Cross‐Lagged Panel Networks of Distinct Complex Post‐Traumatic Stress Disorder Symptom Trajectories Among Young Adults With Adverse Childhood Experiences

Aiyi Liu, Liying Zhang, Mingxiao Liu, Ziwei Wang, Xinchun WuDepression 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses advanced network analysis to map how complex post-traumatic stress disorder (CPTSD) symptoms interact over time in young adults with adverse childhood experiences (ACEs). It identifies two distinct symptom trajectories – a high-risk group that worsens and a resistance group that improves – and pinpoints specific symptoms that drive these trajectories, offering crucial targets for intervention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are a significant risk factor for developing complex post-traumatic stress disorder (CPTSD) in adulthood. CPTSD is a severe condition characterized by not only classic PTSD symptoms (re-experiencing, avoidance, threat) but also disturbances in self-organization, including emotional dysregulation, negative self-concept, and disturbed relationships. While we know ACEs are linked to CPTSD, how these symptoms evolve and interact over time, especially in different individuals, is not fully understood. Previous research often used variable-centered approaches, which can miss individual differences in symptom trajectories. This paper aims to address this gap by identifying distinct symptom trajectories and exploring the dynamic relationships within these trajectories using a person-centered approach and network analysis.

Methods

The researchers employed two primary statistical techniques:

  1. Growth Mixture Modeling (GMM): This method was used to identify distinct groups (trajectories) of individuals based on how their CPTSD symptoms changed over three time points. GMM allows for the identification of homogeneous subgroups with similar symptom patterns over time, accounting for individual differences.
  2. Cross-Lagged Panel Network (CLPN) Analysis: Once trajectories were identified, CLPN analysis was used to examine the temporal relationships between specific CPTSD symptoms within each trajectory group. CLPNs visualize symptoms as nodes and their directional relationships as edges, allowing researchers to see how symptoms predict each other over time. This method is particularly useful for understanding the dynamic interplay and potential causal pathways between symptoms.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 1277 university students in China who reported experiencing ACEs. Data were collected at three time points over three academic years (September 2021, September 2022, and September 2023).

  • ACEs Questionnaire: Assessed family adversity (abuse, neglect, household dysfunction) at baseline.
  • Lifetime Traumatic Exposure (LEC-5): Assessed exposure to various traumatic events.
  • International Trauma Questionnaire (ITQ): Measured CPTSD symptoms (including PTSD clusters and DSO clusters) at all three time points.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two Distinct Paths: Not everyone with ACEs follows the same CPTSD symptom path. The study clearly delineates a "high-risk" group whose symptoms worsen over time and a "resistance" group whose symptoms improve. This highlights the importance of personalized approaches to intervention.
  • Symptom Drivers Differ by Trajectory: The key symptoms that influence others are not the same for everyone. This is a crucial insight for targeted interventions.
  • Disturbances in Self-Organization (DSO) are Central: Symptoms related to self-organization (affective dysregulation, negative self-concept, disturbed relationships) play a pivotal role in the development and maintenance of CPTSD, especially in the high-risk group.
  • Network Dynamics Reveal Vulnerabilities: CLPN analysis provides a granular view of how specific symptoms predict each other, revealing which symptoms are most influential (out-expected influence) and which are most susceptible to influence (in-expected influence) within each trajectory.

Key Results

  • Trajectory Identification: GMM identified two distinct CPTSD symptom trajectories: a "high-risk" group (22.63% of the sample) with initially high and increasing symptom levels, and a "resistance" group (77.37%) with initially lower and decreasing symptom levels.
  • High-Risk Group Network: In the high-risk group, "disturbed relationships" (DRs) were the strongest predictor of other symptoms early on (T1-T2), particularly affecting affective dysregulation (AD), avoidance (AV), and negative self-concept (NSC). Later (T2-T3), "negative self-concept" (NSC) became the most predictive symptom.
  • Resistance Group Network: In the resistance group, the predictive influence of DRs and NSC was attenuated. Instead, "affective dysregulation" (AD) emerged as the central symptom, predicting DRs, AV, and sense of current threat (TH) in the T1-T2 period. As symptoms declined, "avoidance" (AV) became more central.
  • Centrality Indices: The study used centrality indices (in-EI and out-EI) to quantify symptom influence. For example, DRs showed high out-EI in the high-risk group, indicating they drive symptom progression.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cultural Specificity: The sample consisted exclusively of Chinese university students, limiting generalizability to other cultural or demographic groups. Future research should explore cross-cultural validity.
  • Trauma Specificity: The study focused on ACEs; future work could examine how different types of trauma influence these networks.
  • Centrality Stability: Some centrality indices were below the recommended threshold (0.25) in smaller subgroups, potentially due to sample size. Future research should investigate factors influencing centrality stability.
  • Causality: While CLPNs suggest directional relationships, they cannot definitively establish causality due to between-person analysis and fixed lag times.
  • Recent Life Events: The study did not extensively examine recent negative life events beyond childhood adversity, which could influence symptom trajectories. Future studies should incorporate these.

The authors suggest that targeting specific symptoms like DRs and NSC in the high-risk group, and AD in the resistance group, could be effective intervention strategies. They also highlight the need for longer-term follow-up studies to fully understand developmental patterns.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background and Objectives:</b> Young adults with a history of adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) may exhibit varying trajectories of complex post-traumatic stress disorder (CPTSD) symptoms over time. Unraveling the patterns of interactions between CPTSD symptoms across distinct trajectories is crucial. This study aimed to investigate the longitudinal relationships, changes, and central symptoms in CPTSD networks over time across distinct CPTSD trajectory groups. <b>Methods:</b> This longitudinal study followed 1277 university students (47.5% male) who reported ACEs from China through three waves of surveys. ACEs were assessed at baseline, while symptoms of CPTSD were measured at all three time points. Growth mixture modeling (GMM) was used to identify CPTSD symptom trajectories, and cross-lagged panel network (CLPN) analysis estimated the longitudinal relationships among CPTSD symptoms within these trajectories. <b>Results:</b> Two distinct and consistent CPTSD symptom trajectories were identified: a high-risk group and a resistance group. In the high-risk group, "disturbed relationships" (DRs) and "negative self-concept" (NSC) emerged as the strongest predictors of other symptoms at various time points. In the resilient group, the predictive influence of DR and NSC on other symptoms was attenuated. Instead, "affective dysregulation" (AD) emerged as the central symptom, demonstrating the strong predictive associations with other symptom domains. <b>Conclusions:</b> These findings reveal directional relationships among symptoms in young adults. Symptoms related to disturbances in self-organization (DSO), identified through centrality indices, are key drivers of symptom network development in different CPTSD trajectories. Targeting these symptoms in interventions for young adults with ACEs may help prevent or reduce CPTSD progression.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025crosslagged,
  author = {Aiyi Liu and Liying Zhang and Mingxiao Liu and Ziwei Wang and Xinchun Wu},
  title = {{Cross‐Lagged Panel Networks of Distinct Complex Post‐Traumatic Stress Disorder Symptom Trajectories Among Young Adults With Adverse Childhood Experiences}},
  booktitle = {Depression},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1155/da/8823021},
}
Figure