Abstract
In news articles the lead bias is a common phenomenon that usually dominates the learning signals for neural extractive summarizers, severely limiting their performance on data with different or even no bias. In this paper, we introduce a novel technique to demote lead bias and make the summarizer focus more on the content semantics. Experiments on two news corpora with different degrees of lead bias show that our method can effectively demote the model's learned lead bias and improve its generality on out-of-distribution data, with little to no performance loss on in-distribution data.
Introduction
Neural extractive summarizers often rely on "lead bias"—the tendency for news articles to place the most important information in the first few sentences. While this heuristic works well for standard news datasets like CNN/Daily Mail (CNN/DM), it creates a "shortcut" that prevents models from truly understanding content semantics. Consequently, these models generalize poorly to datasets where key information is distributed differently, such as extreme summarization tasks. Previous attempts to mitigate this, like sentence shuffling, often disrupt the natural flow and inter-sentential relationships necessary for learning.
Proposed Method: Alternating Adversarial Learning
We propose a novel framework that demotes lead bias by forcing the model to focus on content rather than position. The architecture consists of two primary components: a Summarization Component and a Position Prediction Component (the adversary).
The training process follows an alternating adversarial game:
- Position Learning: The summarizer's weights are frozen, and the adversary is trained to predict a sentence's position within the document based on its contextualized representation.
- Position Debiasing: The adversary's weights are frozen, and the summarizer is trained to minimize summarization loss while maximizing the adversary's uncertainty. This forces the encoder to "hide" positional information in its embeddings.
To ensure robustness, multiple adversaries are used simultaneously, making the "hiding" task significantly harder for the encoder and preventing it from simply encoding position in a more complex, hidden way.
Experimental Results
We evaluated our method on CNN/DM (high lead bias) for in-distribution performance and XSum (low lead bias) for generality.
Performance and Generality
On XSum, our method achieved a ROUGE-Mean of 10.61, outperforming both the Basic Transformer (10.32) and the Shuffling baseline (10.47). Crucially, unlike the "No Position Encoding" variant which suffered a massive drop on CNN/DM (falling to 29.24), our adversarial method maintained a ROUGE-Mean of 32.18, nearly identical to the Basic Transformer (32.27). This demonstrates that the model "demotes" rather than "deletes" positional cues, successfully balancing them with semantic features.
Qualitative Analysis
Analysis of the relative position distribution shows that our debiased model tracks the "Oracle" (ground truth) distribution much more closely than the basic model, which is heavily skewed toward the beginning of the document.
Conclusion
Our alternating adversarial learning framework effectively reduces the reliance of extractive summarizers on lead bias. By forcing the encoder to produce position-agnostic representations, the model learns to prioritize content semantics, leading to better generalization across diverse datasets without sacrificing performance on standard benchmarks. Future work includes extending this approach to abstractive summarization and exploring dynamic bias adjustment during inference.
Summary updated