Deep Hypergraph Neural Networks with Tight Framelets

Ming Li, Yujie Fang, Yi Wang, Han Feng, Yongchun Gu, Lu Bai, Pietro Liò

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "oversmoothing" problem in deep hypergraph neural networks (HGNNs), where node representations become indistinguishable with increasing network depth. They propose FrameHGNN, a novel framework that uses "tight framelets" to decompose hypergraph signals into low-pass and high-pass components, allowing for more nuanced feature extraction and preserving node distinguishability. FrameHGNN significantly outperforms existing methods on node classification tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness in mitigating oversmoothing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional neural networks often struggle with complex, high-order relationships between entities. Hypergraphs offer a powerful way to model these interactions, going beyond simple pairwise connections. However, just like their graph-based counterparts (Graph Neural Networks or GNNs), deep Hypergraph Neural Networks (HGNNs) suffer from a phenomenon called "oversmoothing." This means that as you add more layers to the network, the representations of individual nodes start to blend together, losing their unique characteristics. This homogenization severely degrades the model's performance, especially in tasks like node classification. While oversmoothing in GNNs has been extensively studied, its specific causes and solutions in the context of hypergraphs are less understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by theoretically analyzing why oversmoothing occurs in HGNNs and proposing a novel architecture, FrameHGNN, to combat it.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper lies in the development of FrameHGNN, a deep HGNN architecture that leverages tight framelets for hypergraph convolutions.

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological contributions:

  • Theoretical Analysis of Oversmoothing: The authors provide a theoretical investigation into the causes of oversmoothing in deep HGNNs. They demonstrate that both low-pass and high-pass components of hypergraph signals are crucial for effective learning. Their analysis suggests that a spectral-based hypergraph convolution that incorporates both types of filters can help mitigate oversmoothing.
  • Framelet-Based Hypergraph Convolution: FrameHGNN introduces a novel hypergraph convolution layer that utilizes tight framelet transforms. These transforms decompose the hypergraph signal into multiple frequency components (low-pass and high-pass). This allows the network to capture both coarse-grained (low-pass) and fine-grained (high-pass) information from the hypergraph structure.
  • Multifrequency Channels: By explicitly incorporating both low-pass and high-pass filters, FrameHGNN creates "multifrequency channels" for information processing. This richer representation helps preserve node distinguishability.
  • Integration with Deep GNN Strategies: To build deep networks, FrameHGNN incorporates established techniques from deep GNNs, such as initial residual connections and identity mappings. These mechanisms help preserve information from earlier layers and prevent its degradation as it passes through deeper layers.
  • Approximation Techniques: To handle the computational complexity of eigendecomposition for large hypergraphs, the authors employ an approximation approach using Chebyshev polynomials, similar to prior work.

Datasets

The paper evaluates FrameHGNN on eight publicly available benchmark datasets:

  • Cora
  • CiteSeer
  • Pubmed
  • Cora-CA (cocitation and coauthorship networks)
  • Senate (legislative cosponsorship networks)
  • House (legislative cosponsorship networks)
  • NTU2012
  • ModelNet40

These datasets cover a variety of applications, including recommendation systems, social network analysis, and cross-modal retrieval. The datasets were split into training, validation, and test sets with a 50%/25%/25% ratio, and early stopping was used to prevent overfitting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Dual Nature of Hypergraph Signals: A crucial insight is that oversmoothing in HGNNs isn't just about losing information, but about losing the balance between different types of information. Both low-pass (global structure) and high-pass (local details) components are essential, and their interplay is key to preventing node representations from collapsing.
  • Framelets as a Natural Fit for Hypergraphs: Tight framelets, with their ability to decompose signals into different frequency bands, are a theoretically sound and practically effective tool for capturing the rich, multi-scale information present in hypergraphs.
  • High-Pass Filters as a "Noise" Source (Sometimes): The ablation study reveals that while high-pass filters are generally beneficial, on certain datasets (like ModelNet40), their exclusion actually improves performance. This suggests that high-pass features can sometimes introduce noise or irrelevant details, and the model's ability to selectively use them is a sign of its adaptability.
  • Deep HGNNs Need More Than Just More Layers: The paper reinforces the idea that simply stacking more layers in HGNNs is counterproductive due to oversmoothing. Instead, architectural innovations that preserve feature diversity, like FrameHGNN's multifrequency approach, are necessary for building truly deep and effective hypergraph models.

Key Results

  • State-of-the-Art Performance: FrameHGNN outperforms seven of the eight baseline models on node classification tasks across the tested datasets.
  • Significant Accuracy Gains: The model achieves notable accuracy improvements, with gains of over 1% on several datasets and a nearly 3% gain on the Senate dataset.
  • Effective Oversmoothing Mitigation: Visualizations (Figure 5) and accuracy trends (Figure 3) clearly show that FrameHGNN maintains distinct node embeddings and higher accuracy with increasing layers, unlike other models that suffer from oversmoothing. For instance, on the Senate dataset, FrameHGNN achieves a 2% higher accuracy with 32 layers compared to just 1 layer.
  • Ablation Study Confirms Contributions: The ablation study demonstrates that integrating both low-pass and high-pass components in FrameHGNN significantly boosts performance, supporting the theoretical findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dataset-Specific Feature Importance: The paper notes that the optimal balance between low-pass and high-pass components is data-dependent. While FrameHGNN's architecture implicitly handles this, future work could explore more explicit adaptive mechanisms for balancing these spectral components.
  • Generalization to Other Domains: The authors suggest extending FrameHGNN to other learning paradigms, such as contrastive learning or continual learning, and to more complex high-order network structures like simplicial or cell complexes.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: While the paper analyzes the sensitivity of key hyperparameters (α, γ, λ), further exploration into their optimal selection across a wider range of datasets could be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025deep,
  author = {Ming Li and Yujie Fang and Yi Wang and Han Feng and Yongchun Gu and Lu Bai and Pietro Liò},
  title = {{Deep Hypergraph Neural Networks with Tight Framelets}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v39i17.34023},
}

Loading related content...

Figure