Crossing beyond scattering amplitudes

Simon Caron-Huot, Mathieu Giroux, Holmfridur S. Hannesdottir, Sebastian Mizera

TL;DR

This paper reveals that crossing symmetry—the principle that relates particles to anti-particles traveling backward in time—is far more expansive than previously thought. The authors propose a generalized crossing equation that connects standard scattering amplitudes to a wider family of "inclusive" observables, such as gravitational waveforms, and provide rigorous proofs at tree-level and extensive tests at the loop-level.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In particle physics, "crossing symmetry" is a fundamental tool. It suggests that if you know the math for electron-positron annihilation ($e^- e^+ \to \gamma \gamma$), you can "cross" a few particles to find the math for Compton scattering ($e^- \gamma \to e^- \gamma$). While this is well-established for simple 2-to-2 particle interactions in theories where every particle has mass, the theoretical foundation becomes shaky for more complex interactions (higher multiplicity) or theories involving massless particles (like gravity or light).

The authors ask a bold question: If we analytically continue a complex scattering process—swapping an incoming particle for an outgoing anti-particle—what do we actually get? Is it always just another scattering amplitude, or could it be something entirely different?

Methods

The researchers employ a mix of high-level mathematical physics and perturbative calculation techniques:

  • Analytic Continuation: They define a complex boost parameter $z$ that allows them to "rotate" particle momenta from incoming to outgoing while staying "on-shell" (keeping the physics realistic).
  • Axiomatic Field Theory: They use the principles of microcausality (the idea that nothing travels faster than light) to justify why these mathematical functions are "analytic" and can be continued into complex space.
  • Perturbative Tools: To test their ideas at the loop-level (where quantum effects get messy), they use unitarity cuts and canonical differential equations to evaluate complex Feynman diagrams like the "massless pentagon."
  • String Theory: They extend the analysis to string theory, using the geometry of the string worldsheet (moduli space) to visualize crossing as a series of "spirals" and "anti-spirals" in the math.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, it does not use traditional datasets. Instead, the "data" consists of master integrals—the building blocks of quantum calculations—including bubbles, triangles, boxes, and pentagons. They also evaluate tree-level open string amplitudes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Crossing Relates Different Observables: The most striking insight is that crossing doesn't just relate amplitudes to amplitudes. It can relate an exclusive amplitude (where you know exactly what comes out) to an inclusive observable (where you sum over all possible outcomes).
  • The Gravitational Wave Connection: This math allows researchers to compute gravitational waveforms—the ripples in spacetime detected by LIGO—by analytically continuing the scattering math of black holes.
  • Webs of Observables: Not all measurements are related. The authors found that observables form "families" or "webs." You can cross your way around within a family, but some measurements remain mathematically isolated from others.
  • Spacetime Gridlock: In theories with massless particles, the authors identified "anomalous thresholds." These act like mathematical roadblocks where internal particles "move faster" than the external ones we are trying to cross, potentially obstructing the path of analytic continuation.

Key Results

  • Tree-Level Proof: The authors provide a combinatorial proof that their generalized crossing equation holds for any scalar tree-level diagram, regardless of how many particles are involved.
  • One-Loop Validation: They successfully verified the crossing conjecture for all massless one-loop master integrals up to five-point functions.
  • String Theory Success: They demonstrated that the crossing relations work perfectly for open string theory at tree-level, providing a geometric interpretation of the process.
  • Inclusive vs. Exclusive: They showed that while crossing massive particles in gapless theories can fail due to anomalous thresholds, crossing massless particles (like gravitons) appears to be "safe," which is great news for gravitational wave physics.

Limitations and Future Work

The main limitation is the "analytic obstruction" found in certain gapless theories. When massive external legs and massless internal particles are involved, the standard path for crossing can hit a branch cut, meaning the simple version of the theory fails.

Future work aims to:

  1. Extend the Proofs: Move from tree-level proofs to multi-loop proofs.
  2. The Bootstrap: Use these new crossing relations to "bootstrap" (mathematically deduce) new observables without doing the full, grueling calculations from scratch.
  3. Signature Exploration: Investigate if moving through "split signature" spacetime (2 space and 2 time dimensions) provides a cleaner mathematical path for crossing in massless theories.

Summary updated

Abstract

We find that different asymptotic measurements in quantum field theory can be related to one another through new versions of crossing symmetry. Assuming analyticity, we conjecture generalized crossing relations for multi-particle processes and the corresponding paths of analytic continuation. We prove them to all multiplicity at tree-level in quantum field theory and string theory. We illustrate how to practically perform analytic continuations on loop-level examples using different methods, including unitarity cuts and differential equations. We study the extent to which anomalous thresholds away from the usual physical region can cause an analytic obstruction to crossing when massless particles are involved. In an appendix, we review and streamline historical proofs of four-particle crossing symmetry in gapped theories.
BibTeX
@article{caronhuot2024crossing,
  author = {Simon Caron-Huot and Mathieu Giroux and Holmfridur S. Hannesdottir and Sebastian Mizera},
  title = {{Crossing beyond scattering amplitudes}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep04(2024)060},
}
Figure