Abstract: Time-resolved single-molecule biophysical experiments yield data that contain a wealth of dynamic information, in addition to the equilibrium distributions derived from histograms of the time series. In typical force spectroscopic setups the molecule is connected via linkers to a readout device, forming a mechanically coupled dynamic network. Deconvolution of equilibrium distributions, filtering out the influence of the linkers, is a straightforward and common practice. We have developed an analogous dynamic deconvolution theory for the more challenging task of extracting kinetic properties of individual components in networks of arbitrary complexity and topology. Our method determines the intrinsic linear response functions of a given object in the network, describing the power spectrum of conformational fluctuations. The practicality of our approach is demonstrated for the particular case of a protein linked via DNA handles to two optically trapped beads at constant stretching force, which we mimic through Brownian dynamics simulations. Each well in the protein free energy landscape (corresponding to folded, unfolded, or possibly intermediate states) will have its own characteristic equilibrium fluctuations. The associated linear response function is rich in physical content, because it depends both on the shape of the well and its diffusivity-a measure of the internal friction arising from such processes as the transient breaking and reformation of bonds in the protein structure. Starting from the autocorrelation functions of the equilibrium bead fluctuations measured in this force clamp setup, we show how an experimentalist can accurately extract the state-dependent protein diffusivity using a straightforward two-step procedure.
Introduction: The Challenge of Single-Molecule Dynamics
In single-molecule biophysics, researchers aim to observe the real-time dynamics of proteins as they fold and unfold. A common experimental setup involves optical tweezers, where a protein is tethered between two double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) "handles" attached to microscopic beads held in laser traps. While these setups provide high-resolution spatial data, the recorded signal—the movement of the beads—is a convolution of the protein's intrinsic motion with the mechanical properties of the entire apparatus.
The beads and DNA handles possess their own mass, drag, and elasticity, acting as a complex mechanical filter that dampens high-frequency fluctuations and distorts the power spectrum of the protein's motion. While "deconvolving" static equilibrium distributions (like free energy landscapes) is standard practice, extracting dynamic properties—such as internal friction and diffusivity—remains a significant challenge due to the coupled nature of the system.
Methodology: Mechanical Networks and Linear Response
The researchers addressed this by developing a "dynamic deconvolution" theory based on Linear Response Theory. They conceptualize the experimental setup as a dynamic mechanical network where each component (bead, handle, protein) is characterized by a frequency-dependent response function, $J(\omega)$, which describes its reaction to an oscillatory force.
Much like electrical circuits composed of resistors and capacitors, these mechanical components follow specific "convolution rules" for series and parallel arrangements. The authors derived mathematical frameworks to combine these response functions, allowing for the isolation of a single component's properties.
The proposed "two-step" experimental procedure involves:
- Calibration: Measuring the system without the protein (beads and handles only) to characterize the "instrumental" response.
- Production: Measuring the full system with the protein. By applying the convolution rules, the known instrumental response is subtracted to isolate the protein’s intrinsic response function.
Crucially, the method leverages the Fluctuation-Dissipation Theorem, which relates equilibrium fluctuations (measured via autocorrelation functions) to the linear response. This allows experimentalists to extract dynamic information without needing to apply external oscillatory forces.
Validation via Brownian Dynamics
To validate the theory, the authors employed Brownian dynamics simulations of a protein-DNA-bead system. This "toy model" provided a ground truth for physical parameters like protein diffusivity and stiffness, which are typically hidden in real-world experiments.
The results demonstrated that the method could accurately recover the protein's mobility ($\mu_P$) and spring constant ($k_P$) to within 6% of their true values. Furthermore, the approach proved robust even when analyzing complex energy landscapes, such as double-well potentials representing folded and unfolded states. By analyzing fluctuations within each state separately, the researchers could extract state-specific internal friction.
Key Insights: Internal Friction and System Damping
A primary insight of this work is the ability to quantify internal friction. The isolated protein response function, $J^P_{ee}(\omega)$, reveals the energy dissipated as internal bonds break and reform during conformational changes. Without deconvolution, the damping effects of the handles and beads shift the system's characteristic frequencies to lower values, potentially leading researchers to misinterpret system-wide slowing as an intrinsic protein property.
Limitations and Future Outlook
The current theory relies on a linearity assumption, which is highly accurate for fluctuations within a stable state (e.g., a folded protein vibrating in its well). However, large-scale transitions between states are inherently non-linear. While the authors mitigate this by analyzing states individually, a unified non-linear deconvolution theory remains a goal for future research.
Additionally, real-world experiments may encounter "colored" noise or complex hydrodynamic interactions. The next logical step is applying this "two-step" recipe to existing experimental data from optical tweezers or Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) to refine our understanding of protein kinetics.
Conclusion
This dynamic deconvolution framework provides a powerful tool for biophysicists to strip away the mechanical "noise" of their instruments. By treating experimental components as a network of linear response functions, it is now possible to reveal the true, intrinsic kinetic properties of single molecules with unprecedented accuracy.
Summary updated