Decadal trends in global CO emissions as seen by MOPITT

Yi Yin, Frédéric Chevallier, Philippe Ciais, Grégoire Broquet, Audrey Fortems‐Cheiney, Isabelle Pison, Marielle Saunois

TL;DR

This study uses an atmospheric inversion model to analyze decadal trends in global carbon monoxide (CO) emissions from 2002-2011. The findings reveal a significant global decrease in CO emissions, primarily driven by reductions in both anthropogenic fuel combustion and biomass burning, contradicting some existing emission inventories. This work highlights the power of combining satellite and surface data for a more accurate understanding of atmospheric pollutant sources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Observations from both ground-based stations and satellites have consistently shown a decline in atmospheric carbon monoxide (CO) concentrations over the past decade. However, current "bottom-up" emission inventories, which estimate emissions based on activity data and emission factors, have struggled to fully explain this observed trend. Some inventories even suggest an increase in CO emissions in certain regions, creating a discrepancy. This paper aims to resolve this by using an "atmospheric inversion" approach, which uses observed atmospheric concentrations to infer the most likely sources and sinks of CO, thereby providing a more direct estimate of emission trends.

Methods

The core of this research is an atmospheric inversion system called PYVAR-SACS. This system simultaneously assimilates satellite CO column data from the MOPITT instrument (version 6) and surface measurements of methane (CH4) and methyl chloroform (MCF). Methane and methyl chloroform are included because they are influenced by the same atmospheric oxidant (hydroxyl radical, OH) that also controls CO's lifetime, allowing the model to better constrain OH concentrations. The inversion model then adjusts the estimated CO emissions, as well as the chemical production and destruction rates of CO, to best match the observed atmospheric concentrations. This approach allows for a more robust attribution of the observed CO trends to specific sources and sinks, going beyond the limitations of prior emission inventories.

Datasets

  • MOPITT v6 satellite CO total column retrievals: This is the primary satellite dataset used for assimilation, providing a long and consistent record of CO concentrations in the atmosphere.
  • Surface in situ measurements of CH4 and MCF: Data from various global networks are used to constrain the atmospheric chemistry and the OH sink.
  • Surface in situ measurements of CO: Used for independent cross-evaluation of the inversion results.
  • OMI satellite formaldehyde (CH2O) column retrievals: Used for independent evaluation of the atmospheric source of CO, though not assimilated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Satellite data reveals a global CO emission decline: The study provides strong evidence that global CO emissions have been decreasing, a finding that challenges some existing emission inventories.
  • Inversion is key to reconciling observations and inventories: The atmospheric inversion approach proves crucial in bridging the gap between observed atmospheric CO trends and estimates from bottom-up inventories.
  • Technology improvements are likely driving emission reductions: The significant inferred decrease in CO emissions, particularly in regions like China, suggests that technological advancements in combustion are outweighing increases in fuel consumption.
  • Biomass burning is a significant contributor to CO emission trends: Reductions in biomass burning emissions are identified as a key factor in the overall decline of CO emissions, especially in regions like Australia and Southeast Asia.

Key Results

  • Global CO emissions decreased by 2.3% per year: This is more than double the trend estimated by prior emission inventories (-1.0% yr⁻¹).
  • Significant emission decreases observed in key regions:
    • Western Europe: -4.0% yr⁻¹
    • United States: -4.6% yr⁻¹
    • East Asia: -1.2% yr⁻¹
    • Australia: -5.3% yr⁻¹
    • Indonesia: -6.7% yr⁻¹
  • Contradiction with China's emission trends: While bottom-up inventories suggested a 2% yr⁻¹ increase in China, the inversion inferred a significant decrease of 1.1% yr⁻¹.
  • Atmospheric burden of CO decreased by 10% per decade: This is twice the decrease suggested by prior emissions.
  • CO chemical sources showed little trend: This suggests that the observed CO decline is primarily due to reduced emissions rather than changes in chemical production.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited OH resolution: OH concentrations were optimized over six large regions, potentially missing sub-regional trends that could influence CO budgets.
  • MCF constraint weakening: The decreasing concentrations of methyl chloroform in recent years might limit its ability to constrain OH in the inversion.
  • CH2O not assimilated: While CH2O retrievals were used for evaluation, they were not assimilated due to limited temporal coverage. Assimilating CH2O and other chemically connected species could further improve the estimation of regional CO budgets and chemical sources/sinks.
  • Model-data misfit in some regions: While the inversion generally improved model-data fit, some regions showed increased misfits, possibly due to challenges in modeling vertical CO profiles or representativeness issues.

The authors suggest that future work could focus on incorporating more detailed regional OH information and assimilating additional chemical species to refine the understanding of CO sources and sinks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Negative trends of carbon monoxide (CO) concentrations are observed in the recent decade by both surface measurements and satellite retrievals over many regions of the globe, but they are not well explained by current emission inventories. Here, we analyse the observed CO concentration decline with an atmospheric inversion that simultaneously optimizes the two main CO sources (surface emissions and atmospheric hydrocarbon oxidations) and the main CO sink (atmospheric hydroxyl radical OH oxidation). Satellite CO column retrievals from Measurements of Pollution in the Troposphere (MOPITT), version 6, and surface observations of methane and methyl chloroform mole fractions are assimilated jointly for the period covering 2002–2011. Compared to the model simulation prescribed with prior emission inventories, trends in the optimized CO concentrations show better agreement with that of independent surface in situ measurements. At the global scale, the atmospheric inversion primarily interprets the CO concentration decline as a decrease in the CO emissions (−2.3 % yr−1), more than twice the negative trend estimated by the prior emission inventories (−1.0 % yr−1). The spatial distribution of the inferred decrease in CO emissions indicates contributions from western Europe (−4.0 % yr−1), the United States (−4.6 % yr−1) and East Asia (−1.2 % yr−1), where anthropogenic fuel combustion generally dominates the overall CO emissions, and also from Australia (−5.3 % yr−1), the Indo-China Peninsula (−5.6 % yr−1), Indonesia (−6.7 % y−1), and South America (−3 % yr−1), where CO emissions are mostly due to biomass burning. In contradiction with the bottom-up inventories that report an increase of 2 % yr−1 over China during the study period, a significant emission decrease of 1.1 % yr−1 is inferred by the inversion. A large decrease in CO emission factors due to technology improvements would outweigh the increase in carbon fuel combustions and may explain this decrease. Independent satellite formaldehyde (CH2O) column retrievals confirm the absence of large-scale trends in the atmospheric source of CO. However, it should be noted that the CH2O retrievals are not assimilated and OH concentrations are optimized at a very large scale in this study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yin2015decadal,
  author = {Yi Yin and Frédéric Chevallier and Philippe Ciais and Grégoire Broquet and Audrey Fortems‐Cheiney and Isabelle Pison and Marielle Saunois},
  title = {{Decadal trends in global CO emissions as seen by MOPITT}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-15-13433-2015},
}
Figure