Day-Ahead Wind Power Forecasting Using a Two-Stage Hybrid Modeling Approach Based on SCADA and Meteorological Information, and Evaluating the Impact of Input-Data Dependency on Forecasting Accuracy

Dehua Zheng, Min Shi, Yifeng Wang, Abinet Tesfaye Eseye, Jianhua ZhangEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel two-stage hybrid model for day-ahead wind power forecasting, combining Hilbert-Huang Transform (HHT), Genetic Algorithms (GA), and Artificial Neural Networks (ANN). This approach significantly improves forecasting accuracy by effectively integrating meteorological data and SCADA records, outperforming existing methods and demonstrating the importance of comprehensive input data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of wind power into electricity grids presents a significant challenge due to the inherent intermittency and volatility of wind speed. This uncertainty complicates grid management for Transmission System Operators (TSOs) and Distribution System Operators (DSOs), impacting grid stability and efficiency. Accurate day-ahead wind power forecasting is crucial for reliable grid operation, enabling better planning for power dispatch, resource allocation, and market participation. Existing forecasting methods often struggle with data gaps or fail to fully leverage both physical (meteorological) and statistical (SCADA) data sources.

Methods

The core of this research is a novel two-stage hybrid forecasting model:

  • Stage 1: Wind Speed Forecasting: This stage uses Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) meteorological data (wind speed, direction, air pressure, temperature, humidity) as input. The data is first decomposed into subseries using the Hilbert-Huang Transform (HHT) to capture complex non-linear patterns. An Artificial Neural Network (ANN), specifically a Multi-Layer Feedforward (MLFF) network, is then trained to predict wind speed at the turbine hub height. To optimize the ANN's performance, Genetic Algorithms (GA) are employed to tune the network's weights and biases, aiming to minimize the mean squared error.
  • Stage 2: Wind Power Forecasting: This stage takes the forecasted wind speed from Stage 1 and uses it, along with historical SCADA wind speed and power data, to predict the actual wind power output. Similar to Stage 1, HHT is used for data decomposition, GA for ANN optimization, and ANN for mapping wind speed to power. The final forecasted wind power is obtained by reconstructing the HHT-decomposed subseries.

The paper also investigates the impact of input data selection on forecasting accuracy by testing various combinations of meteorological variables.

Datasets

The study utilized a one-year dataset (May 2014 to April 2015) from a microgrid wind farm in Beijing, China. This included:

  • SCADA Data: Ten-minute interval records of actual wind speed and power output.
  • NWP Data: Fifteen-minute interval meteorological forecasts from the WRF model, including wind speed, wind direction, air pressure, air temperature, and humidity.

The dataset was split into 85% for training and 15% for validation. The paper also compares its approach against models using different input data subsets to analyze data dependency.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HHT for Signal Decomposition: The Hilbert-Huang Transform proves highly effective in decomposing complex, non-stationary time series data (like wind speed and power) into simpler, more manageable intrinsic mode functions (IMFs). This decomposition allows ANNs to learn more effectively from the underlying patterns.
  • GA for ANN Optimization: Using Genetic Algorithms to optimize ANN weights and biases is a robust approach that helps avoid local minima often encountered with traditional backpropagation methods, leading to better generalization and accuracy.
  • Two-Stage Hybridization: The two-stage approach, first predicting wind speed and then power, is more effective than a single-stage model. This separation allows for specialized optimization at each step.
  • Importance of Comprehensive Input Data: The study clearly demonstrates that including a wider range of meteorological variables (wind speed, direction, air pressure, temperature, and humidity) significantly improves forecasting accuracy compared to using fewer variables. This highlights the value of integrating physical and statistical data.
  • Robustness to Data Gaps: While not explicitly tested for missing data in this study, the paper suggests that hybrid approaches incorporating NWP data can offer a practical solution for wind farms with SCADA data gaps.

Key Results

The proposed HHT-GA-ANN model achieved superior forecasting performance compared to benchmark (Smart Persistence) and other AI-based approaches (BP-ANN, GA-ANN, Wavelet-GA-ANN).

  • MAPE: The average daily Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) was 5.54%, representing a significant improvement over other methods. For instance, it was 65.65% better than Smart Persistence.
  • NMAE: The average Normalized Mean Absolute Error (NMAE) was 0.48% of the installed capacity.
  • Forecast Skill (FS): The model achieved a high average forecast skill of 42.67%, indicating its ability to outperform a simple persistence forecast.
  • Input Data Impact: Using all five meteorological variables (wind speed, direction, air temperature, air pressure, and humidity) resulted in the best MAPE (5.54%), showing a 5.78% improvement over using only wind speed.
  • Computational Time: The model's average computation time was approximately 30 seconds on a standard personal computer.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper focuses on day-ahead forecasting; its performance for longer-term forecasts is not discussed.
  • While the approach is suggested as a solution for SCADA data gaps, the paper does not explicitly demonstrate this capability with missing data scenarios.
  • The study uses data from a single wind turbine unit; its scalability to larger wind farms with multiple turbines might require further investigation.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that the model can be periodically retrained with new input data, implying a need for continuous learning and adaptation.
  • Further research could explore the application of this model to larger wind farms and investigate its performance under various weather conditions and data availability scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

The power generated by wind generators is usually associated with uncertainties, due to the intermittency of wind speed and other weather variables. This creates a big challenge for transmission system operators (TSOs) and distribution system operators (DSOs) in terms of connecting, controlling and managing power networks with high-penetration wind energy. Hence, in these power networks, accurate wind power forecasts are essential for their reliable and efficient operation. They support TSOs and DSOs in enhancing the control and management of the power network. In this paper, a novel two-stage hybrid approach based on the combination of the Hilbert-Huang transform (HHT), genetic algorithm (GA) and artificial neural network (ANN) is proposed for day-ahead wind power forecasting. The approach is composed of two stages. The first stage utilizes numerical weather prediction (NWP) meteorological information to predict wind speed at the exact site of the wind farm. The second stage maps actual wind speed vs. power characteristics recorded by SCADA. Then, the wind speed forecast in the first stage for the future day is fed to the second stage to predict the future day’s wind power. Comparative selection of input-data parameter sets for the forecasting model and impact analysis of input-data dependency on forecasting accuracy have also been studied. The proposed approach achieves significant forecasting accuracy improvement compared with three other artificial intelligence-based forecasting approaches and a benchmark model using the smart persistence method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2017day,
  author = {Dehua Zheng and Min Shi and Yifeng Wang and Abinet Tesfaye Eseye and Jianhua Zhang},
  title = {{Day-Ahead Wind Power Forecasting Using a Two-Stage Hybrid Modeling Approach Based on SCADA and Meteorological Information, and Evaluating the Impact of Input-Data Dependency on Forecasting Accuracy}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10121988},
}
Figure