Data-Driven Control of Distributed Event-Triggered Network Systems

Xin Wang, Jian Sun, Gang Wang, Frank Allgöwer, Jie Chen

TL;DR

This paper introduces a way to control complex, interconnected systems (like power grids or robot swarms) without needing a mathematical model of their physics. By combining a novel distributed event-triggering strategy with data-driven stability analysis, the authors provide a method to co-design controllers and communication protocols that maintain stability while significantly reducing the amount of data sent over the network.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In Networked Control Systems (NCS), multiple subsystems exchange information over a shared communication channel to achieve a global goal. Traditionally, this is done via periodic sampling—sending updates at fixed time intervals. However, in large-scale systems, this "constant chatter" wastes bandwidth and energy.

Event-Triggered Systems (ETS) solve this by only transmitting data when a specific "event" (like a large state deviation) occurs. The catch? Designing these triggers usually requires an exact mathematical model (the $A$ and $B$ matrices) of the system. In the real world, systems are often too complex to model accurately, or their parameters change over time. This paper addresses the gap of how to design efficient, distributed event-triggered control for unknown discrete-time systems using only raw input-output data.

Methods

The authors propose a three-pronged approach:

  1. Distributed Dynamic ETS: They developed a new triggering law that uses both local state information and information from neighboring subsystems. Unlike "static" triggers, this one includes a "dynamic" variable ($\eta$) that acts as a flexible threshold, effectively allowing for longer intervals between transmissions without sacrificing stability.
  2. Data-Driven Parametrization: Instead of using physics equations, they use a recent breakthrough in control theory (based on Willems’ Fundamental Lemma) to represent the system using a collection of offline-collected state and input data. This allows them to account for noise in the measurements.
  3. Discrete-Time Looped-Functional: To prove the system won't crash (stability), they used a "looped-functional" mathematical framework. This is a sophisticated way to analyze stability in sampled-data systems that is less "conservative" (meaning it doesn't over-engineer the safety margins) than traditional Lyapunov methods.

The final "product" of their method is a set of Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMIs). For engineers, this is ideal because LMIs can be solved efficiently using standard optimization software to find the best controller gains and triggering parameters simultaneously.

Datasets

The paper evaluates the method using a simulated Network of Coupled Inverted Pendulums.

  • Setup: Three identical pendulums connected by springs.
  • Data Collection: They generated 200 offline measurements ($ \rho = 200 $) by applying random inputs to the system and recording the states, specifically adding random noise to simulate real-world sensor inaccuracies.
  • Comparison: They compared their data-driven results against a "model-based" version (where the physics are known) to see how much performance is lost when you don't have a model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic is Better than Static: The inclusion of the dynamic variable $\eta$ in the triggering condition is a "memory" mechanism. It allows the system to "wait" longer to send data if the previous states were stable, which is much more efficient than a fixed threshold.
  • Neighborly Advice: By incorporating the relative state information of neighbors into the trigger, the subsystems can stay synchronized with fewer total transmissions.
  • The "Data Tax": The authors show that data-driven control is inherently more "conservative" than model-based control. Because the controller doesn't know the exact physics, it has to be more "cautious," which can lead to slightly slower convergence (settling time) compared to a model-aware controller.
  • Noise Robustness: The framework explicitly includes a "noise bound" assumption, making it applicable to real-world hardware where sensors are never perfect.

Key Results

  • Communication Savings: In the pendulum simulation, the system only needed 109 transmissions out of 450 possible sampling instances to maintain stability.
  • Superiority over Decentralized Methods: The distributed strategy (using neighbor info) was compared to a decentralized one (local info only). The distributed version required significantly fewer transmissions (109 vs. 148) to achieve the same level of control.
  • Convergence: Despite the lack of a model and the presence of noise, all subsystem states successfully converged to zero, proving the efficacy of the co-design LMI approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: As the amount of collected data ($\rho$) increases, the size of the LMIs grows. For massive networks (thousands of nodes), this could become a computational bottleneck.
  • Global vs. Local Design: While the execution of the control is distributed, the design phase (solving the LMIs) currently requires global information about the network structure. The authors suggest that making the design phase fully distributed is a key next step.
  • Performance Guarantees: The current work focuses on stability. Future work aims to extend this to $L_2$-gain performance, which would provide guarantees on how well the system rejects continuous disturbances.

Summary updated

Abstract

The present paper deals with data-driven event-triggered control of a class of unknown discrete-time interconnected systems (a.k.a. network systems). To this end, we start by putting forth a novel distributed event-triggering transmission strategy based on periodic sampling, under which a model-based stability criterion for the closed-loop network system is derived, by leveraging a discrete-time looped-functional approach. Marrying the model-based criterion with a data-driven system representation recently developed in the literature, a purely data-driven stability criterion expressed in the form of linear matrix inequalities (LMIs) is established. Meanwhile, the data-driven stability criterion suggests a means for co-designing the event-triggering coefficient matrix and the feedback control gain matrix using only some offline collected state-input data. Finally, numerical results corroborate the efficacy of the proposed distributed data-driven event-triggered network system (ETS) in cutting off data transmissions and the co-design procedure.
BibTeX
@article{wang2023data,
  author = {Xin Wang and Jian Sun and Gang Wang and Frank Allgöwer and Jie Chen},
  title = {{Data-Driven Control of Distributed Event-Triggered Network Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE CAA J. Autom. Sinica},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=L0nryRXGhaS},
}

Loading related content...

Figure