate and detailed assessment of underground space development potential, crucial for efficient urban planning and risk mitigation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Urban development is increasingly pushing towards underground spaces to alleviate land use pressure and spatial congestion. However, the feasibility and safety of such developments are heavily reliant on geological conditions. Traditional methods for evaluating geological suitability for underground space development primarily use 2D Geographic Information Systems (GIS). These 2D approaches suffer from a significant loss of crucial 3D spatial data and lack the depth resolution necessary for accurate assessments. This leads to an incomplete understanding of the underground environment, potentially resulting in increased risks, costs, and inefficient planning. The paper addresses this gap by proposing a dedicated 3D UGEE software system that can handle and analyze multivariate geoscientific data in three dimensions.
Methods
The core of this work is the design and implementation of a 3D UGEE software system. The system is built using an "integrated secondary development" approach, leveraging the powerful 3D geological modeling capabilities of Surpac™ software as a foundation. External functionalities are extended using the C# programming language. This approach aims to combine the stability and visualization strengths of Surpac with the flexibility of custom programming.
The system's architecture is hierarchical, comprising:
- Foundation Layer: Database and File System.
- Data Access Layer: Surpac API and Custom Extension API.
- Business Logic Layer: This is where the main functionalities reside, including:
- Data Conversion and Interaction Module: Handles 2D-to-3D conversion and discretization of geological data.
- Evaluation Index Screening Module: Uses methods like maximum dissimilarity analysis and rough set theory to select critical evaluation indicators.
- 3D Spatial Analysis Module: A suite of tools for analyzing 3D geological data, including:
- 3D Spatial Statistical Analysis (e.g., geological body complexity, thickness, depth).
- 3D Spatial Surface Analysis (e.g., surface extraction, interface analysis, slope, relief).
- 3D Spatial Distance Analysis (e.g., influence distance of geological features).
- 3D Spatial Overlay Analysis (combining multiple 3D datasets).
- 3D Spatial Interpolation (using methods like IDW, Kriging).
- Comprehensive Evaluation Module: Integrates analyzed data to produce final suitability scores, incorporating weight determination (subjective and objective methods) and various evaluation models.
- Underground Space Resource Estimation Module: Calculates volumes of developed and available underground space.
Datasets
The study utilizes multidimensional and multi-source data for its case study in Qingdao. This includes:
- Borehole data
- Digital Elevation Model (DEM)
- Planar geological maps
- Planning data
These datasets were used to construct a 3D engineering geological model using Geomodeller™ software. The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather demonstrates the application of the developed system on existing, real-world geoscientific data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging the 2D-3D Gap: The most significant insight is the successful development of a system that moves beyond the limitations of 2D GIS for underground space evaluation, offering true 3D analysis and visualization.
- Integrated Workflow: The system provides a comprehensive workflow, from data conversion to final suitability scoring and resource estimation, streamlining the entire UGEE process.
- Leveraging Existing Software: The "integrated secondary development" approach, building upon Surpac, is a practical strategy to leverage robust existing platforms while extending functionality for specialized tasks.
- Multi-faceted Analysis: The inclusion of diverse 3D spatial analysis techniques (statistical, surface, distance, overlay, interpolation) allows for a more nuanced understanding of complex geological environments.
- Quantitative Suitability: The system moves beyond qualitative assessments to provide quantitative geological suitability levels, enabling more precise decision-making.
Key Results
The paper presents a case study in Qingdao, China, demonstrating the system's capabilities.
- The 3D UGEE system was successfully applied to analyze geological suitability for underground space development in a 3.2 km² area.
- The system generated 3D spatial analysis results for various evaluation factors, including ground elevation, geological structure complexity, bedrock surface depth, and artificial fill thickness.
- A comprehensive evaluation of the shallow subsurface layer (0-15 m) classified areas into "undevelopable," "insufficiently developable," and "fully developable" zones.
- Approximately 78.38% of the shallow layer was identified as having remaining underground space resource capacity.
- The results indicated that faulted structural zones and artificial fill thickness were primary constraints in certain areas.
- The system's output was found to have better accuracy and practicability compared to traditional 2D methods, with a more intuitive presentation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Computational Complexity: The authors acknowledge that the computational complexity of 3D UGEE increases exponentially with the size of the evaluated area, potentially leading to billions of operations and impacting operational efficiency.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that investigating novel geometric measurement and sorting methodologies to optimize existing 3D spatial analysis and evaluation models, with the goal of accelerating software computation, is a prominent future research trend. This would further enhance the system's practicality for large-scale applications.
Summary updated