Cosmological constraints on decaying axion-like particles: a global analysis

Csaba Balázs, Sanjay Bloor, Tomás E. Gonzalo, Will Handley, Sebastian Hoof, Felix Kahlhoefer, Marie Lecroq, David J. E. Marsh, Janina J. Renk, Pat Scott, Patrick Stöcker

TL;DR

Researchers have performed the first "global analysis" of Axion-Like Particles (ALPs) that decay into photons between the eras of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). By combining multiple cosmological and astrophysical datasets, they established a new lower bound on the ALP mass of approximately 300 keV, closing a significant window for these elusive particles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Axion-Like Particles (ALPs) are theoretical cousins of the axion, a particle proposed to solve fundamental symmetry problems in physics. ALPs are also top candidates for dark matter. However, most studies assume ALPs are either stable enough to be dark matter today or were once in perfect thermal equilibrium with the early universe.

This paper tackles a "middle ground" gap: ALPs with masses in the keV–MeV range that are produced via a "freeze-in" mechanism (never reaching thermal equilibrium) and decay into photons between 1 second and 300,000 years after the Big Bang. These decays would inject energy into the early universe, potentially altering the abundance of light elements (like Deuterium) or distorting the "perfect" blackbody spectrum of the CMB. Until now, these constraints were often studied in isolation; this paper seeks to unify them.

Methods

The authors utilized the GAMBIT (Global and Astro-particle Merging Bayesian Inference Tool) framework, specifically its CosmoBit module.

What makes this approach novel is the Global Fit: instead of checking one constraint at a time while holding other variables fixed, the authors varied the ALP mass ($m_a$), coupling ($g_{a\gamma}$), and abundance ($\xi$) simultaneously with standard $\Lambda$CDM cosmological parameters (like the Hubble constant $H_0$) and "nuisance" parameters (experimental uncertainties).

Key technical components included:

  • micrOMEGAs: To calculate the "irreducible freeze-in abundance"—the minimum amount of ALPs that must exist due to interactions in the primordial plasma.
  • CLASS & ACROPOLIS: To model how ALP decays photodisintegrate light nuclei and affect CMB anisotropies.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: Specifically for SN1987A data, to model how ALPs emitted from a supernova would decay into detectable gamma rays.

Datasets

The study integrated a massive array of observational data:

  • CMB Anisotropies: Planck 2018 (TT, TE, EE + lensing).
  • CMB Spectral Distortions: COBE/FIRAS data (and projections for a future mission called PIXIE).
  • BBN Abundances: Primordial measurements of Deuterium, Helium-3, Helium-4, and Lithium-7.
  • Astrophysics: Gamma-ray limits from Supernova SN1987A and energy-loss constraints from Horizontal Branch stars in globular clusters.
  • Late-time Cosmology: BOSS DR12 (Baryon Acoustic Oscillations) and Pantheon (Type Ia Supernovae).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Irreducible" Floor: Even if you assume no ALPs were created at the beginning of the universe, the "Primakoff process" ($\gamma + \text{charged particle} \to a + \text{charged particle}$) in the hot early plasma creates a guaranteed minimum population of ALPs. This "floor" makes the cosmological constraints much harder for ALPs to evade.
  • A Helpful Decay?: Interestingly, the authors found that ALP decays can actually improve the fit to BBN data. There is a slight tension in standard cosmology regarding the ratio of Deuterium to Baryon density. ALP decays can break down Helium-4 into Deuterium (photodisintegration), potentially resolving this minor discrepancy.
  • The SN1987A + CMB Pincer: SN1987A provides a "ceiling" on how strong the ALP-photon coupling can be. If the coupling is weak (to satisfy SN1987A), the ALPs live longer. If they live longer, they decay closer to the time of the CMB, where they are then hammered by spectral distortion limits from FIRAS. This "pincer move" effectively eliminates light, unstable ALPs.

Key Results

  • Mass Bound: The analysis robustly excludes unstable ALPs with masses below $m_a \approx 300$ keV. This bound is largely independent of the specific reheating temperature of the universe.
  • Best Fit: The global best-fit point occurs at $m_a \approx 126$ MeV and a lifetime of $\tau_a \approx 6 \times 10^9$ seconds. While this fits the data slightly better than the standard $\Lambda$CDM model (due to the Deuterium effect mentioned above), the improvement is not statistically significant enough to claim a discovery.
  • Future Sensitivity: The authors show that a future mission like PIXIE (designed to measure CMB spectral distortions with much higher precision) could improve the mass bound by two orders of magnitude, potentially detecting ALPs that are currently invisible.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Coupling Assumptions: This study focused exclusively on ALP-photon coupling. In many models, ALPs also couple to electrons or hadrons, which would introduce new constraints from white dwarfs or different BBN processes.
  • The Lithium Problem: While ALP decays helped with Deuterium, they did not solve the long-standing "Cosmological Lithium Problem" (the discrepancy between predicted and observed Lithium-7).
  • Reheating Sensitivity: While the 300 keV bound is robust, the exact "allowed" regions of parameter space still depend on the assumed reheating temperature ($T_R$) of the early universe, which remains an unknown variable.

The authors suggest that the next step is expanding this global framework to include ALP-matter couplings and more complex production scenarios, such as the misalignment mechanism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Axion-like particles (ALPs) decaying into photons are known to affect a wide range of astrophysical and cosmological observables. In this study we focus on ALPs with masses in the keV–MeV range and lifetimes between 10 4 and 10 13 seconds, corresponding to decays between the end of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis and the formation of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). Using the CosmoBit module of the global fitting framework GAMBIT , we combine state-of-the-art calculations of the irreducible ALP freeze-in abundance, primordial element abundances (including photodisintegration through ALP decays), CMB spectral distortions and anisotropies, and constraints from supernovae and stellar cooling. This approach makes it possible for the first time to perform a global analysis of the ALP parameter space while varying the parameters of ΛCDM as well as several nuisance parameters. We find a lower bound on the ALP mass of around m a > 300 keV, which can only be evaded if ALPs are stable on cosmological timescales. Future observations of CMB spectral distortions with a PIXIE-like mission are expected to improve this bound by two orders of magnitude.
BibTeX
@article{balazs2022cosmological,
  author = {Csaba Balázs and Sanjay Bloor and Tomás E. Gonzalo and Will Handley and Sebastian Hoof and Felix Kahlhoefer and Marie Lecroq and David J. E. Marsh and Janina J. Renk and Pat Scott and Patrick Stöcker},
  title = {{Cosmological constraints on decaying axion-like particles: a global analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2022/12/027},
}

Loading related content...

Figure