Overview
This document serves as a formal correction to the review article titled "Thermochromic phantoms and paint to characterize and model image-guided thermal ablation and ablation devices: a review." In the field of medical physics, review papers act as foundational guides for researchers and clinicians. Consequently, maintaining the accuracy of the "Version of Record" is paramount for ensuring that the scientific community can reliably trace the development of hyperthermia technologies and phantom characterization.
The Importance of Bibliographic Accuracy
The original review paper is a critical resource for those developing thermal therapies, such as High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound (HIFU). It details the use of thermochromic phantoms—materials like gels or polymers infused with temperature-sensitive dyes—that change color to provide a real-time visual map of heat distribution. This allows for the empirical validation of computational models and the assessment of device safety.
The corrections provided in this notice address three specific types of errors:
- Misattributed Citations: A primary reference was incorrectly linked to a commercial website rather than a peer-reviewed journal article.
- Author Disambiguation: Two separate papers by the same lead author (A. Eranki) were swapped, leading to potential confusion between studies on mechanical "boiling histotripsy" and "tissue-mimicking phantoms."
- Broken or Misplaced Links: A specific URL for temperature-sensitive material was corrected to ensure researchers can access technical specifications.
Key Bibliographic Updates
The "results" of this correction notice are the updated and verified citations:
- Reference 1: Now correctly cites Kok, H.P., et al. (2020). Heating technology for malignant tumors: a review. International Journal of Hyperthermia, 37(1), 711–741. This replaces a link to a commercial product page with a comprehensive scientific overview.
- Reference 19: Now correctly cites the study on tissue-mimicking thermochromic phantoms published in the International Journal of Hyperthermia (2019).
- Reference 96: Now correctly cites the study on boiling histotripsy published in PLoS ONE (2017).
- Technical Documentation: The citation on page 7 now includes the correct direct link to the SpotSee heatmark indicator technology.
Impact on the Field
By disambiguating these references, the authors ensure that researchers looking for specific methodologies—such as the creation of tissue-mimicking phantoms versus mechanical ablation techniques—are not misled. This correction preserves the utility of the original review as a definitive starting point for new research.
Future work in this sub-field involves the development of "reusable" phantoms that can reset their color state rapidly and the creation of materials that more accurately mimic the complex thermal properties of perfused human tissue, where blood flow significantly impacts heat dissipation.
Summary updated