Daisy-chain gene drives for the alteration of local populations

Charleston Noble, John Min, Jason Olejarz, Joanna Buchthal, Alejandro Chavez, Andrea L. Smidler, Erika A. DeBenedictis, George M. Church, Martin A. Nowak, Kevin M. Esvelt

TL;DR

This paper introduces "daisy-chain gene drives," a novel CRISPR-based system designed to alter local populations of organisms without the risk of uncontrolled global spread. By arranging genetic drive elements in a sequential "daisy chain," these systems can achieve desired genetic modifications locally while naturally self-exhausting over time, offering a safer and more ethically manageable approach to ecological engineering.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

CRISPR-based gene drives hold immense promise for tackling pressing ecological and public health challenges, such as eradicating disease vectors or controlling invasive species. However, their inherent self-propagating nature poses a significant risk of unintended and irreversible spread across geographical and political boundaries. This uncontrolled spread complicates ethical considerations, public acceptance, and the feasibility of conducting safe field trials. The paper addresses this critical challenge by proposing a gene drive system that can achieve potent local effects but is inherently designed to limit its own spread, thereby enabling more controlled and community-driven applications.

Methods

The core innovation presented is the "daisy-chain gene drive" system. Unlike standard gene drives that propagate indefinitely, a daisy-chain drive consists of a series of genetic elements (e.g., C, B, A) arranged sequentially. Each element drives the next in the chain, with the final "cargo" element (A) being the ultimate target for modification. Crucially, the elements at the "base" of the chain (e.g., C) cannot drive themselves and are eventually lost from the population due to natural selection. This sequential dependency and eventual loss limit the drive's persistence and spread.

The authors employed mathematical modeling and numerical simulations to analyze the dynamics of these daisy-chain drives. They developed deterministic models to study the evolution of populations under these drive systems, considering factors like homing efficiency (the rate at which the drive converts wild-type alleles), fitness costs associated with the drive elements, and release sizes. They also explored metapopulation models to assess spread between connected populations.

A significant methodological contribution is the identification and design of novel, highly active guide RNA (gRNA) sequences. To ensure the stability of daisy-chain drives and prevent the formation of "daisy necklaces" (where elements recombine to form a self-propagating drive), they focused on creating gRNAs with minimal homology to each other. This was achieved through careful analysis of existing data and experimental screening in human cell cultures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors generated their own data through simulations and experimental assays of guide RNA activity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Self-Exhausting Nature: The daisy-chain design is the key innovation. By creating a dependency where earlier elements are lost, the drive naturally "runs out of steam," preventing indefinite spread. This is a fundamental shift from self-propagating drives.
  • Local Control and Ethical Deployment: The self-exhausting property directly addresses the ethical concerns surrounding gene drives. It allows for localized interventions and provides a mechanism for communities to decide on and manage the alteration of their local ecosystems.
  • Tunable Potency: The system's effectiveness can be tuned by adjusting the number of elements in the chain, the homing efficiency, and the fitness costs. Longer chains and higher homing efficiencies lead to more potent and efficient spread of the cargo element.
  • Minimally Homologous gRNAs for Stability: The identification of highly active, divergent gRNAs is crucial for preventing the formation of self-propagating "daisy necklaces" through recombination. This is a critical step towards building stable and reliable daisy-chain systems.
  • Potential for Reversal: The self-exhausting nature also implies that the effects of a daisy drive are transient, offering a potential pathway for reversal or natural reversion to the wild-type state.

Key Results

  • Local Fixation Achieved: Simulations demonstrated that daisy-chain drives can drive a "cargo" genetic element to near local fixation (e.g., >99% frequency) within a population, even with relatively small initial releases and moderate fitness costs.
  • Limited Inter-Population Spread: In metapopulation models, daisy-chain drives showed significantly limited spread to adjacent populations compared to standard self-propagating drives, especially at lower migration rates.
  • Sensitivity to Parameters: The spread and persistence of daisy drives are sensitive to homing efficiency, fitness costs, and release size, but the self-exhausting mechanism inherently limits long-term spread.
  • Identification of Stable gRNAs: The study identified 15 highly active sgRNA sequences with minimal homology, suitable for constructing stable daisy-chain drives of up to five elements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The models used are deterministic and assume ideal conditions (e.g., random mating, independent inheritance of elements). Real-world populations may exhibit more complex dynamics.
  • Experimental Validation: While gRNA activity was tested in human cell culture, the full daisy-chain system requires extensive validation in target animal models.
  • Resistance Evolution: While the paper discusses strategies to mitigate resistance, the long-term evolution of resistance to daisy drives in wild populations remains a concern and requires further investigation.
  • Inter-Population Spread Beyond Daisy Drive Exhaustion: The authors acknowledge that daisy drives alone cannot prevent the spread of engineered genes into adjacent populations if the drive is still active. They suggest that a subsequent "threshold-dependent" drive system might be needed to actively eliminate engineered alleles from minority populations.
  • Feasibility of Construction: The practical construction of multi-element daisy-chain drives, especially in complex organisms, will require further technological development.
  • Investigating Persistence: While the paper touches on persistence, a more thorough quantitative analysis of how long cargo elements remain at high frequencies after achieving them is needed.
  • Metapopulation Dynamics: Further investigation into the dynamics of daisy drives in more complex metapopulation structures and with varying gene flow rates is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

If they are able to spread in wild populations, CRISPR-based gene-drive elements would provide new ways to address ecological problems by altering the traits of wild organisms, but the potential for uncontrolled spread tremendously complicates ethical development and use. Here, we detail a self-exhausting form of CRISPR-based drive system comprising genetic elements arranged in a daisy chain such that each drives the next. “Daisy-drive” systems can locally duplicate any effect achievable by using an equivalent self-propagating drive system, but their capacity to spread is limited by the successive loss of nondriving elements from one end of the chain. Releasing daisy-drive organisms constituting a small fraction of the local wild population can drive a useful genetic element nearly to local fixation for a wide range of fitness parameters without self-propagating spread. We additionally report numerous highly active guide RNA sequences sharing minimal homology that may enable evolutionarily stable daisy drive as well as self-propagating CRISPR-based gene drive. Especially when combined with threshold dependence, daisy drives could simplify decision-making and promote ethical use by enabling local communities to decide whether, when, and how to alter local ecosystems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{noble2019daisy,
  author = {Charleston Noble and John Min and Jason Olejarz and Joanna Buchthal and Alejandro Chavez and Andrea L. Smidler and Erika A. DeBenedictis and George M. Church and Martin A. Nowak and Kevin M. Esvelt},
  title = {{Daisy-chain gene drives for the alteration of local populations}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1716358116},
}
Figure