Criticism of the paper “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance”
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
The authors of this letter represent a large student body who have generally had especially positive experiences with female mentors’ advice and mentorships and do not support the conclusions of the article “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance” because its conclusions regarding gender reach beyond the article’s scope and because the quality of mentorships cannot be analysed only through citation counts. Publications are not equivalent to learning outcomes or professional advancement.After careful review of the aforementioned article, we see numerous scientific flaws. The causal inferences that can be drawn from the observed effects of gender on the mentor-protégé relationship are insubstantial and other aspects of the paper are limited in the reductionist design of their mentor-protégé relationship assessment, which is based on the scientific impact of future papers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kran2021criticism,
author = {Esben Kran and Alina Kereszt and Andrea Dioni Munksgaard and Anita Kurm and Anja Birch Alsøer and Anja Feibel Meerwald and Astrid Elmann Hansen and Bianka Szöllősi and Birgitte Dühring and Blanka Sara Palfi and Cecilie Vestergaard and Christoffer Jensen and David T. Fjendbo and Emily Virginia Hus and Emma Lundkvist Søndergaard and Emma Risgaard Olsen and Emma Rose Hahn and Emma-Louise Albæk Schnedler and Gacilda Anne Soosaipillai and Gustav Helms and Helle Skjøth Sørensen and Jannik Wiggers and Jessica Clarke Rasmussen and Jonathan Hvithamar Rystrøm and J. Jünger and Julie Svinth Nielsen and Jørgen Højlund WIbe and Karen Marie Gjerløff and Klara Krøyer Fomsgaard and Kristine Zenner Torp and Laura Bock Paulsen and Laura Emilie Hollænder and Lina Elkjær Pedersen and Louie Juhl and Manon Éloïse Albeck Grandjean and Maria Nissen Byg and Maria Raunsbæk Thorsø and Maris Sala and Martine Lind Jensen and Mathilde Hyldal Eberholst and Matilde Just Sterup and Mia Jacobsen and Mille Bryske Møller Nielsen and Mina Almasi and Nanna Marie Steenholdt and Nicoline Schmidt and Niels Aalund Krogsgaard and Nina Caroline Høj Illum and Orla Mallon and Pernille Højlund Brams and Pernille Lærke Munk-Hansen and Sara Hansen Viuf and Sarah Hvid Andersen and Sebastian Scott Engen and Sigrid Agersnap Bom Nielsen and Sophie Stenderup Korch and S Hansen and Thea Pedersen and Tobias Grønhøi Hansen and Veronika Juhasz and Victoria Hagelskjær Vilstrøm and Wilhelmina Axelgaard and Andreas Roepstorff and Byurakn Ishkhanyan and Christine E. Parsons and Cordula Vesper and Daina Crafa and Fabio Trecca and Joshua Skewes and Micah Allen and Mikkel Wallentin and Rebekah Baglini},
title = {{Criticism of the paper “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance”}},
booktitle = {Research},
year = {2021},
}Loading related content...