Abstract
As autonomous systems become increasingly complex and "taskable," the gap between their internal logic and human understanding poses significant safety risks. This paper presents a framework for a Personalized AI Assessment Module (AAM) designed to interrogate black-box AI systems. By utilizing a strategic query-response interface, the AAM constructs human-understandable models of an AI’s capabilities and operational boundaries. The framework emphasizes data efficiency, personalization through user-specific vocabularies, and interpretability, enabling non-expert users to safely deploy and oversee complex autonomous agents.
Introduction
The deployment of taskable AI systems—agents capable of executing complex sequences of actions to achieve high-level goals—in real-world environments has outpaced our ability to understand their internal decision-making processes. Most modern AI systems operate as "black boxes," where their internal representations do not align with human concepts. This misalignment can lead to "unintended side effects" or accidents when a user incorrectly assumes an agent's capabilities or safety limits.
To address this, there is a critical need for a "manual" or capability model that is personalized to the user's vocabulary and derived efficiently without requiring exhaustive observation. This research introduces the Personalized AI Assessment Module (AAM), a system that acts as an intermediary between a human user and a black-box AI.
Methodology
The AAM framework treats the AI system as an agent within a simulator, rather than attempting to analyze its source code directly. The assessment process is driven by several key technical components:
Minimal Query-Response Interface
The AAM interacts with the AI through a structured interface. It sends queries (e.g., "Can you achieve state X starting from state Y?") and receives responses based on the AI's performance in a simulated environment.
Interrogation Policies and Top-Down Inference
Rather than random sampling, the AAM treats query generation as a planning problem. It iteratively selects the most informative next question based on previous interactions. To manage the combinatorial complexity of potential models, the system employs a top-down inference approach. It tests abstract models first; if an abstraction is inconsistent with the AI's response, the AAM can prune an entire class of refined models, significantly accelerating the learning process.
Capability Discovery and Vocabulary Alignment
The AAM observes low-level state transitions and clusters them into high-level "capabilities" (e.g., "navigating a room"). These capabilities are then mapped to the user’s preferred "concept vocabulary," ensuring the final model is interpretable to the specific end-user.
Experimental Evaluation
The framework was evaluated using PDDL (Planning Domain Definition Language) models and simulated environments to generate behavioral traces.
Algorithmic Performance
- Efficiency: The Agent Interrogation Algorithm (AIA) demonstrated faster convergence to a correct model compared to existing state-of-the-art methods like FAMA.
- Stochastic Environments: The Query-based Autonomous Capability Estimation (QACE) module successfully derived models in uncertain environments with higher sample efficiency than baselines like GLIB.
- Adaptability: The DAAISy (Differential Assessment) algorithm allowed for incremental updates to the capability model as the AI evolved, avoiding the need for full reassessment.
Human-Centric Assessment
A user study was conducted to compare the effectiveness of AAM-generated descriptions against raw primitive action sequences. Participants using the high-level capability descriptions were able to predict AI behavior more accurately and significantly faster than those viewing low-level data.
Discussion and Future Work
While the AAM framework provides a robust path toward interpretable AI, several challenges remain. Current models largely assume "fully observable" environments, necessitating expansion into partially observable settings. Furthermore, the quality of the assessment is dependent on the richness of the user-provided "concept vocabulary."
Future research aims to integrate this assessment framework with systems like JEDAI to develop "Level II assistive AI." Such systems would not only perform tasks but proactively assist users in understanding and managing the complexities of robotic autonomy.
Summary updated