Cost-aware green cellular networks with energy and communication cooperation

Jie Xu, Lingjie Duan, Rui Zhang

TL;DR

This paper proposes novel approaches for cellular networks to significantly reduce energy costs by intelligently coordinating energy harvesting, grid power, and communication resource allocation. By treating energy and communication as intertwined resources, the authors demonstrate substantial cost savings through various cooperation strategies, paving the way for more sustainable and economical mobile networks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ever-increasing demand for mobile data is driving the deployment of more cellular base stations (BSs), leading to a surge in energy consumption and operational expenditure (OPEX). For instance, China Mobile alone spent nearly $3 billion on energy for its 920,000 BSs in 2011. While renewable energy sources like solar and wind offer a greener alternative, their intermittent nature and spatial variability make it challenging for individual BSs to rely solely on harvested energy. Simultaneously, traditional communication cooperation strategies, designed for maximizing throughput or minimizing energy consumption, may not be cost-effective when considering the cheaper price of renewable energy. This paper addresses the critical need to develop integrated energy and communication strategies that leverage both renewable energy and smart grid capabilities to minimize the overall energy cost of cellular networks.

Methods

The paper introduces three main categories of cooperation strategies:

  • Energy Cooperation (Supply Side): BSs leverage the two-way energy flow in smart grids to trade or share harvested renewable energy. This is facilitated by an "aggregator" that acts as an intermediary, allowing BSs with surplus energy to sell it and those with deficits to buy it at potentially lower prices than grid power. Two specific schemes are discussed:
  • Aggregator-Assisted Energy Trading: BSs buy and sell energy to an aggregator at pre-determined prices.
  • Aggregator-Assisted Energy Sharing: BSs mutually negotiate and share energy through the aggregator, aiming to balance local deficits and surpluses within a group.
  • Communication Cooperation (Demand Side): BSs share wireless resources and reshape traffic loads to reduce energy consumption, while considering the available energy supply. Three cost-aware schemes are presented:
  • Cost-Aware Traffic Offloading: BSs with surplus renewable energy can accept traffic from neighboring BSs that are short of energy, even if the latter have similar or lighter loads.
  • Cost-Aware Spectrum Sharing: BSs can share spectrum resources, allowing a BS short on energy to reduce its transmission power while another BS with abundant renewable energy can utilize its spectrum more.
  • Cost-Aware Coordinated Multi-Point (CoMP): BSs cooperatively transmit signals to mobile terminals, allowing for adaptive adjustment of transmission power to match harvested renewable energy, thereby minimizing grid power consumption.
  • Joint Energy and Communication Cooperation (Both Sides): This approach combines strategies from both energy and communication cooperation to achieve maximum cost savings. The paper explores six potential combinations, focusing on three specific examples:
  • Joint energy and spectrum sharing.
  • Joint energy cooperation (trading/sharing) and CoMP.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper presents a case study with simulated parameters for two BSs and their associated mobile terminals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Energy and Communication are Intertwined: The core insight is that energy and communication resources are not independent. By jointly optimizing them, significant cost savings can be achieved beyond optimizing each in isolation.
  • The Aggregator is Key: For large-scale cellular networks, an aggregator is crucial for managing energy trading and sharing, simplifying coordination with the smart grid.
  • Renewable Energy is Cheaper, Use It Wisely: The paper emphasizes that renewable energy, despite its unreliability, is cheaper. Cooperation strategies should prioritize its utilization to offset grid power costs.
  • Cost-Awareness is Crucial: Traditional communication cooperation focused on throughput or energy efficiency needs to be re-evaluated with a cost-aware perspective, considering the price difference between renewable and grid energy.
  • Joint Cooperation Offers Maximum Savings: The case study clearly demonstrates that combining energy and communication cooperation strategies yields the most substantial cost reductions.

Key Results

The paper's case study, comparing various cooperation schemes for a two-BS system, highlights significant cost savings:

  • Conventional Design: Total energy cost of 15.78.
  • Energy Cooperation (Aggregator-Assisted Trading/Sharing): Reduced total energy cost to 10.51 and 10.03, respectively.
  • Communication Cooperation (Spectrum Sharing/CoMP): Reduced total energy cost to 11.54 and 1.25, respectively.
  • Joint Energy and Communication Cooperation:
    • Joint energy and spectrum sharing: Total energy cost of 7.60.
  • Joint energy cooperation and CoMP: Achieved the lowest total energy costs of 0.46 (aggregator-assisted energy trading) and 0.10 (aggregator-assisted energy sharing).

These results show that joint cooperation, particularly with CoMP, can lead to near-zero energy costs by maximizing the use of renewable energy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Implementation Complexity: Joint energy and communication cooperation, especially when requiring real-time decisions and frequent information exchange, can be complex to implement and may require significant infrastructure upgrades (e.g., high-capacity backhaul).
  • Multi-Time Scale Cooperation: The paper suggests exploring multi-time scale implementations where energy cooperation operates on a longer timescale than communication cooperation to balance cost savings and complexity.
  • Inter-System Cooperation: The authors propose investigating cooperation between multiple self-interested cellular systems (owned by different operators) and heterogeneous networks (e.g., WiFi and small cells).
  • Energy Storage Integration: The current work does not consider energy storage at BSs. Future research could integrate energy storage management with energy and communication cooperation to further enhance reliability and cost savings.
  • Scalability: While the paper focuses on a limited number of BSs, scalability to large networks remains an area for further study, potentially through clustering approaches.

Summary updated

Abstract

Energy cost of cellular networks is ever-increasing to match the surge of wireless data traffic, and the saving of this cost is important to reduce the operational expenditure (OPEX) of wireless operators in future. The recent advancements of renewable energy integration and two-way energy flow in smart grid provide potential new solutions to save the cost. However, they also impose challenges, especially on how to use the stochastically and spatially distributed renewable energy harvested at cellular base stations (BSs) to reliably supply time- and space-varying wireless traffic over cellular networks. To overcome these challenges, in this article we present three approaches, namely, {\emph{energy cooperation, communication cooperation, and joint energy and communication cooperation}}, in which different BSs bidirectionally trade or share energy via the aggregator in smart grid, and/or share wireless resources and shift loads with each other to reduce the total energy cost.
BibTeX
@article{xu2015cost,
  author = {Jie Xu and Lingjie Duan and Rui Zhang},
  title = {{Cost-aware green cellular networks with energy and communication cooperation}},
  journal = {IEEE Communications Magazine},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1109/mcom.2015.7105673},
}
Figure