Delayed viral clearance and exacerbated airway hyperinflammation in hypertensive COVID-19 patients

Saskia Trump, Soeren Lukassen, Markus S. Anker, Robert Lorenz Chua, Johannes Liebig, Loreen Thürmann, Victor M. Corman, Marco Binder, Jennifer Loske, Christina Klasa, Teresa G. Krieger, Bianca P. Hennig, Marey Messingschlager, Fabian Pott, Julia Kazmierski, Sven Twardziok, Jan Philipp Albrecht, Sara Hadzibegovic, Alessia Lena, Bettina Heidecker, Christine Goffinet, Florian Kurth, Martin Witzenrath, Maria Theresa Völker, Sarah Dorothea Müller, Uwe G. Liebert, Naveed Ishaque, Lars Kaderali, Leif Erik Sander, Sven Laudi, Christian Drosten, Roland Eils, Christian Conrad, Ulf Landmesser, Irina LehmannmedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, clinical observations have consistently identified hypertension and cardiovascular disease (CVD) as primary risk factors for severe disease progression and mortality. A significant point of contention in the medical community has been the role of common antihypertensive treatments—specifically Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme inhibitors (ACEi) and Angiotensin Receptor Blockers (ARB). Because the SARS-CoV-2 virus utilizes the ACE2 receptor for cellular entry, concerns were raised that these medications might increase viral susceptibility by upregulating receptor expression.

This study investigates the cellular and molecular mechanisms driving poor outcomes in hypertensive patients, utilizing single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) of airway samples to map the "cellular landscape" of the infection. The findings suggest that the increased risk in hypertensive patients stems not from increased susceptibility to infection, but from a pre-existing inflammatory "priming" of the immune system that is further modulated by specific antihypertensive therapies.

The ACE2 Susceptibility Question

One of the study's primary objectives was to determine if ACEi or ARB treatments increase the expression of the SARS-CoV-2 entry receptor, ACE2, in the upper respiratory tract. By analyzing 114,761 individual cells from nasopharyngeal swabs, the researchers found no significant difference in ACE2 expression among patients treated with ACEi, ARBs, or those not on these medications. This evidence effectively suggests that these common blood pressure medications do not increase a patient's initial susceptibility to SARS-CoV-2 infection.

Cellular Priming and Hyperinflammation

The study revealed that hypertensive patients possess a distinct inflammatory predisposition even before infection. Immune cells, specifically macrophages and neutrophils, in these patients showed higher baseline levels of inflammatory markers. This state of "inflammatory priming" means that upon viral challenge, the immune system is already poised for an exaggerated response, often leading to the dangerous "cytokine storm" associated with critical COVID-19 cases.

Divergent Effects of ACEi and ARB Therapy

While hypertension itself increases risk, the study found that the type of antihypertensive treatment significantly influenced the disease course:

  • ACE Inhibitors (ACEi): Patients treated with ACEi exhibited a dampened hyper-inflammatory response. Clinical data showed that ACEi treatment was associated with a reduction in the risk of critical disease to levels comparable to patients without hypertension. Furthermore, these patients demonstrated normal viral clearance rates.
  • Angiotensin Receptor Blockers (ARB): Conversely, ARB treatment was associated with delayed viral clearance and enhanced interactions between epithelial and immune cells. Patients on ARBs showed significantly slower viral clearance (p=0.031) compared to healthy controls.

The CCL3/CCL4/CCR1 Signaling Axis

At the molecular level, the study identified the CCL3/CCL4/CCR1 signaling axis as a key driver of severity in hypertensive patients, particularly those on ARBs. Macrophages and neutrophils in these patients exhibited significantly higher expression of the chemokines CCL3 and CCL4, along with their receptor CCR1. This signaling pathway recruits additional immune cells to the lungs, fueling a cycle of hyperinflammation and airway damage that correlates strongly with critical disease progression.

Conclusion

This research provides a mechanistic explanation for why cardiovascular comorbidities exacerbate COVID-19. It suggests that hypertension primes the immune system for hyperinflammation, while different classes of blood pressure medication further modulate this response. While ACE inhibitors appear to mitigate some of these risks by dampening inflammation and supporting viral clearance, ARBs may be associated with a more prolonged inflammatory state.

As an observational study, these findings do not yet warrant a change in clinical guidelines, but they provide a strong molecular rationale for ongoing randomized controlled trials (RCTs) investigating the comparative benefits of ACEi versus ARB therapy in the context of COVID-19.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In COVID-19, hypertension and cardiovascular diseases have emerged as major risk factors for critical disease progression. Concurrently, the impact of the main anti-hypertensive therapies, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEi) and angiotensin receptor blockers (ARB), on COVID-19 severity is controversially discussed. By combining clinical data, single-cell sequencing data of airway samples and in vitro experiments, we assessed the cellular and pathophysiological changes in COVID-19 driven by cardiovascular disease and its treatment options. Anti-hypertensive ACEi or ARB therapy, was not associated with an altered expression of SARS-CoV-2 entry receptor ACE2 in nasopharyngeal epithelial cells and thus presumably does not change susceptibility for SARS-CoV-2 infection. However, we observed a more critical progress in COVID-19 patients with hypertension associated with a distinct inflammatory predisposition of immune cells. While ACEi treatment was associated with dampened COVID-19-related hyperinflammation and intrinsic anti-viral responses, under ARB treatment enhanced epithelial-immune cell interactions were observed. Macrophages and neutrophils of COVID-19 patients with hypertension and cardiovascular comorbidities, in particular under ARB treatment, exhibited higher expression of CCL3, CCL4 , and its receptor CCR1 , which associated with critical COVID-19 progression. Overall, these results provide a potential explanation for the adverse COVID-19 course in patients with cardiovascular disease, i.e. an augmented immune response in critical cells for the disease course, and might suggest a beneficial effect of clinical ACEi treatment in hypertensive COVID-19 patients.
BibTeX
@misc{trump2020delayed,
  author = {Saskia Trump and Soeren Lukassen and Markus S. Anker and Robert Lorenz Chua and Johannes Liebig and Loreen Thürmann and Victor M. Corman and Marco Binder and Jennifer Loske and Christina Klasa and Teresa G. Krieger and Bianca P. Hennig and Marey Messingschlager and Fabian Pott and Julia Kazmierski and Sven Twardziok and Jan Philipp Albrecht and Sara Hadzibegovic and Alessia Lena and Bettina Heidecker and Christine Goffinet and Florian Kurth and Martin Witzenrath and Maria Theresa Völker and Sarah Dorothea Müller and Uwe G. Liebert and Naveed Ishaque and Lars Kaderali and Leif Erik Sander and Sven Laudi and Christian Drosten and Roland Eils and Christian Conrad and Ulf Landmesser and Irina Lehmann and Irina Lehmann},
  title = {{Delayed viral clearance and exacerbated airway hyperinflammation in hypertensive COVID-19 patients}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.09.22.20199471},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure