Correlated Dirac semimetal by periodized cluster dynamical mean-field theory

Qing-Xiao Li, Rong-Qiang He, Zhong-Yi LuPhysical 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The nature of the phase transition in the half-filled Hubbard model on a honeycomb lattice has been a subject of intense debate. This paper employs Periodized Cluster Dynamical Mean-Field Theory (PCDMFT) with exact diagonalization to resolve discrepancies caused by translation symmetry breaking in standard cluster methods. The study identifies a stable correlated Dirac semimetal at weak interactions that transitions directly into an antiferromagnetic insulator via a first-order quantum phase transition at $U_c \approx 3.7t$, ruling out an intermediate spin liquid phase.

Introduction

The honeycomb lattice, the structural basis of graphene, is a focal point in condensed matter physics due to its unique electronic properties, specifically the presence of massless Dirac fermions. When electron-electron interactions are introduced via the Hubbard model, the system's behavior becomes complex. A central question has been whether a "quantum spin liquid" phase exists between the semimetallic and antiferromagnetic insulating states.

Previous computational approaches, such as standard Cluster Dynamical Mean-Field Theory (CDMFT), often struggle with the honeycomb lattice because they break its translation symmetry. This leads to artificial results, such as predicting an insulating state even at very low interaction strengths. This paper aims to fix that symmetry problem to get a clearer picture of the phase transition.

Methodology: Restoring Translation Symmetry

To address these limitations, the authors utilize Periodized Cluster Dynamical Mean-Field Theory (PCDMFT). By periodizing the self-energy of a six-site hexagonal cluster, the method restores the partial translation symmetry of the original lattice. This approach provides a more balanced description of electron correlations than either standard CDMFT (which is too "loose" and breaks symmetry) or the Dynamic Cluster Approximation (DCA, which is often too "stiff"). The cluster problem is solved using Exact Diagonalization (ED), providing high precision at zero temperature.

The Correlated Dirac Semimetal Phase

A primary success of the PCDMFT approach is the recovery of the Dirac semimetal phase in the weak-interaction regime.

Density of states for various interaction strengths U, showing the characteristic V-shape of a Dirac semimetal at low U.

As illustrated in the Density of States (DOS) calculations (Figure 2), the system maintains a characteristic V-shape near the Fermi level ($\omega=0$) for interaction strengths up to $U=3.0t$. This linear behavior confirms that the electrons remain in a semimetallic state despite the presence of correlations. The PCDMFT effectively cures the "spurious" gap opening observed in non-periodized cluster methods, confirming the existence of a "correlated Dirac semimetal."

The First-Order Phase Transition

As the interaction strength $U$ increases beyond a critical threshold, the system undergoes a dramatic change.

Staggered magnetization as a function of U/t, illustrating the first-order transition and the associated hysteresis loop.

The transition to an antiferromagnetic insulator occurs at $U_c \approx 3.7t$. This value is in excellent agreement with large-scale Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations ($U_c \approx 3.8t$). As shown in Figure 4, the staggered magnetization exhibits a sharp jump and a clear hysteresis loop (indicated by the arrows). This history-dependent behavior is a hallmark of a first-order quantum phase transition.

Crucially, the data shows a direct jump from the semimetal (zero magnetization, zero gap) to the antiferromagnet (finite magnetization, finite gap). The absence of an intermediate region where the gap is open but magnetization is zero suggests that a spin liquid phase does not exist for this specific model on the honeycomb lattice.

Conclusion

The application of PCDMFT provides a clear resolution to the debate surrounding the honeycomb Hubbard model. By restoring translation symmetry, the researchers demonstrated that the transition from a correlated Dirac semimetal to an antiferromagnetic insulator is a direct, first-order event. This work highlights the importance of symmetry preservation in numerical simulations of quantum materials and provides a robust framework for studying other frustrated lattice systems where translation symmetry breaking is a known hurdle.

Summary updated

Abstract

The periodized cluster dynamical mean-field theory (PCDMFT) combined with exact diagonalization as the impurity solver has been applied to the half-filled standard Hubbard model on the honeycomb lattice. A correlated Dirac semimetal is found for weak interactions and it transforms into an antiferromagnetic insulating phase for strong interactions via a first-order quantum phase transition, not intervened by a spin liquid phase in between. In this application, the PCDMFT introduces the partial translation symmetry, but cures well the problem caused by the translation symmetry breaking in the cluster dynamical mean-field theory studies for the same model, which gives rise to a spurious insulating phase in the weakly interacting region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2015correlated,
  author = {Qing-Xiao Li and Rong-Qiang He and Zhong-Yi Lu},
  title = {{Correlated Dirac semimetal by periodized cluster dynamical mean-field theory}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.92.155127},
}
Figure