TL;DR
Researchers have used cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) to visualize how dynein motor proteins, crucial for cellular transport and movement, interact with microtubules. They discovered that an axonemal dynein, unlike its cytoplasmic counterpart, significantly distorts the microtubule's structure, suggesting a novel mechanism for coordinating motor activity in cilia and flagella.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Dyneins are essential molecular motors that "walk" along microtubules, powering various cellular processes like intracellular transport and the beating of cilia and flagella. Their interaction with microtubules is mediated by a specific domain called the microtubule-binding domain (MTBD). While the general mechanism of dynein binding and release from microtubules is understood to involve conformational changes in response to ATP binding, the precise structural details of how different types of dyneins interact with microtubules, especially axonemal dyneins involved in complex cellular structures, remained unclear. Specifically, axonemal dyneins possess unique features, like a "flap" insertion in their MTBD, whose functional significance and impact on microtubule structure were unknown. This study aimed to resolve the high-resolution structures of both cytoplasmic and axonemal dynein MTBDs bound to microtubules to understand these differences and their implications.
Methods
The core technique employed was cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The researchers decorated purified microtubules with either the cytoplasmic dynein-1 MTBD or the axonemal dynein DNAH7 MTBD. They then flash-froze these samples and imaged them using advanced cryo-EM microscopes.
A key methodological advancement was the application of the Relion 3.0 software pipeline, specifically leveraging its capabilities for helical reconstruction and local symmetry averaging. This allowed them to achieve near-atomic resolution (4.1 Å for cytoplasmic dynein and 4.5 Å for axonemal dynein) for these complex, pseudo-symmetric structures. They also developed a refined image processing workflow that incorporated local symmetry to better handle the inherent imperfections and variations in microtubule structures.
For structural analysis, they built and refined atomic models of the dynein MTBDs and tubulin subunits into the cryo-EM density maps using software like Chimera and Coot. They also performed detailed analysis of microtubule curvature and dynein decoration patterns using specialized scripts and measurements.
Datasets
The paper describes the generation and analysis of new cryo-EM datasets for:
- Cytoplasmic dynein-1 MTBD decorated microtubules: This dataset was used to determine the structure at 4.1 Å resolution.
- Axonemal dynein DNAH7 MTBD decorated microtubules: This dataset was used to determine the structure at 4.5 Å resolution.
Additionally, they reprocessed an existing EB3-decorated microtubule dataset (EMPIAR ID 10030) using their Relion workflow to demonstrate its general applicability for reconstructing decorated pseudosymmetric microtubules.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Conserved Binding Mechanism, Divergent Impact: Both cytoplasmic and axonemal dynein MTBDs utilize a largely conserved mechanism for binding to microtubules, primarily involving the movement of helix H1 to achieve high affinity. However, the axonemal dynein DNAH7 has a dramatically different effect on the microtubule itself.
- The "Flap" is Key: The 18-residue "flap" insertion unique to many axonemal dyneins (like DNAH7) is crucial. This flap extends the interaction surface and directly contacts an adjacent protofilament of the microtubule.
- Microtubule Distortion as a Regulatory Mechanism: DNAH7 binding causes significant distortions in the microtubule's cross-sectional curvature, making it less circular and more elliptical. This is a novel finding, suggesting that dyneins might not just be passive passengers on microtubules but can actively alter their structure.
- Curvature Sensing: The observed correlation between higher DNAH7 decoration and lower local microtubule curvature suggests that DNAH7 might act as a "curvature sensor," binding more strongly to flatter regions. This could be important for coordinating dynein activity within the highly organized axoneme.
- Potential for Torque Generation: The off-axis tilt of the DNAH7 MTBD relative to cytoplasmic dynein, coupled with the flap interaction, hints at a mechanism for generating torque, which is known to be important for ciliary bending.
Key Results
- Near-Atomic Resolution Structures: The study successfully determined cryo-EM structures of cytoplasmic dynein-1 MTBD (4.1 Å) and axonemal dynein DNAH7 MTBD (4.5 Å) bound to microtubules.
- Minimal MTBD Rearrangement: The majority of the dynein MTBD structure remains rigid upon binding; the primary change for high-affinity binding is the upward movement of helix H1.
- DNAH7 Induces Significant Microtubule Curvature Changes: Unlike cytoplasmic dynein-1, DNAH7 binding leads to substantial distortions in the microtubule's cross-sectional shape, with protofilament angles varying significantly.
- Flap-Protofilament Interaction: The DNAH7 flap was observed to contact an adjacent protofilament, specifically interacting with loops on both α- and β-tubulin.
- Correlation Between Decoration and Curvature: Sub-classification revealed that regions of the microtubule with lower local curvature exhibit higher levels of DNAH7 decoration.
Limitations and Future Work
- In Vitro System: The study was conducted using purified microtubules and dynein MTBDs in vitro. The behavior of DNAH7 within the complex environment of a native axoneme, where other proteins and the doublet microtubule structure play roles, may differ.
- Flap Flexibility: While the flap's interaction is evident, its observed density suggests some degree of flexibility, making its precise dynamics challenging to fully capture.
- Axonemal Context: The authors speculate that the observed distortions could play a role in coordinating dynein activity in axonemes, potentially influencing torque generation or acting as curvature sensors. However, direct experimental validation of these hypotheses within the axoneme is needed.
- Higher Resolution of Axonemal Dyneins: Future work could focus on obtaining higher-resolution structures of full-length axonemal dyneins in their native context to further elucidate their mechanisms of action and interactions.
- Testing Hypotheses: The authors suggest testing their hypotheses about flap-induced communication and curvature sensing through further experiments, potentially involving in vivo studies or more complex in vitro reconstitution systems.
Summary updated