Deep nonparametric regression on approximate manifolds: Nonasymptotic error bounds with polynomial prefactors

Yuling Jiao, Guohao Shen, Yuanyuan Lin, Jian Huang

TL;DR

This paper provides theoretical guarantees for deep neural networks performing nonparametric regression, showing they can overcome the "curse of dimensionality" when data lies on or near low-dimensional structures. Crucially, their error bounds depend polynomially, not exponentially, on the data's ambient dimension, offering a significant theoretical advantage for high-dimensional problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In statistical modeling, nonparametric regression aims to estimate a complex, unknown relationship between input features (predictors) and an output (response) without assuming a specific functional form. A major challenge, especially with high-dimensional data (many predictors), is the "curse of dimensionality," where the amount of data needed to achieve good performance grows exponentially with the number of predictors. This paper tackles this by investigating how deep neural networks (DNNs) can mitigate this curse, particularly when the underlying data has a simpler, low-dimensional structure (e.g., lying on or near a manifold). Existing theoretical results often show that DNNs can achieve optimal rates but with prefactors that grow exponentially with the ambient dimension, rendering them impractical for high-dimensional settings. This work aims to derive error bounds that depend polynomially on the ambient dimension, making DNNs more theoretically viable for such problems.

Methods

The authors derive non-asymptotic upper bounds for the prediction error of the empirical risk minimizer (ERM) using feedforward neural networks with ReLU activation. Their approach involves:

  • Novel Approximation Error Bound: They establish a new bound for approximating Hölder-smooth functions using ReLU networks. This bound is key because it features a prefactor that depends polynomially on the dimension, a significant improvement over existing exponential dependencies.
  • Stochastic and Approximation Error Decomposition: Following standard practice, they decompose the total error into stochastic (data-dependent) and approximation (model-dependent) errors. They then bound each component.
  • Manifold and Minkowski Dimension Assumptions: To alleviate the curse of dimensionality, they introduce assumptions about the data's support:
  • Approximate Low-Dimensional Manifold: Data lies near a low-dimensional manifold.
  • Exact Low-Dimensional Manifold: Data lies precisely on a low-dimensional manifold.
  • Low Minkowski Dimension: A more general notion of dimensionality.
  • Network Structure Analysis: They explicitly analyze how network parameters (depth, width, size) influence the error bounds and introduce a "network relative efficiency" metric to compare different network architectures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The theoretical analysis focuses on general assumptions about the data distribution and the structure of the predictor space.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Polynomial Prefactors are Possible: The most significant insight is demonstrating that DNNs can achieve optimal nonparametric regression rates with error bounds whose prefactors depend polynomially on the ambient dimension, not exponentially. This is a crucial theoretical breakthrough for high-dimensional data.
  • Low-Dimensional Structure is Key: The paper strongly suggests that the "curse of dimensionality" can be circumvented if the data's support is concentrated on or near a low-dimensional manifold or set. This aligns with observations in many real-world high-dimensional datasets (e.g., images).
  • Deep vs. Wide Networks: The analysis provides quantitative insights into the trade-offs between network depth and width. They propose a "network relative efficiency" metric, suggesting that deeper networks can be more sample-efficient (achieve the same error with fewer parameters) than wider, shallower ones.
  • Flexibility in Network Design: The results offer guidance on designing network architectures, showing that optimal convergence rates can be achieved with various combinations of depth and width, not just a single "best" structure.

Key Results

  • Improved Approximation Error: A novel approximation error bound for Hölder-smooth functions is derived, with a prefactor depending polynomially on the dimension $d$, improving upon existing results with exponential dependence.
  • Manifold Assumption Benefits: Under approximate or exact low-dimensional manifold assumptions, the convergence rate improves from $O(n^{-2\beta/(2\beta+d)})$ to rates dependent on the manifold's intrinsic dimension ($d_m$) or Minkowski dimension ($d^*$), significantly mitigating the curse of dimensionality.
  • Polynomial Dependence on Ambient Dimension: The derived non-asymptotic error bounds for deep ReLU networks have prefactors that depend polynomially on the ambient dimension $d$, a key theoretical improvement.
  • Network Relative Efficiency: A metric is introduced to quantify the efficiency of different network structures, showing that deep networks can be more efficient than wide ones in terms of sample complexity. For example, deep networks are shown to be twice as efficient as wide networks in terms of their relative efficiency metric.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimal Rate Under Approximate Manifold: The paper notes that the optimal convergence rate under the approximate manifold assumption remains unknown. It's unclear if the dependence on the ambient dimension $d$ can be fully removed in this setting.
  • Prefactor Optimization: While polynomial prefactors are achieved, finding the absolute "best" prefactors for the error bounds remains an open challenge.
  • Generalization to Other Problems: The authors suggest that extending these results to other problems like density estimation, conditional density estimation, and generative learning would be valuable future work.
  • Optimization Challenges: The paper acknowledges that deeper networks can be more challenging to optimize in practice, a practical aspect not fully addressed by the theoretical analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the properties of nonparametric least squares regression using deep neural networks. We derive nonasymptotic upper bounds for the excess risk of the empirical risk minimizer of feedforward deep neural regression. Our error bounds achieve minimax optimal rate and improve over the existing ones in the sense that they depend polynomially on the dimension of the predictor, instead of exponentially on dimension. We show that the neural regression estimator can circumvent the curse of dimensionality under the assumption that the predictor is supported on an approximate low-dimensional manifold or a set with low Minkowski dimension. We also establish the optimal convergence rate under the exact manifold support assumption. We investigate how the prediction error of the neural regression estimator depends on the structure of neural networks and propose a notion of network relative efficiency between two types of neural networks, which provides a quantitative measure for evaluating the relative merits of different network structures. To establish these results, we derive a novel approximation error bound for the Hölder smooth functions using ReLU activated neural networks, which may be of independent interest. Our results are derived under weaker assumptions on the data distribution and the neural network structure than those in the existing literature.
BibTeX
@article{jiao2023deep,
  author = {Yuling Jiao and Guohao Shen and Yuanyuan Lin and Jian Huang},
  title = {{Deep nonparametric regression on approximate manifolds: Nonasymptotic error bounds with polynomial prefactors}},
  journal = {The Annals of Statistics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1214/23-aos2266},
}
Figure