Cosmology Intertwined I: Perspectives for the Next Decade

Eleonora Di Valentino, Luis A. Anchordoqui, Özgür Akarsu, Yacine Ali-Haïmoud, Luca Amendola, Nikki Arendse, Marika Asgari, M. Ballardini, Spyros Basilakos, E. S. Battistelli, Micol Benetti, Simon Birrer, F. R. Bouchet, Marco Bruni, Erminia Calabrese, David Camarena, Salvatore Capozzıello, Angela Chen, Jens Chluba, Anton Chudaykin, Eoin Ó Colgáin, Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine, P. de Bernardis, Javier de Cruz Pérez, Jacques Delabrouille, Jo Dunkley, Celia Escamilla‐Rivera, A. Ferté, F. Finelli⋆, Wendy L. Freedman, Noemi Frusciante, Elena Giusarma, Adrià Gómez-Valent, Will Handley, I. Harrison, Luke Hart, Alan Heavens, H. Hildebrandt, D. E. Holz, Dragan Huterer, Mikhail M. Ivanov, Shahab Joudaki, Marc Kamionkowski, Tanvi Karwal, Lloyd Knox, Suresh Kumar, Luca Lamagna, J. Lesgourgues, Matteo Lucca, Valerio Marra, Silvia Masi, S. Matarrese, Arindam Mazumdar, A. Melchiorri, Olga Mena, Laura Mersini–Houghton, Vivian Miranda, Cristian Moreno-Pulido, David F. Mota, J. Muir, Ankan Mukherjee, Florian Niedermann, Alessio Notari, Rafael C. Nunes, Francesco Pace, Andronikos Paliathanasis, A. Palmese, Supriya Pan, D. Paoletti, V. Pettorino, F. Piacentini, Vivian Poulin, Marco Raveri, Adam G. Riess, Vincenzo Salzano, Emmanuel N. Saridakis, Anjan A. Sen, Arman Shafieloo, Anowar J. Shajib, Joseph Silk, Alessandra Silvestri, Martin S. Sloth, Tristan L. Smith, Joan Solà, Carsten van de Bruck, Licia Verde, Luca Visinelli, B. D. Wandelt, Deng Wang, Jian‐Min Wang, Anil Kumar Yadav, Weiqiang Yang

TL;DR

While the $\Lambda$CDM (Lambda Cold Dark Matter) model has been the "gold standard" of cosmology for decades, recent high-precision data has revealed cracks in the foundation, most notably the "Hubble tension." This paper outlines a strategic roadmap for the next decade, arguing that resolving these discrepancies requires a transition from treating $\Lambda$CDM as an effective model to a fundamental physical one through a massive influx of data from next-generation observatories like LSST, Euclid, and CMB-S4.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For years, cosmologists have relied on the $\Lambda$CDM model to explain everything from the Big Bang's afterglow to the distribution of galaxies. However, as our measurements have become more precise, different methods of measuring the universe's expansion rate (the Hubble constant, $H_0$) and the "clumpiness" of matter ($\sigma_8$) have begun to disagree.

The "Hubble tension" is now a full-blown crisis, with a discrepancy of over $4\sigma$ between early-universe predictions (based on the Cosmic Microwave Background) and late-universe observations (using supernovae and "distance ladders"). This paper addresses the urgent need to determine if these tensions are merely systematic errors in our instruments or "smoking guns" for new physics—such as modified gravity, dark radiation, or non-standard inflation—that lies beyond the Standard Model.

Methods

As a "Letter of Interest" for the Snowmass2021 planning process, this paper does not present a single new algorithm. Instead, it synthesizes a multi-disciplinary methodology for the next decade of research:

  • Cross-Calibration: Using "Standard Sirens" (gravitational waves from merging black holes/neutron stars) as an independent check on traditional "Standard Candles" (supernovae).
  • Multi-Messenger Synergy: Combining data from galaxy clustering (Euclid/LSST), radio interferometry (SKA), and CMB polarization (CMB-S4) to break parameter degeneracies.
  • Systematic Rigor: Moving toward "de-standardizing" $\Lambda$CDM assumptions in analysis pipelines to ensure that we aren't accidentally "baking in" the model we are trying to test.
  • Non-linear Modeling: Improving the theoretical understanding of physics on smaller, non-linear scales where traditional perturbation theory fails.

Datasets

The paper highlights a suite of upcoming "Stage IV" experiments and missions that will provide the data necessary to stress-test the current model:

  • CMB-S4: The next generation of ground-based Cosmic Microwave Background experiments.
  • LSST (Vera C. Rubin Observatory): A 10-year survey that will chart 20 billion galaxies.
  • Euclid & Roman Space Telescopes: Space-based missions focused on dark energy and cosmic acceleration.
  • Square Kilometre Array (SKA): A massive radio telescope array that will probe the "Dark Ages" via the 21 cm hydrogen line.
  • LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA: Gravitational wave detectors providing "standard siren" distance measurements.
  • CERN’s LHC (ATLAS/CMS/FASER): Searching for the particle nature of dark matter and light relics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "First-Order" Realization: The authors suggest $\Lambda$CDM should be viewed as a brilliant first-order approximation, much like Newtonian physics was to Einstein. The current tensions are likely the "higher-order" effects showing us the way to a more realistic theory.
  • Intertwined Anomalies: The $H_0$ tension, the $S_8$ tension, and anomalies in the Planck satellite data (like the "lensing excess") are likely related. Solving one in isolation may be impossible; they must be addressed as an "intertwined" cosmological puzzle.
  • The Power of $N_{eff}$: Measuring the "effective number of relativistic species" ($N_{eff}$) with a precision of $\Delta N_{eff} \leq 0.06$ (via CMB-S4) will be a definitive test for the existence of "light relics"—particles like sterile neutrinos or axions that could have influenced the early universe.
  • Cosmic Voids as Probes: Beyond just looking at where galaxies are, the paper emphasizes looking at where they aren't. The geometry and expansion of $O(10^5)$ cosmic voids can distinguish between different gravity models.

Key Results

The paper sets ambitious quantitative targets for the next ten years:

  • Hubble Precision: Achieving a 1% precision in $H_0$ measurements through local distance ladders and a 1.5% precision via gravitational time delays.
  • Gravitational Waves: Constraining $H_0$ to ~2% within five years and 1% within a decade using the LIGO-Virgo network.
  • Galaxy Mapping: LSST is expected to provide multiple simultaneous probes of dark energy and dark matter by charting billions of galaxies across the sky.
  • Redshift Reach: SKA will detect the 21 cm emission line from a billion galaxies out to a redshift of $z \sim 2$, providing a map of the universe's expansion during its middle ages.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation acknowledged is the current "impossibility" of solving all cosmological tensions simultaneously with existing models. Many proposed solutions to the $H_0$ tension actually worsen the $S_8$ tension, and vice versa.

Future work must focus on "blinded" data analysis to prevent confirmation bias and a heavy investment in "beyond-$\Lambda$CDM" theoretical frameworks. The authors conclude that the next decade won't just provide better numbers; it will likely force a fundamental shift in our understanding of the evolution of the cosmos.

Summary updated

Abstract

The standard $Λ$ Cold Dark Matter cosmological model provides an amazing description of a wide range of astrophysical and astronomical data. However, there are a few big open questions, that make the standard model look like a first-order approximation to a more realistic scenario that still needs to be fully understood. In this Letter of Interest we will list a few important goals that need to be addressed in the next decade, also taking into account the current discordances present between the different cosmological probes, as the Hubble constant $H_0$ value, the $σ_8 - S_8$ tension, and the anomalies present in the Planck results. Finally, we will give an overview of upgraded experiments and next-generation space-missions and facilities on Earth, that will be of crucial importance to address all these questions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{valentino2021cosmology,
  author = {Eleonora Di Valentino and Luis A. Anchordoqui and Özgür Akarsu and Yacine Ali-Haïmoud and Luca Amendola and Nikki Arendse and Marika Asgari and M. Ballardini and Spyros Basilakos and E. S. Battistelli and Micol Benetti and Simon Birrer and F. R. Bouchet and Marco Bruni and Erminia Calabrese and David Camarena and Salvatore Capozzıello and Angela Chen and Jens Chluba and Anton Chudaykin and Eoin Ó Colgáin and Francis-Yan Cyr-Racine and P. de Bernardis and Javier de Cruz Pérez and Jacques Delabrouille and Jo Dunkley and Celia Escamilla‐Rivera and A. Ferté and F. Finelli⋆ and Wendy L. Freedman and Noemi Frusciante and Elena Giusarma and Adrià Gómez-Valent and Will Handley and I. Harrison and Luke Hart and Alan Heavens and H. Hildebrandt and D. E. Holz and Dragan Huterer and Mikhail M. Ivanov and Shahab Joudaki and Marc Kamionkowski and Tanvi Karwal and Lloyd Knox and Suresh Kumar and Luca Lamagna and J. Lesgourgues and Matteo Lucca and Valerio Marra and Silvia Masi and S. Matarrese and Arindam Mazumdar and A. Melchiorri and Olga Mena and Laura Mersini–Houghton and Vivian Miranda and Cristian Moreno-Pulido and David F. Mota and J. Muir and Ankan Mukherjee and Florian Niedermann and Alessio Notari and Rafael C. Nunes and Francesco Pace and Andronikos Paliathanasis and A. Palmese and Supriya Pan and D. Paoletti and V. Pettorino and F. Piacentini and Vivian Poulin and Marco Raveri and Adam G. Riess and Vincenzo Salzano and Emmanuel N. Saridakis and Anjan A. Sen and Arman Shafieloo and Anowar J. Shajib and Joseph Silk and Alessandra Silvestri and Martin S. Sloth and Tristan L. Smith and Joan Solà and Carsten van de Bruck and Licia Verde and Luca Visinelli and B. D. Wandelt and Deng Wang and Jian‐Min Wang and Anil Kumar Yadav and Weiqiang Yang},
  title = {{Cosmology Intertwined I: Perspectives for the Next Decade}},
  booktitle = {Astroparticle},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.astropartphys.2021.102606},
}
Figure