Cost-Optimal Learning of Causal Graphs

Murat Kocaoglu, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Sriram Vishwanath

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of learning causal relationships between variables when performing experiments (interventions) has a cost. The authors develop polynomial-time algorithms to find the cheapest set of interventions needed to uniquely identify a causal graph, given its underlying structure (skeleton). They also propose efficient greedy algorithms for scenarios with a limited number of interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Discovering causal relationships is crucial in many scientific fields, from medicine to economics. The gold standard for establishing causality is through randomized controlled trials (experiments). However, these interventions often come with significant costs. For instance, intervening on a variable like "smoking" might be expensive and difficult, while intervening on "cancer" might be impossible. This paper addresses the challenge of designing a set of experiments to learn a causal graph that minimizes the total intervention cost, while still guaranteeing the ability to uniquely identify the true causal structure. This is particularly relevant when the underlying structure of the causal graph is known (its "skeleton"), but the direction of the causal arrows is not.

Methods

The core of the paper's approach lies in connecting causal graph learning with graph theory concepts, specifically graph separating systems and graph colorings.

  • Graph Separating Systems: The authors prove that a set of interventions can uniquely identify any causal graph with a given skeleton if and only if the intervention sets form a G-separating system for the skeleton graph. A G-separating system is a collection of subsets of variables such that for every edge in the graph, there's at least one subset that contains exactly one of the edge's endpoints. This means each edge can be "cut" by at least one intervention.
  • Graph Colorings: They establish a crucial link: any graph separating system can be constructed from a proper graph coloring, and vice-versa. This allows them to reframe the intervention design problem as a graph coloring problem.
  • Cost-Optimal Intervention Design:
    • For chordal graphs (a class of graphs with specific structural properties), they show that the cost-optimal intervention design can be found in polynomial time by identifying the maximum weighted independent set and intervening on the remaining vertices, partitioned by color.
  • When the number of interventions is limited, they formulate the problem as an integer linear program. They show this can be solved in polynomial time for trees and clique trees.
  • For general chordal skeletons, they propose a greedy algorithm that iteratively selects interventions based on coloring the graph. An improved greedy algorithm is presented for interval graphs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithm development and simulation studies on synthetically generated graphs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Necessity of Graph Separating Systems: The paper provides the first formal proof that a set of interventions must form a graph separating system to guarantee learning any causal graph with a given skeleton. This is a fundamental theoretical result.
  • Intervention Design as Graph Coloring: The equivalence between graph separating systems and proper graph colorings is a powerful insight. It allows the problem of finding optimal interventions to be translated into the well-studied domain of graph coloring, enabling the use of existing combinatorial optimization techniques.
  • Structure Dictates Solvability: The paper highlights how the structural properties of the causal graph skeleton (e.g., being a tree, clique tree, chordal, or interval graph) determine whether the cost-optimal intervention design problem can be solved efficiently (in polynomial time).
  • Greedy Approach for General Cases: The development of greedy algorithms offers practical solutions for more complex graph structures where exact polynomial-time solutions might not exist.

Key Results

  • Polynomial-time solvability for chordal graphs: The cost-optimal intervention design problem for chordal graph skeletons can be solved in polynomial time.
  • Polynomial-time solvability for trees and clique trees with bounded interventions: When the number of interventions is limited, polynomial-time solutions exist for tree and clique tree skeletons.
  • Greedy algorithms for general chordal graphs: Efficient greedy algorithms are provided for general chordal skeletons, with an improvement for interval graphs.
  • Theoretical connection: The paper formally establishes that a set of interventions must be a graph separating system for the skeleton to learn any causal graph with that skeleton.

The paper includes simulation results (Figures 2 and 3) showing that their greedy approach achieves low costs, especially for sparse graphs, even with a small number of experiments. The normalized cost increases as the number of experiments decreases or the graph becomes denser.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The paper assumes causal sufficiency (all relevant variables are observed) and faithfulness (all conditional independences are implied by the graph structure). These are common assumptions in causal discovery but can be restrictive in real-world scenarios.
  • Adaptive vs. Non-adaptive: The focus is on non-adaptive intervention designs, where the choice of interventions is fixed beforehand. Adaptive designs, where interventions are chosen sequentially based on previous results, are mentioned as a direction for future work.
  • General Graphs: While greedy algorithms are provided for chordal graphs, the problem for general undirected graphs with a limited number of interventions remains challenging.
  • Real-world data: The simulations are performed on synthetically generated graphs. Applying these methods to real-world datasets would be a valuable next step.
  • Computational Complexity: While polynomial-time solutions are found for specific graph classes, the integer linear programming formulation for limited interventions can still be computationally intensive for large graphs.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of learning a causal graph over a set of variables with interventions. We study the cost-optimal causal graph learning problem: For a given skeleton (undirected version of the causal graph), design the set of interventions with minimum total cost, that can uniquely identify any causal graph with the given skeleton. We show that this problem is solvable in polynomial time. Later, we consider the case when the number of interventions is limited. For this case, we provide polynomial time algorithms when the skeleton is a tree or a clique tree. For a general chordal skeleton, we develop an efficient greedy algorithm, which can be improved when the causal graph skeleton is an interval graph.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kocaoglu2017cost,
  author = {Murat Kocaoglu and Alexandros G. Dimakis and Sriram Vishwanath},
  title = {{Cost-Optimal Learning of Causal Graphs}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Machine Learning},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure