Crowd-Sourced Data and Analysis Tools for Advancing the Chemical Vapor Deposition of Graphene: Implications for Manufacturing

Joshua A. Schiller, Ricardo J. Toro, Aagam Shah, Mitisha Surana, Kaihao Zhang, Matthew Robertson, Kristina Miller, Kevin Cruse, Kevin Liu, Bomsaerah Seong, Seol Chae, Ian Foster, Ben Blaiszik, Ben Galewsky, Darren Adams, Daniel S. Katz, Placid Ferreira, Elif Ertekin, Sameh Tawfick

Abstract

Industrial production of graphene by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) requires more than the ability to synthesize large domain, high-quality graphene in a lab reactor. Progress toward industrial objectives is hindered by the hundreds of coupled synthesis parameters that can strongly affect CVD of low-dimensional materials and poor communication in the published literature of the rich experimental data that exists in individual laboratories. We report here on a platform, “graphene recipes for synthesis of high quality material” (Gr-ResQ), which includes powerful new tools for data-driven graphene synthesis. At the core of Gr-ResQ is a crowd-sourced database of CVD synthesis recipes and associated experimental results capturing ~300 parameters. A suite of associated tools enable fast, automated, and standardized processing of Raman spectra and scanning electron microscopy images. We envision that this holistic approach to data-driven synthesis can accelerate CVD recipe discovery and production control and open opportunities for advancing not only graphene but also many other 1D and 2D materials.

Introduction: The Reproducibility Crisis in Graphene Synthesis

Graphene synthesis via Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) is notoriously finicky. Despite thousands of publications, reproducing results across different laboratories remains a major challenge. This difficulty stems from two primary hurdles: extreme sensitivity to hundreds of coupled parameters and significant data fragmentation. Much of the rich experimental data—including critical "negative results" where growth failed—remains locked in individual lab notebooks, inaccessible to the broader community.

The Challenge of "Dark Data"

A meta-analysis of the most highly cited graphene CVD publications reveals a startling dearth of reported parameters. Critical variables that significantly impact growth outcomes, such as reactor dew point or specific furnace geometry, are rarely documented in formal literature.

Fraction of highly-cited papers with unreported critical synthesis data.

As shown above, parameters like "Tube Length" and "Dew Point" are unreported in nearly 100% and 80% of top-cited papers, respectively. Without a standardized, centralized repository, the community cannot leverage machine learning to navigate the hyper-dimensional "recipe space" required for industrial-scale manufacturing.

Standardizing the CVD Recipe Space with Gr-ResQ

To address these gaps, we developed Gr-ResQ, a multi-faceted platform hosted on nanoHUB. The platform introduces structured data ingestion that captures approximately 300 parameters across six categories, including provenance, ambient conditions, and specific recipe steps.

Schematic of the multi-stage CVD process captured by the Gr-ResQ platform.

By tracking the entire lifecycle of a growth run—from heating and annealing to the growth phase and cooling duration—Gr-ResQ allows researchers to visualize clusters of successful recipes using t-distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (t-SNE). This helps identify "islands" of stability in a sea of variables, moving graphene production from a "black box" trial-and-error approach toward predictable, data-driven manufacturing.

Automated Analysis and Cyber-Physical Integration

Beyond data storage, Gr-ResQ provides free, automated tools for Raman and SEM analysis. The Raman tool performs baseline correction and Lorentzian fitting to automatically determine graphene quality and layer count. Similarly, the SEM tool uses template matching and Sobel filters to segment graphene from substrates and quantify the angular alignment of domains.

To facilitate community-based efforts, Gr-ResQ provides tools for cyber-physical collaborations among research groups, allowing experiments to be designed, executed, and analyzed by different teams. The platform successfully implements FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reproducible) data principles by publishing data to the Materials Data Facility (MDF) and assigning unique DOIs to recipe collections.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While currently focused on graphene, the Gr-ResQ framework is designed to be expandable to other 2D materials like transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs). The utility of such a crowd-sourced effort scales with its user base; community-wide participation is essential to reach the critical mass required for robust predictive machine learning models. By standardizing reporting and analysis, Gr-ResQ aims to accelerate the transition of graphene from a laboratory curiosity to a reliable industrial material.

Summary updated

Abstract

Industrial production of graphene by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) requires more than the ability to synthesize large domain, high-quality graphene in a lab reactor. The integration of graphene in the fabrication process of electronic devices requires the cost-effective and environmentally friendly production of graphene on dielectric substrates, but current approaches can only produce graphene on metal catalysts. Sustainable manufacturing of graphene should also conserve the catalyst and reaction gases, but today the metal catalysts are typically dissolved after synthesis. Progress toward these objectives is hindered by the hundreds of coupled synthesis parameters that can strongly affect CVD of low-dimensional materials and poor communication in the published literature of the rich experimental data that exists in individual laboratories. We report here on a platform, “graphene recipes for synthesis of high quality material” (Gr-ResQ: pronounced graphene rescue), which includes powerful new tools for data-driven graphene synthesis. At the core of Gr-ResQ is a crowd-sourced database of CVD synthesis recipes and associated experimental results. The database captures ∼300 parameters ranging from synthesis conditions such as a catalyst material and preparation steps, to ambient lab temperature and reactor details, as well as resulting Raman spectra and microscopy images. These parameters are carefully selected to unlock the potential of machine-learning models to advance synthesis. A suite of associated tools enable fast, automated, and standardized processing of Raman spectra and scanning electron microscopy images. To facilitate community-based efforts, Gr-ResQ provides tools for cyber-physical collaborations among research groups, allowing experiments to be designed, executed, and analyzed by different teams. Gr-ResQ also allows publication and discovery of recipes via the Materials Data Facility, which assigns each recipe a unique identifier when published and collects parameters in a search index. We envision that this holistic approach to data-driven synthesis can accelerate CVD recipe discovery and production control and open opportunities for advancing not only graphene but also many other 1D and 2D materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schiller2020crowd,
  author = {Joshua A. Schiller and Ricardo J. Toro and Aagam Shah and Mitisha Surana and Kaihao Zhang and Matthew Robertson and Kristina Miller and Kevin Cruse and Kevin Liu and Bomsaerah Seong and Seol Chae and Ian Foster and Ben Blaiszik and Ben Galewsky and Darren Adams and Daniel S. Katz and Placid Ferreira and Elif Ertekin and Sameh Tawfick},
  title = {{Crowd-Sourced Data and Analysis Tools for Advancing the Chemical Vapor Deposition of Graphene: Implications for Manufacturing}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1021/acsanm.0c02018},
}
Figure