Dehn surgery and negatively curved 3-manifolds

Daryl Cooper, Marc Lackenby

Abstract

This paper investigates the relationship between Dehn surgery and negative curvature in 3-manifolds. The authors prove that for any given 3-manifold $M$, there are at most finitely many hyperbolic knots $K \subset S^3$ and surgery coefficients $p/q$ (with $|q| > 22$) such that $M$ is obtained by $p/q$-surgery on $K$. This result stems from a broader theorem: if $M$ is obtained by Dehn filling a hyperbolic 3-manifold $X$ along slopes of length greater than $2\pi + \epsilon$, there are only finitely many possibilities for $X$ and the filling slopes.

Introduction: Kirby’s Problem and Geometric Constraints

Dehn surgery is a fundamental construction in 3-manifold topology, involving the removal of a solid torus neighborhood of a knot and its re-attachment via a specific slope $p/q$. A long-standing question in the field, identified as Problem 3.6 (D) in Kirby’s list, asks whether a single 3-manifold can be produced by surgery on an infinite number of distinct knots.

This research addresses this problem by leveraging the geometric properties of knot complements. By exploring how the hyperbolic geometry of the original manifold constrains the topology of the resulting manifold, the authors provide a finiteness bound for "long" surgeries.

Methodology: Bridging Topology and Geometry

The authors' approach relies on the interplay between topological invariants and geometric metrics.

The 2π Theorem and Negative Curvature

The work builds on the Gromov-Thurston $2\pi$ Theorem, which posits that Dehn filling a hyperbolic manifold along slopes longer than $2\pi$ results in a manifold admitting a negatively curved metric. The authors extend this by establishing precise estimates for volume, sectional curvature, and the Gromov norm.

Slope Length Analysis

A critical component of the proof involves relating the topological "distance" between slopes to their geometric length.

Figure 1: Geometric representation of slopes $s_1, s_2, s_3$ as vectors in a lattice, used to analyze the relationship between topological distance and geometric length.

As shown in Figure 1, slopes are treated as vectors in a lattice representing the fundamental group of the boundary torus. The authors prove that if the intersection number (topological distance) between two slopes is large, at least one slope must be geometrically long. This bridge allows topological constraints to be translated into geometric bounds.

Geometric Convergence

By demonstrating that the volumes of potential "parent" hyperbolic manifolds are bounded, the authors apply convergence theory. This ensures that only a finite number of such manifolds can exist for a given target manifold $M$, provided the surgery slopes satisfy the length requirement.

Key Insights

  1. Geometry as a Finiteness Filter: The requirement for a negatively curved metric with sectional curvatures bounded away from zero (the $2\pi + \epsilon$ condition) acts as a filter, limiting the possible underlying hyperbolic structures.
  2. Volume and Gromov Norm Parity: For long surgeries, the Gromov norm of the filled manifold remains close to the volume of the original hyperbolic manifold. Since the Gromov norm is a topological invariant, it effectively "locks" the volume of the parent manifold.
  3. Almost Hyperbolic Rigidity: The authors characterize "almost hyperbolic" manifolds—those admitting metrics with sectional curvatures arbitrarily close to -1—proving they must possess a complete, finite-volume hyperbolic structure.

Main Results

  • Theorem 4.1: For a fixed 3-manifold $M$ and $\epsilon > 0$, there are only finitely many hyperbolic manifolds $X$ and sets of slopes $s_i$ (length $\ge 2\pi + \epsilon$) such that Dehn filling $X$ along $s_i$ yields $M$.
  • Corollary 4.5: For any closed orientable 3-manifold $M$, there are at most finitely many hyperbolic knots $K \subset S^3$ and fractions $p/q$ (with $|q| > 22$) such that $M$ is obtained by $p/q$-surgery on $K$.
  • Theorem 6.2: A compact orientable 3-manifold is hyperbolic if and only if it is "almost hyperbolic."

Conclusion and Limitations

The primary constraint of these findings is the $2\pi + \epsilon$ condition. While the results cover "long" surgeries, the possibility of infinitely many "short" surgeries yielding the same manifold remains theoretically open. The specific bound $|q| > 22$ for knot surgery is a direct consequence of the geometric estimates used. Future research may focus on refining these bounds or extending the finiteness results to shorter surgery slopes.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that, for any given 3-manifold M, there are at most finitely many hyperbolic knots K in the 3-sphere and fractions p/q (with q > 22), such that M is obtained by p/q surgery along K. This is a corollary of the following result. If M is obtained by Dehn filling the cusps of a hyperbolic 3-manifold X, where each filling slope has length more than 2 π+ ε, then, for any given M and ε> 0, there are only finitely many possibilities for X and for the filling slopes. In this paper, we also investigate the length of boundary slopes, and sequences of negatively curved metrics on a given 3-manifold.
BibTeX
@article{cooper1998dehn,
  author = {Daryl Cooper and Marc Lackenby},
  title = {{Dehn surgery and negatively curved 3-manifolds}},
  journal = {Journal of Differential Geometry},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.4310/jdg/1214424971},
}
Figure