Cross-species efficacy of AAV-mediated ARSA replacement for metachromatic leukodystrophy

Shyam Ramachandran, Jeffery Ardinger, Jie Bu, M. Isabel Alcalá Ramos, Lilu Guo, Debabrata Ghosh, Mahmud Hossain, Shelley N. Chou, Chen Yao, Erik Wischhof, Swathi Ayloo, Roger Trullo, Yongde Luo, Jessica M. Hogestyn, Daniel M. DuBreuil, Emily Crosier, Johanna G. Flyer-Adams, Amy M. Richards, Michael Tsabar, Giorgio Gaglia, Shelley Nass, Bindu Nambiar, Denise Woodcock, Catherine R. O’Riordan, Qi Tang, Bradford Elmer, Bailin Zhang, Martin Goulet, Christian MuellerJournal of Clinical Investigation 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel adeno-associated virus (AAV) capsid, AAV.GMU01, that significantly improves delivery of the ARSA gene to the central nervous system (CNS) in nonhuman primates (NHPs). This engineered AAV shows promise for treating metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) by restoring ARSA enzyme levels, reducing toxic sulfatide buildup, and reversing disease-associated pathology in both mouse models and NHPs, suggesting a potential clinical breakthrough.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is a devastating, inherited neurodegenerative disorder caused by mutations in the arylsulfatase A (ARSA) gene. This deficiency leads to the toxic accumulation of sulfatides, particularly in the brain and nervous system, causing progressive disability and often early death, especially in children. While gene therapy using AAV vectors has shown potential for MLD, a major hurdle has been achieving sufficient and widespread distribution of the therapeutic gene throughout the CNS. Previous attempts, even with promising AAV serotypes like AAV.rh10, have been hampered by limited biodistribution, preventing them from reaching therapeutic endpoints in clinical trials. This paper aims to overcome this limitation by developing and testing a new AAV capsid designed for superior CNS delivery.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the development and evaluation of a novel AAV capsid, AAV.GMU01. This engineered capsid was identified through a screening process of AAV9 variants with a specific peptide insert designed to enhance CNS targeting.

Key methodological steps include:

  • Capsid Engineering and Screening: A library of AAV9 variants with a 7-amino acid peptide insert was screened in rhesus macaques via intracerebroventricular (ICV) injection to identify candidates with enhanced biodistribution and transgene expression. AAV.GMU01 emerged as the lead candidate.
  • Comparative Biodistribution Studies (NHPs): AAV.GMU01 was directly compared to the established AAV.rh10 serotype in cynomolgus nonhuman primates (NHPs). Both vectors carried an eGFP reporter gene and were administered via intrathecal (IT) delivery. Vector genomes (VGs) and eGFP expression were quantified across numerous brain regions to assess biodistribution and expression levels.
  • Intracisternal Magna (ICM) vs. ICV Delivery (NHPs): The optimal route of administration for AAV.GMU01 was investigated by comparing bilateral ICV injection with direct injection into the cisterna magna (ICM) in NHPs. This evaluation included assessing VG distribution, transgene expression (using nanoluciferase and mCherry reporters), and histopathological markers of inflammation and degeneration.
  • Preclinical Efficacy Studies (MLD Mouse Model): The therapeutic efficacy of AAV.GMU01 carrying the human ARSA gene (AAV.GMU01-ARSA) was tested in a well-established mouse model of MLD (Arsa-KO mice). Studies involved administering the vector at different stages of disease progression and assessing sulfatase activity, sulfatide levels, neuroinflammation markers, and auditory function.
  • ARSA Protein Cross-Correction Studies: The ability of the delivered ARSA enzyme to correct neighboring, non-transduced cells was investigated using both AAV.rh10 and AAV.GMU01 vectors in mouse models. This was assessed by measuring ARSA mRNA and protein levels in relation to vector genome presence.
  • Dose-Ranging Studies (Mice and NHPs): The impact of different vector doses on ARSA expression, sulfatide clearance, and safety was evaluated in both MLD mice and NHPs.
  • Safety and Tolerability Assessments: In both mouse and NHP models, comprehensive safety assessments were performed, including histopathology, monitoring for immune responses (cytokine levels, IFN-γ ELISpot), and evaluation of neurological and behavioral parameters.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in the paper as distinct datasets for training or evaluation. The study relies on data generated from experiments involving:

  • Nonhuman Primates (NHPs): Cynomolgus monkeys were used for biodistribution, delivery route optimization, and safety studies.
  • Mouse Models: MLD mouse models (Arsa-KO) were used for preclinical efficacy and dose-ranging studies.
  • Human Brain Tissue: Postmortem brain tissue from healthy human donors was used for comparison of ARSA protein levels.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • AAV.GMU01: A Game Changer for CNS Gene Delivery: The development of AAV.GMU01 represents a significant leap forward. Its ability to achieve superior CNS biodistribution and transgene expression in NHPs, even at lower vector doses compared to AAV.rh10, is a critical breakthrough for treating neurological disorders.
  • ICM Delivery: A Promising Route: The study highlights the cisterna magna (ICM) injection as a well-tolerated and effective route for delivering AAV.GMU01 to the CNS in NHPs, offering broad distribution without the need for multiple invasive procedures.
  • ARSA Cross-Correction: Amplifying Therapeutic Reach: The research demonstrates that the ARSA enzyme, once delivered, can be taken up by neighboring cells. This "cross-correction" mechanism significantly expands the therapeutic footprint of the gene therapy, reaching cells that may not have been directly transduced by the AAV vector.
  • Early Intervention and Long-Term Efficacy: Studies in MLD mice show that AAV.GMU01-ARSA treatment can reverse disease pathology and restore function even when administered at early, pre-symptomatic stages, suggesting the potential for long-term benefits with a single administration.
  • Biomarkers for Monitoring: The study validates the use of sulfatide levels in plasma and cerebrospinal fluid, as well as Nf-L levels, as potential biomarkers for monitoring therapeutic efficacy in MLD patients.

Key Results

  • Superior Biodistribution in NHPs: AAV.GMU01 demonstrated approximately 10-fold lower vector genome (VG) exposure in gray matter punches compared to AAV.rh10 in NHPs, yet achieved significantly higher eGFP expression. This indicates a more efficient transduction per vector genome.
  • Effective Sulfatide Reduction in Mice: AAV.GMU01-ARSA treatment in MLD mice restored sulfatase activity to WT levels in the brain, spinal cord, and DRGs, leading to a significant reduction in toxic sulfatides (lyso-ST, C16, C18, and total ST) across these tissues and in plasma and CSF.
  • Reversal of Pathology and Dysfunction: Treated MLD mice showed a reduction in neuroinflammation markers, improved auditory function (preventing hearing loss), and decreased histopathological signs of neurodegeneration and vacuolation.
  • Therapeutic ARSA Levels in NHPs: In NHPs, AAV.GMU01-ARSA treatment achieved human ARSA protein levels in the brain that were 1.2- to 8.1-fold higher than endogenous cynomolgus ARSA levels, and significantly surpassed levels associated with ARSA pseudodeficiency.
  • Favorable Safety Profile: AAV.GMU01-ARSA treatment was generally well-tolerated in both mice and NHPs, with no significant cell-mediated immune responses or dose-dependent cytokine elevations observed in NHPs. Transient Nf-L elevations were noted, which is common with AAV administration.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cell-Specific Resolution: The authors acknowledge that while bulk tissue assessments are informative, they lack cell-specific resolution for transgene expression. Future studies should delve deeper into which specific cell types are transduced and how cross-correction occurs at the cellular level.
  • GLP Toxicology Studies: For clinical translation, Good Laboratory Practice (GLP) toxicology studies using clinically representative materials are essential.
  • Species Differences: The paper notes that differences in sulfatide metabolism dynamics and disease progression between mice and humans may influence the complete normalization of sulfatide metabolites observed in preclinical models.
  • Immune Response Complexity: While the study showed a favorable safety profile, the potential for cross-reactive immune responses, particularly in CRIM-negative individuals (those lacking endogenous ARSA), warrants careful monitoring in clinical trials.
  • Clinical Translation Challenges: The authors highlight the need for rigorous clinical trial design to validate safety and efficacy, considering the complexities of enzyme distribution, activity thresholds, and tissue-specific requirements. The use of ICM delivery, while promising, still requires specialized expertise.
  • Nf-L as a Biomarker: The transient nature of Nf-L elevations post-AAV administration can complicate its interpretation as a biomarker for therapeutic efficacy, necessitating a focus on long-term trends.

The future work will likely focus on advancing this promising therapy towards human clinical trials, including further safety assessments and optimizing dosing strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is an autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorder caused by mutations in the arylsulfatase A (ARSA) gene, resulting in lower sulfatase activity and the toxic accumulation of sulfatides in the central and peripheral nervous system. Children account for 70% of cases and become progressively disabled, with death occurring within 10 years of disease onset. Gene therapy approaches to restore ARSA expression via adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors have been promising but hampered by limited brain biodistribution. We report the development of an engineered capsid, AAV.GMU01, demonstrating superior biodistribution and transgene expression in the central nervous system of nonhuman primates (NHPs). Next, we show that AAV.GMU01-ARSA-treated MLD mice exhibit persistent, normal levels of sulfatase activity and a concomitant reduction in toxic sulfatides. Treated mice also show a reduction in MLD-associated pathology and auditory dysfunction. Lastly, we demonstrate that treatment with AAV.GMU01-ARSA in NHPs is well tolerated and results in potentially therapeutic ARSA expression in the brain. In summary, we propose AAV.GMU01-ARSA-mediated gene replacement as a clinically viable approach to achieve broad and therapeutic levels of ARSA.
BibTeX
@article{ramachandran2025cross,
  author = {Shyam Ramachandran and Jeffery Ardinger and Jie Bu and M. Isabel Alcalá Ramos and Lilu Guo and Debabrata Ghosh and Mahmud Hossain and Shelley N. Chou and Chen Yao and Erik Wischhof and Swathi Ayloo and Roger Trullo and Yongde Luo and Jessica M. Hogestyn and Daniel M. DuBreuil and Emily Crosier and Johanna G. Flyer-Adams and Amy M. Richards and Michael Tsabar and Giorgio Gaglia and Shelley Nass and Bindu Nambiar and Denise Woodcock and Catherine R. O’Riordan and Qi Tang and Bradford Elmer and Bailin Zhang and Martin Goulet and Christian Mueller},
  title = {{Cross-species efficacy of AAV-mediated ARSA replacement for metachromatic leukodystrophy}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Investigation},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1172/jci185001},
}
Figure