Defining Factors Associated with High-quality Surgery Following Radical Cystectomy: Analysis of the British Association of Urological Surgeons Cystectomy Audit

Wei Shen Tan, Jeffrey J. Leow, Maya Marchese, Ashwin Sridhar, Giles Hellawell, Matthew Mossanen, Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh, Sarah Fowler, Alexandra Colquhoun, Jo Cresswell, James W.f. Catto, Quoc‐Dien Trinh, John D. KellyEuropean 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies key factors associated with high-quality radical cystectomy (RC) surgery for bladder cancer, finding that higher surgeon experience and minimally invasive approaches lead to better outcomes. Crucially, high-quality surgery is independently linked to a lower risk of death during the initial hospital stay, underscoring the importance of specialized care.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Radical cystectomy (RC) is a complex and high-morbidity surgery for muscle-invasive bladder cancer. Despite its critical role, the quality of RC can vary significantly, leading to differing patient outcomes. The challenge lies in defining what constitutes "high-quality" RC and identifying the factors that contribute to it. This paper aims to address this by analyzing a large national registry to pinpoint surgeon, patient, and hospital characteristics associated with superior surgical quality and, consequently, better patient outcomes.

Methods

The researchers utilized a multilevel hierarchical mixed-effect logistic regression model to analyze data from the British Association of Urological Surgeons (BAUS) registry. This statistical approach is suitable for handling clustered data (patients within hospitals) and allows for the identification of independent predictors of high-quality surgery and index admission mortality.

High-quality surgery was defined by a composite metric including:

  • Pathological factors: Absence of positive surgical margins (PSM) and a minimum of a level I lymph node dissection (LND) with at least ten lymph nodes removed.
  • Recovery: A hospital length of stay (LOS) of 10 days or less.
  • Technical factors: Intraoperative blood loss less than 500 ml for open RC and less than 300 ml for minimally invasive RC.

Datasets

The study used data from the prospective British Association of Urological Surgeons (BAUS) registry, collected between January 2014 and December 2017. This registry captures approximately 80% of all RC surgeries performed in the UK.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surgeon Volume Matters More Than Hospital Volume: While both surgeon and hospital volume are often considered, this study found that annual surgeon operating volume was a significant predictor of high-quality surgery, but annual hospital operating volume was not. This suggests that individual surgeon expertise plays a more direct role in surgical quality than the overall throughput of the hospital.
  • Minimally Invasive RC is Associated with Higher Quality: The study found that patients undergoing minimally invasive RC (laparoscopic/robotic) were more likely to receive high-quality surgery. This aligns with the technical definitions of quality used, which included lower blood loss thresholds for minimally invasive procedures.
  • High-Quality Surgery Translates to Lower Mortality: Perhaps the most impactful finding is that high-quality surgery, as defined by the study's metrics, was an independent predictor of lower index admission mortality. This provides a direct link between surgical quality and immediate patient survival.
  • Recent Surgery is a Quality Indicator: More recent year of surgery was also associated with higher quality, suggesting that advancements in techniques, protocols, or learning curves over time contribute to better outcomes.

Key Results

  • A total of 4654 patients underwent RC by 152 surgeons at 78 UK hospitals.
  • 19.6% of patients (914 out of 4654) met the criteria for high-quality surgery.
  • Predictors of High-Quality Surgery: Minimally invasive surgical approach (OR: 1.86), higher annual surgeon operating volume (23.1-33.0 cases: OR 1.54; ≥33.1 cases: OR 1.64), and more recent surgery year (OR: 1.22) were independently associated with receiving high-quality surgery.
  • Impact on Mortality: High-quality surgery was independently associated with a significantly lower risk of index admission mortality (OR: 0.38).
  • Thresholds for Quality: The study identified minimum annual surgeon volume of ≥20 RCs/surgeon/yr and hospital volume of ≥68 RCs/hospital/yr as thresholds associated with better rates of high-quality RC.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective Data: The data is from a retrospective registry, which can introduce reporting biases.
  • Self-Submitted Data: Data submitted by surgeons or administrative staff may not be perfectly accurate.
  • Incomplete Data: Up to 20% of cases may not have been recorded, potentially skewing results.
  • Missing Variables: Key variables like enhanced recovery protocols, 30/90-day mortality, and detailed complication rates were not captured. Preoperative chemotherapy data was also significantly missing.
  • Patient-Reported Outcomes: Patient-reported quality of life outcomes were not included.

Future work could focus on incorporating patient-reported outcomes, standardizing data collection, and further investigating the specific mechanisms by which surgeon volume and minimally invasive techniques contribute to high-quality outcomes. The study also supports the continued centralisation of complex oncology services and the development of robust quality assurance programs.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this registry study of patients treated with surgical excision of the urinary bladder for bladder cancer, we report that patients treated by a surgeon with a higher annual operative volume and a minimally invasive approach were associated with the receipt of high-quality surgery. Patients treated with high-quality surgery were more likely to be discharged alive following surgery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2021defining,
  author = {Wei Shen Tan and Jeffrey J. Leow and Maya Marchese and Ashwin Sridhar and Giles Hellawell and Matthew Mossanen and Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh and Sarah Fowler and Alexandra Colquhoun and Jo Cresswell and James W.F. Catto and Quoc‐Dien Trinh and John D. Kelly},
  title = {{Defining Factors Associated with High-quality Surgery Following Radical Cystectomy: Analysis of the British Association of Urological Surgeons Cystectomy Audit}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.euros.2021.08.005},
}
Figure