Data-driven subspace predictive control of adaptive optics for high-contrast imaging

Sebastiaan Y. Haffert, Jared R. Males, Laird M. Close, Kyle Van Gorkom, Joseph D. Long, Alexander D. Hedglen, Olivier Guyon, Lauren Schatz, Maggie Kautz, Jennifer Lumbres, Alex Rodack, Justin Knight, He Sun, Kevin FogartyJournal of Astronomical Telescopes Instruments and Systems 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel data-driven adaptive optics (AO) controller that significantly improves high-contrast imaging for exoplanet detection. By predicting atmospheric disturbances in real-time, it achieves contrast improvements of over two orders of magnitude in lab experiments, overcoming a key limitation in current astronomical instruments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ground-based telescopes are increasingly capable of directly imaging exoplanets, but a major hurdle is distinguishing faint planets from the overwhelming glare of their host stars. Adaptive optics (AO) systems are crucial for sharpening telescope images by correcting atmospheric distortions. However, the inherent delay in traditional AO systems (servo-lag) limits their effectiveness, especially for the small angular separations where exoplanets are expected. This delay means the system can only react to past atmospheric conditions, not anticipate future ones. This paper tackles this servo-lag problem by developing a predictive control strategy that learns and forecasts atmospheric changes to proactively correct them, thereby enhancing contrast and enabling the detection of fainter exoplanets.

Methods

The core of this work is the Data-Driven Subspace Predictive Controller (DDSPC). Unlike traditional predictive control methods that rely on explicit physical models of the atmosphere, DDSPC is entirely data-driven. It uses a linear auto-regressive (AR) model to predict future wavefront sensor measurements based on past measurements and deformable mirror commands. This model is continuously updated in real-time using Recursive Least Squares (RLS) to adapt to non-stationary atmospheric conditions. A key innovation is that DDSPC operates in closed-loop, meaning it directly uses the measured wavefront errors and DM command changes without needing separate open-loop measurements for system identification. This allows it to work with non-linear wavefront sensors like the Pyramid Wavefront Sensor (PWFS). The controller is implemented in a distributed manner, with each mode of the deformable mirror controlled independently, which is computationally efficient and amenable to parallel processing on GPUs.

Datasets

The paper uses simulated atmospheric turbulence data for training and evaluation. Specifically, it employs Kolmogorov phase screens generated using the HCIPy package to mimic atmospheric disturbances. For lab verification, data was collected from the MagAO-X instrument, which includes measurements from a Pyramid Wavefront Sensor (PWFS) and a 97-actuator woofer DM. The data was split into training (1500 samples) and validation (500 samples) sets for deriving the reconstruction matrix.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data-driven prediction is sufficient: The DDSPC demonstrates that accurate prediction of atmospheric disturbances for AO control can be achieved using purely data-driven methods, without needing complex physical models.
  • Closed-loop operation is a game-changer: Operating directly in closed-loop simplifies the system, avoids the need for pseudo-open loop reconstructions, and enables compatibility with non-linear wavefront sensors.
  • Real-time adaptation is crucial: The use of RLS for online model updates allows the controller to effectively handle non-stationary atmospheric conditions, a significant challenge for many AO systems.
  • Distributed control scales well: Controlling each mode of the deformable mirror independently makes the DDSPC computationally feasible for high-order AO systems and readily adaptable to GPU acceleration.
  • Contrast improvement is the primary benefit: While Strehl improvement is modest, the DDSPC's main impact is a dramatic increase in raw contrast, directly enabling the detection of fainter exoplanets.

Key Results

  • Simulations: DDSPC achieved an improvement of more than 2 orders of magnitude in contrast in simulations for both stationary and non-stationary turbulence.
  • Lab Experiments (MagAO-X): The DDSPC demonstrated a contrast improvement of a factor of 10 to 20 for low wind speeds and more than two orders of magnitude for high wind speeds.
  • Stability: Nyquist plots confirmed the stability of the DDSPC controller across a wide range of power-law disturbances and parameter choices.
  • Learning Rate: The DDSPC exhibits a learning rate that scales as 1/√t, indicating continuous improvement over time as it learns atmospheric correlations.
  • Robustness: The controller showed robustness to non-linearities in the PWFS and handled sudden changes in wind speed and direction effectively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While RLS is more efficient than Kalman filters, applying DDSPC to high-order AO systems with thousands of modes remains computationally challenging. The paper proposes GPU acceleration and distributed implementations to address this.
  • Noise Handling: The current controller does not explicitly account for measurement noise, although it can handle noisy measurements. Future work could incorporate a filter to improve robustness against noise.
  • Spatial Coupling: For computational reasons, spatial correlations between modes were removed. Reintroducing spatial coupling could potentially further reduce noise effects, though at increased computational cost.
  • Realistic Wind Models: While simulations used frozen-flow turbulence, future work could benefit from more realistic wind models with more temporal structure.
  • On-Sky Demonstration: An on-sky demonstration of DDSPC with MagAO-X is planned, which will be a crucial step towards its practical application in exoplanet detection.

Summary updated

Abstract

The search for exoplanets is pushing adaptive optics (AO) systems on ground-based telescopes to their limits. One of the major limitations at small angular separations, exactly where exoplanets are predicted to be, is the servo-lag of the AO systems. The servo-lag error can be reduced with predictive control where the control is based on the future state of the atmospheric disturbance. We propose to use a linear data-driven integral predictive controller based on subspace methods that are updated in real time. The new controller only uses the measured wavefront errors and the changes in the deformable mirror commands, which allows for closed-loop operation without requiring pseudo-open loop reconstruction. This enables operation with non-linear wavefront sensors such as the pyramid wavefront sensor. We show that the proposed controller performs nearoptimal control in simulations for both stationary and non-stationary disturbances and that we are able to gain several orders of magnitude in raw contrast. The algorithm has been demonstrated in the lab with MagAO-X, where we gain more than two orders of magnitude in contrast.
BibTeX
@article{haffert2021data,
  author = {Sebastiaan Y. Haffert and Jared R. Males and Laird M. Close and Kyle Van Gorkom and Joseph D. Long and Alexander D. Hedglen and Olivier Guyon and Lauren Schatz and Maggie Kautz and Jennifer Lumbres and Alex Rodack and Justin Knight and He Sun and Kevin Fogarty},
  title = {{Data-driven subspace predictive control of adaptive optics for high-contrast imaging}},
  journal = {Journal of Astronomical Telescopes Instruments and Systems},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jatis.7.2.029001},
}
Figure