Controller Synthesis for MDPs and Frequency LTL\GU

Vojtech Forejt, Jan Krcál, Jan Kretínský

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of synthesizing controllers for Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) that satisfy properties expressed in a quantitative temporal logic called Frequency LTL (fLTL). The authors present a decidable algorithm for a significant fragment of fLTL (fLTL\GU), which allows reasoning about the frequency of events over time, a crucial capability for probabilistic systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing controllers for systems that behave probabilistically is a fundamental challenge in computer science. While traditional temporal logics like LTL are useful for specifying desired system behavior, they are often too rigid for probabilistic systems, which may not be able to guarantee properties with 100% certainty. Frequency LTL (fLTL) extends LTL to express quantitative properties, such as "an event occurs at least 80% of the time." However, controller synthesis for full fLTL is known to be undecidable. This paper focuses on a decidable fragment, fLTL\GU, which excludes the "until" operator within "globally" (G) operators, but still allows for expressive quantitative specifications. This fragment is important because it captures many practical properties, including those related to rare failures or frequent successes.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in a novel translation-based approach. Instead of directly working with the MDP and the fLTL\GU formula, the authors translate the fLTL\GU formula into a deterministic generalized Rabin automaton (DGRMA) with mean-payoff objectives. This automaton captures the logic's semantics. Then, they construct a product MDP between the original MDP and this automaton. Finally, they analyze this product MDP to determine if a strategy exists that satisfies the property, and if so, to construct such a strategy. This approach leverages existing automata-theoretic techniques for verification but extends them to handle quantitative frequency properties. The construction involves several steps, including building "master" and "slave" automata to monitor different aspects of the formula, and then combining them.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The paper provides a significant step towards decidable controller synthesis for quantitative temporal logics by focusing on a tractable fragment of fLTL.
  • Automata-Centric Approach: The core idea is to translate the temporal logic formula into a deterministic automaton. This allows leveraging well-established automata-theoretic methods for verification and synthesis.
  • Handling Frequencies: The key challenge is to represent and reason about frequency-based properties. The authors introduce a sophisticated automaton construction that can monitor these frequencies.
  • Master-Slave Automata: The construction uses a "master" automaton to track the overall formula and "slave" automata to monitor specific subformulas, particularly those involving frequency operators. This modular design helps manage complexity.
  • Decidability for fLTL\GU: The paper establishes decidability for controller synthesis for the fLTL\GU fragment, which is a crucial theoretical result for this class of quantitative properties.

Key Results

The main result is the decidability of the controller synthesis problem for MDPs and the fLTL\GU fragment. The authors provide an algorithm that, given an MDP and an fLTL\GU formula, can determine whether a strategy exists to satisfy the property with a given probability threshold. The algorithm constructs a witness strategy in doubly exponential time. This is a significant theoretical advance, as it provides a formal method for designing controllers for probabilistic systems with quantitative specifications.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their algorithm is for a fragment of fLTL (fLTL\GU) and does not cover the full logic, particularly formulas involving the "until" operator within "globally" operators. They note that extending their approach to the full fLTL is a major task, as the current construction relies on the acyclicity of slave LTS, a property not guaranteed for unrestricted formulas. Future work would involve tackling these more complex formulas and potentially improving the complexity of the current algorithm.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantitative extensions of temporal logics have recently attracted significant attention. In this work, we study frequency LTL (fLTL), an extension of LTL which allows to speak about frequencies of events along an execution. Such an extension is particularly useful for probabilistic systems that often cannot fulfil strict qualitative guarantees on the behaviour. It has been recently shown that controller synthesis for Markov decision processes and fLTL is decidable when all the bounds on frequencies are 1. As a step towards a complete quantitative solution, we show that the problem is decidable for the fragment fLTL$\setminus$GU, where U does not occur in the scope of G (but still F can). Our solution is based on a novel translation of such quantitative formulae into equivalent deterministic automata.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{forejt2015controller,
  author = {Vojtech Forejt and Jan Krcál and Jan Kretínský},
  title = {{Controller Synthesis for MDPs and Frequency LTL\textbackslash\{\}GU}},
  booktitle = {LPAR},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-662-48899-7\_12},
}
Figure