Cooperative Satellite-Aerial-Terrestrial Systems: A Stochastic Geometry Model

Zhe Song, Jianping An, Gaofeng Pan, Shuai Wang, Haoxing Zhang, Yunfei Chen, Mohamed‐Slim Alouini

TL;DR

This paper introduces a robust mathematical framework using stochastic geometry to evaluate the performance of integrated satellite-aerial-terrestrial networks (SATNs). By modeling aerial transmitters with a Matérn hard-core point process—which accounts for real-world safety distances between drones—the authors derive closed-form expressions for end-to-end outage probability, providing a vital tool for designing reliable 6G "space-air-ground" communication systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we move toward 6G, achieving "seamless global coverage" requires integrating satellites, high-altitude platforms, and low-altitude drones (UAVs). However, analyzing these systems is incredibly complex.

Most existing research focuses on isolated parts of the link (just the uplink or just the downlink) or assumes fixed, idealized positions for all devices. In reality, aerial devices are distributed randomly across the sky, and they often share the same frequency bands, leading to significant Multi-User Interference (MUI). Furthermore, direct links between drones and ground stations are often blocked by obstacles or distance, necessitating the use of satellites or a chain of aerial relays. This paper tackles the challenge of modeling these end-to-end (e2e) connections while accounting for random spatial distributions, interference, and hostile jamming.

Methods

The researchers employed Stochastic Geometry to model the spatial randomness of the network:

  • Matérn Hard-Core Point Process (MHCPP) Type-II: Unlike a standard Poisson process, this model is used for aerial transmitters because it enforces a "hard-core" minimum safety distance ($D_{min}$) between drones, reflecting real-world aviation safety requirements.
  • Poisson Point Process (PPP): Used to model the distribution of hostile aerial jammers near the terrestrial destination.
  • Fading Models: The authors used Nakagami-m fading for aerial-to-aerial links and the Shadowed-Rician model for satellite-to-ground links to capture realistic signal fluctuations.
  • Relaying Scheme: They analyzed a Decode-and-Forward (DF) protocol across two paths: a single-hop satellite relay and a multi-hop chain of aerial relays.

The core contribution is the derivation of exact, closed-form analytical expressions for the Probability Density Function (PDF) and Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) of the Signal-to-Interference Ratio (SIR), which are then used to calculate the Outage Probability (OP).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical contribution, the authors used Monte-Carlo simulations (with $10^6$ realizations) to validate their mathematical derivations rather than training on external datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Safety Distance" Benefit: Increasing the minimum safety distance between drones ($D_{min}$) actually improves network performance. By forcing drones further apart, the density of interferers near the receiver decreases, reducing the overall MUI.
  • Uplink Distance Neutrality: Interestingly, the absolute distance to the satellite has a relatively small impact on the uplink outage probability. This is because both the target signal and the interfering signals from other drones suffer the same path loss as they travel toward the satellite.
  • The Multi-Hop Diminishing Return: Adding more aerial relays ($N$) initially improves the end-to-end performance because it shortens each individual hop. However, this benefit plateaus quickly; once the relay hops are "good enough," the overall system performance becomes limited by the initial uplink or final downlink.
  • Interference vs. Noise: In these dense aerial scenarios, the system is "interference-limited" rather than "noise-limited." The spatial distribution of other users is a much bigger factor than the background thermal noise.

Key Results

  • Model Validation: The derived closed-form expressions perfectly matched the Monte-Carlo simulation results across various scenarios, proving the framework's accuracy.
  • Uplink Sensitivity: The size of the drone distribution area ($R_A$) and the density of transmitters ($\lambda_A$) are the primary drivers of uplink failure. A larger, denser cluster of drones significantly increases the outage probability.
  • Downlink Sensitivity: The downlink is highly vulnerable to the density ($\lambda_I$) and power ($P_J$) of jammers. Even a small increase in jammer density can cause the outage probability to spike by several orders of magnitude.
  • Comparative Performance: The paper demonstrates that neither the satellite nor the aerial relay chain is universally superior. The "best" path depends on specific factors like the number of available relays, transmit power, and the presence of ground-level interference.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fixed Nodes: While the transmitters and jammers are modeled randomly, the satellite and the final terrestrial destination are treated as fixed points in parts of the analysis to keep the math tractable.
  • Doppler Effects: The authors explicitly ignored Doppler shifts caused by high-speed movement to focus on spatial modeling, noting that Doppler effects are well-covered in other literature.
  • Mobility: The current model provides a "snapshot" in time. Future work could incorporate temporal dynamics to see how performance changes as drones and satellites move relative to each other.
  • Energy Constraints: The paper focuses on signal reliability (outage) but does not deeply explore the energy efficiency trade-offs of maintaining a multi-hop aerial chain.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nowadays, satellite and aerial platforms are playing an important role in realizing global seamless wireless coverage. In this paper, a cooperative satellite-aerial-terrestrial network (SATN) is considered, in which two kinds of relaying links, satellite and aerial relaying links, are used to assist a group of aerial terminals to forward their information to a remote terrestrial destination (D). Specifically, we model these aerial platforms sharing the same frequency band as a Matérn hard-core point process type-II. Also, a group of aerial jammers at D’s side is modeled as a Poisson point process. To demonstrate the end-to-end (e2e) performance of the two relaying links, the statistical characteristics of the received signal-to-interference are characterized and then a closed-form expression for the outage probability (OP) over the uplink from the aerial source to the satellite/the aerial relay, the downlink from the satellite/the aerial relay to D, and the inter-aerial relay link are derived. Numerical results are presented to verify the proposed analysis models and compare the outage performance of the considered cooperative SATN with the two relay links under numerous scenarios.
BibTeX
@article{song2022cooperative,
  author = {Zhe Song and Jianping An and Gaofeng Pan and Shuai Wang and Haoxing Zhang and Yunfei Chen and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Cooperative Satellite-Aerial-Terrestrial Systems: A Stochastic Geometry Model}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2022.3192276},
}
Figure