TL;DR
This paper introduces CPS-MEBR, a novel framework that tackles the challenge of retrieving relevant information from long, complex web pages by generating multiple embeddings. It achieves this by first summarizing web pages to extract key sentences, guided by user click data, and then using these summaries to create multi-embedding representations for more effective retrieval.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Modern search engines rely on embedding-based retrieval (EBR) to match user queries with relevant documents. However, representing entire web pages, which can be very long and contain a lot of irrelevant information, with a single embedding is problematic. This single embedding struggles to capture the diverse semantic aspects of a page that might be relevant to different user queries. Furthermore, the computational cost of processing long sequences with Transformer models is a significant bottleneck for industrial-scale applications. Existing methods often fail to effectively filter out noise and redundancy present in web pages, leading to suboptimal retrieval performance.
Methods
The CPS-MEBR framework consists of two main components:
- Click Feedback-Aware Web Page Summarization (Pageformer): This module aims to extract the most relevant sentences from a web page. It leverages a Page-Level Semantic Encoder that uses a Reformer model to handle long sequences efficiently and a Structure-Aware Sentence Classifier that incorporates both semantic and structural information (like HTML tags and Y-axis position) to identify important sentences. A key innovation is the click feedback-aware pre-training task, where the model is trained using user click data from search logs to learn which sentences are most likely to satisfy user intent. This is achieved through a query-guided data mining process that assigns weights to sentences based on their relevance to clicked queries.
- Multi-Embedding-Based Retrieval (MEBR) Model: This component utilizes the key sentences extracted by Pageformer to create multiple embeddings for a web page. Instead of a single embedding, it generates a set of representations, including one for the title and others for the extracted key sentences. These representations are then combined using a sentence-level semantic post-interaction strategy, which injects a global content representation (C) into each sentence-level representation. This approach allows different embeddings to capture distinct aspects of the web page, improving the ability to match diverse queries. The model uses a MaxP (Maximum Pooling) strategy to compute the final retrieval score by taking the maximum similarity across all query and document embeddings.
Datasets
The paper uses the following datasets:
- Training Data: Search log data and manually labeled data, as described in Section 3.2.3.
- Evaluation Datasets:
- Manual: Contains 6,384 queries and 14,7342 query-document pairs, with relevance labels rated on a 5-level scale by experts. The title is highly relevant to the document content in this dataset.
- Hardcase: Features 211 queries and 1,132 query-document pairs, where the title does not fully represent the document, requiring content information for accurate retrieval. Each query has an average of 3 relevant documents (label >= 2).
- Content Hit: A search log dataset with 3503 queries and 14,1055 query-document pairs, where query terms appear more frequently in the content than the title.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Summarization as a Precursor to Retrieval: The core idea is that effectively summarizing a web page by identifying key sentences is crucial for improving multi-embedding-based retrieval, especially for long documents.
- Leveraging Click Data: User click behavior is a powerful signal for understanding user intent and can be effectively used to train summarization models, making them more attuned to what users are actually looking for.
- Structure Matters: Incorporating structural information (like HTML tags and visual layout) alongside semantic information significantly enhances the ability to identify important sentences within a web page.
- Multi-Embedding for Nuance: Representing a document with multiple embeddings, derived from key sentences, allows for a more nuanced capture of its content, enabling better matching with diverse queries compared to a single embedding.
- Addressing Long Document Challenges: The use of Reformer for the page-level encoder and sentence-level interactions in the MEBR model are key to handling the computational complexity and semantic diversity of long web pages.
Key Results
- The proposed CPS-MEBR framework (MEBR-TSC) consistently outperforms various single-embedding-based retrieval (SEBR) baseline models across all three evaluation datasets.
- On the Manual dataset, MEBR-TSC achieves an average recall of 67.45%, outperforming the best SEBR baseline (SEBR-TC) by 0.9%.
- The Hardcase dataset, where content is crucial, shows significant improvements with MEBR-TSC, highlighting its ability to leverage content information effectively.
- Experiments with varying the number of key sentences (Table 2) suggest that using the top 10 sentences provides the best recall performance on average, indicating that beyond a certain point, adding more sentences can introduce noise.
- The weight coefficient λ (Table 3) for combining title and content representations is optimized at 0.8, suggesting a balanced approach between title and content information.
Limitations and Future Work
- Computational Complexity: While the paper addresses computational complexity with Reformer and efficient summarization, it acknowledges that token-level or phrase-level multi-encoders are still infeasible for billion-scale industrial deployment.
- Generalizability of Summarization: The effectiveness of the Pageformer relies on the quality of click data. In scenarios with limited or noisy click data, its performance might be affected.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that their CPS-MEBR framework can be deployed as a complement to existing EBR models, implying potential for further integration and optimization within larger search systems. The exploration of more sophisticated sentence-level semantic interactions and pre-training strategies could also be future directions.
Summary updated