Coordination and Control of Multiple Climbing Robots in Transporting Heavy Loads through Extreme Terrain

Himangshu Kalita, Steven Morad, Jekan Thangavelautham

Introduction: The Challenge of Lunar Polar Exploration

The lunar North and South poles contain permanently shadowed regions (PSRs) that are believed to harbor significant deposits of water ice. These resources are critical for future lunar bases and as a source for interplanetary refueling. However, accessing these deposits requires navigating some of the most rugged and coldest environments in the solar system, characterized by steep crater walls and extreme terrain.

Lunar polar maps showing ice exposures constrained by various instruments (M3, LOLA, Diviner, and LAMP) at the North (A) and South (B) poles.

Traditional heavy rovers face significant risks in these environments; a single mechanical failure or loss of traction on a steep slope can result in mission termination. To address these challenges, researchers at the University of Arizona have proposed a resilient, distributed multi-robot system capable of transporting heavy payloads through extreme terrain by distributing weight and control across a swarm of smaller, reconfigurable robots.

System Architecture and Gripping Physics

The proposed system utilizes a team of small, spherical robots (approximately 30 cm in diameter and 3 kg in mass) equipped with "microspine" gripping technology. These microspines consist of numerous tiny hooks that allow the robots to anchor themselves to rugged surfaces, similar to how alpinists use ice axes.

Schematic of the multi-robot transport system on an inclined plane (left) and the corresponding vector model for dynamics and control (right).

The robots are connected to a central payload via passive viscoelastic tethers. This configuration allows for a "hop and grip" movement strategy where robots move sequentially, ensuring the payload is always securely anchored by the remaining stationary robots. The gripping force is modeled as a function of surface roughness and spine tip radius, identifying a critical trade-off: smaller tips can grip smoother surfaces but have a lower maximum load capacity.

Dynamics, Optimization, and Motion Planning

The system's dynamics are modeled using Kelvin-Voight viscoelastic connections to account for tether elasticity and damping during transport. To optimize the robot-payload configuration, the team employed the NSGA-II (Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm II). This evolutionary approach determines the optimal number of robots and their specific attachment points to maximize travel distance while minimizing payload oscillations.

For real-time navigation, the researchers implemented the LBKPIECE algorithm from the Open Motion Planning Library (OMPL). By simplifying the state space to an inclined plane and utilizing the triangle inequality to maintain robot proximity, the high-dimensional planning problem was made computationally feasible for low-power space-grade hardware.

Key Results and Insights

Simulations demonstrated that the multi-robot system could successfully transport a 10 kg payload—over three times the mass of an individual robot—up and down $15^\circ$ slopes. The evolutionary algorithm effectively identified configurations that minimized payload "sloshing" and instability. Furthermore, the motion planner successfully navigated a $256m^2$ simulated environment based on the Victoria Crater on Mars, finding safe paths through steep terrain in under five seconds on standard hardware.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research presents a robust alternative to traditional heavy rovers for extreme terrain exploration. By leveraging a distributed "climbing team" approach, the system mitigates single-point failure risks and enables the transport of heavy ISRU equipment. Future work will focus on extending the motion planning to full 3D dynamics and addressing practical challenges such as tether entanglement and operation in the extreme thermal environments of the lunar night.

Summary updated

Abstract

The discovery of ice deposits in the permanently shadowed craters of the lunar North and South Pole Moon presents an important opportunity for In-Situ Resource Utilization. These ice deposits maybe the source for sustaining a lunar base or for enabling an interplanetary refueling station. These ice deposits also preserve a unique record of the geology and environment of their hosts, both in terms of impact history and the supply of volatile compounds, and so are of immense scientific interest. To date, these ice deposits have been studied indirectly and by remote active radar, but they need to be analyzed in-situ by robotic systems that can study the depths of the deposits, their purity and composition. However, these shadowed craters never see sunlight and are one of the coldest places in the solar system. NASA JPL proposed use of solar reflectors mounted on crater rims to project sunlight into the crater depths for use by ground robots. The solar reflectors would heat the crater base and vehicles positioned at the base sufficiently to survive the cold-temperatures. Our approach analyzes part of the logistics of the approach, with teams of robots climbing up and down to the crater to access the ice deposits. The mission will require robots to climb down extreme environments and carry large structures, including instruments and communication devices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kalita2019coordination,
  author = {Himangshu Kalita and Steven Morad and Jekan Thangavelautham},
  title = {{Coordination and Control of Multiple Climbing Robots in Transporting Heavy Loads through Extreme Terrain}},
  booktitle = {AIAA},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.2514/6.2019-0870},
}
Figure