Coupling between infraslow activities and high‐frequency oscillations precedes seizure onset

Hiroaki Hashimoto, Hui Ming Khoo, Takufumi Yanagisawa, Naoki Tani, Satoru Oshino, Haruhiko Kishima, Masayuki HirataEpilepsia 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that a specific brainwave coupling pattern, involving very slow infraslow activity and high-frequency oscillations (HFOs), emerges minutes before a seizure begins. This pre-seizure coupling could serve as a crucial early warning signal for predicting epileptic seizures, offering a new avenue for diagnostic tools.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Epilepsy is characterized by sudden, uncontrolled bursts of electrical activity in the brain, often originating from specific "seizure-onset zones." Researchers have observed two types of brainwave activity in these zones: very slow infraslow oscillations (0.016-1 Hz) and high-frequency oscillations (HFOs, typically >80 Hz). While both are linked to seizures, their precise relationship and how they interact before a seizure remains unclear. Understanding this pre-seizure dynamic is critical for developing predictive biomarkers that could alert patients or clinicians before an event occurs.

Methods

The researchers employed a technique called Phase-Amplitude Coupling (PAC) to investigate the relationship between infraslow activity and HFOs. PAC measures how the phase (the timing or "peak/trough") of a slower brainwave influences the amplitude (the strength or "height") of a faster brainwave.

Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Intracranial EEG (iEEG): They used iEEG, which involves surgically implanting electrodes directly into the brain, to capture high-resolution brain activity from a patient with focal epilepsy. This provides much more detailed data than scalp EEG.
  • Data Acquisition: iEEG signals were recorded at a high sampling rate (1 kHz) for 20 minutes before to 5 minutes after seizure onset.
  • Signal Processing:
    • HFOs: Ripples (80-250 Hz) and fast ripples (250-330 Hz) were extracted using band-pass filtering and Hilbert transforms to get their power over time.
  • Infraslow Activity: A 0.016-1 Hz band-pass filter was used to isolate these very slow waves.
  • PAC Calculation: The synchronization index (SI) was used to quantify PAC, with its magnitude (SIm) ranging from 0 (no coupling) to 1 (perfect coupling). A 1-second sliding window was used for analysis.
  • Statistical Analysis: To determine significance, they used permutation tests and a familywise error (FWE) correction to account for multiple comparisons, ensuring that observed couplings were not due to chance.

Datasets

The study utilized intracranial EEG (iEEG) data from a single 28-year-old male patient diagnosed with focal epilepsy due to a dysembryoplastic neuroepithelial tumor (DNT). Five habitual seizures were recorded and analyzed. This is a case study, not a large-scale dataset analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pre-Seizure Coupling is Key: The most significant finding is that the coupling between the phase of infraslow activity and the amplitude of HFOs emerges before the seizure onset time (SOT). This is a novel observation that differentiates it from post-seizure coupling.
  • Infraslow Activity as a Predictor: While theta (4-8 Hz) phase-amplitude coupling with HFOs was observed after the seizure onset, the infraslow-HFO coupling appeared earlier, suggesting its potential as a predictive biomarker.
  • PAC Detects Subtle Changes: The study highlights that PAC can detect subtle neural interactions that might be missed by conventional visual inspection of iEEG signals, especially for very slow infraslow activities.
  • SOZ Localization: The findings reinforce the idea that the seizure onset zone (SOZ) is associated with the observed infraslow activities and HFOs.

Key Results

  • Post-Seizure HFO Power: A significant increase in HFO power was observed after the seizure onset time (SOT).
  • Post-Seizure Theta-HFO Coupling: Significant coupling between theta (4-8 Hz) phase and HFO amplitude was also observed after the SOT.
  • Pre-Seizure Infraslow-HFO Coupling: Crucially, significant coupling between infraslow activity (0.016-1 Hz) phase and HFO amplitude was detected a few minutes before the SOT. This pre-seizure coupling was observed in the seizure onset zone electrodes and, to a lesser extent, averaged across all electrodes.
  • Timing Differences: The timing of infraslow-HFO coupling detection at specific electrodes (A2) was earlier than the detection of theta-HFO coupling at the same electrodes, and also earlier than the detection of HFO power bursts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Patient Case Study: The most significant limitation is that these findings are based on data from only one patient. It's unclear if this infraslow-HFO coupling pattern is generalizable to other epilepsy types or patients, especially those without brain tumors.
  • Seizure Context: All analyzed seizures occurred after a reduction in antiepileptic drugs, which might influence seizure characteristics.
  • Fast Ripple Bandwidth: The analysis of fast ripples was limited by the sampling rate, potentially missing higher frequencies.

Future Work: The authors suggest analyzing more seizures from a larger cohort of patients to confirm the predictive value of infraslow-HFO coupling. They also propose using simulation methods to further investigate the underlying mechanisms of this coupling. Expanding the analysis to include neocortical epilepsy patients would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Infraslow activities and high-frequency oscillations (HFOs) are observed in seizure-onset zones. However, the relation between them remains unclear. In this study, we investigated phase-amplitude coupling between infraslow phase (0.016-1 Hz) and HFOs' amplitude of focal impaired awareness seizures followed by focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures, in a 28-year-old right-handed man with a dysembryoplastic neuroepithelial tumor. We recorded five habitual seizures. After the time of seizure onset, a significant increase in the power of HFOs was observed, and the power was significantly coupled with θ (4-8 Hz) phase. In contrast, coupling of infraslow activities and HFOs surged a few minutes before the seizure-onset time, and ictal HFOs discharged after that. Collectively, our results show that coupling of infraslow activities and HFOs precedes the seizure-onset time. We infer that such coupling may be a potential biomarker for seizure prediction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hashimoto2020coupling,
  author = {Hiroaki Hashimoto and Hui Ming Khoo and Takufumi Yanagisawa and Naoki Tani and Satoru Oshino and Haruhiko Kishima and Masayuki Hirata},
  title = {{Coupling between infraslow activities and high‐frequency oscillations precedes seizure onset}},
  booktitle = {Epilepsia},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1002/epi4.12425},
}
Figure