Control of tissue development and cell diversity by cell cycle-dependent transcriptional filtering

Maria Abou Chakra, Ruth Isserlin, Thinh Ngoc Tran, Gary D. BadereLife 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel mechanism where the cell cycle acts as a "transcriptional filter," controlling which genes get fully transcribed based on their length and the cell's division speed. This filter, combined with evolutionary changes in gene length, can explain how diverse cell types and tissue proportions arise during development, a finding supported by computational models and single-cell RNA sequencing data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

How does a single fertilized egg develop into a complex organism with a vast array of specialized cell types? While we know that cell division and gene expression are crucial, the precise mechanisms that orchestrate the generation of cell diversity and control tissue proportions during development remain incompletely understood. Specifically, how do cells decide which genes to express, and how does this relate to their division rate and the overall developmental timeline? This paper tackles this by investigating the role of cell cycle duration as a potential regulator of gene expression and, consequently, cell fate and diversity.

Methods

The authors developed a novel agent-based computational model to simulate multicellular development. Each simulated cell has a genome with genes of varying lengths and a defined cell cycle duration. The core of the model is the "transcriptional filter" concept: if a cell's cycle is too short, long genes won't be fully transcribed. This filter's impact was explored by varying cell cycle duration, gene length distribution, and the number of genes. The model operates at a single-cell resolution, allowing for direct comparison with experimental single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data. They also performed evolutionary genome analysis to correlate gene length distributions with developmental speeds across different species.

Datasets

The study utilized single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data from various sources to validate their model's predictions. Specifically, they analyzed data from:

  • Mouse neural cortex development (Yuzwa et al., 2017)
  • Microglia across multiple species (Geirsdottir et al., 2019)
  • Embryonic development in Xenopus tropicalis (Briggs et al., 2018) and Danio rerio (Kimmel et al., 1995; Wagner et al., 2018)

They also curated developmental time data and gene length distributions for 101 species from public databases and literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Cell Cycle as a Transcriptional Filter: The most significant insight is that the cell cycle duration acts as a natural filter. Shorter cell cycles inherently limit the transcription of longer genes, while longer cycles allow for the expression of a broader range of gene lengths. This is a direct consequence of the time required for transcription.
  • Gene Length as an Evolutionary Tuning Knob: The paper suggests that over evolutionary time, changes in the distribution of gene lengths within a genome can tune the developmental process. Fast-developing organisms tend to have narrower gene length distributions, while slower developers have a broader range, including more long genes. This implies a co-evolution of genome structure and developmental speed.
  • Controlling Cell Diversity: The transcriptional filter mechanism provides a direct way to control cell diversity. By modulating cell cycle duration, a developing tissue can generate a more heterogeneous population of cells with distinct transcriptomes, or conversely, a more homogeneous one.
  • Trade-off Between Speed and Diversity: There's an inherent trade-off: fast cell cycles generate more cells quickly but limit diversity, while slower cycles generate fewer cells but allow for greater diversity. The model shows how this balance can be managed.
  • Spatial Regulation in Embryos: The study highlights how this mechanism might operate spatially, as seen in the Drosophila embryo, where different regions have different cell cycle durations and express Hox genes of varying lengths, suggesting a link between local cell cycle speed and gene expression patterns.

Key Results

  • Transcript Count vs. Gene Length: Simulations showed that shorter cell cycles lead to higher transcript counts for short genes and lower counts for long genes, a pattern consistent with observed scRNA-seq data across multiple species.
  • Cell Diversity Control: The model demonstrated that cell diversity (measured by transcriptome diversity and clustering) increases with cell cycle duration when the transcriptional filter is active. Interestingly, diversity peaks at intermediate cell cycle durations, suggesting a complex regulatory interplay.
  • Evolutionary Correlation: A strong positive correlation (r=0.74) was found between estimated developmental time and median gene length across 101 species, supporting the idea that slower development is associated with longer genes.
  • Pathway Enrichment: Short genes were enriched in pathways related to rapid activation (e.g., immune response, translation), while long genes were enriched in pathways for mature cell functions (e.g., neural development, muscle control).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Simplified Model: The model omits many biological complexities, such as splicing, translation, gene-gene interactions, intercellular signaling, and environmental cues, to focus on the core mechanism.
  • Focus on Transcription: The model primarily considers transcription and RNA polymerase II re-initiation, while other regulatory mechanisms (gene silencing, regulatory networks, etc.) are not explicitly modeled.
  • Experimental Validation: While the model's predictions align with existing scRNA-seq data, direct experimental validation of the transcriptional filter mechanism is still needed.
  • Cell Cycle Phase Specificity: The model simplifies the cell cycle into a single duration, whereas transcription primarily occurs during gap phases (G1, G2), and different phases have distinct roles.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Incorporating more regulatory mechanisms into the model.
  • Investigating the role of cell cycle phase-specific transcription.
  • Exploring how cell cycle duration itself is controlled.
  • Testing the hypotheses with more experimental data across diverse systems.
  • Extending the model to other biological processes involving cell cycle dynamics, such as regeneration, immune activation, and cancer.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cell cycle duration changes dramatically during development, starting out fast to generate cells quickly and slowing down over time as the organism matures. The cell cycle can also act as a transcriptional filter to control the expression of long gene transcripts, which are partially transcribed in short cycles. Using mathematical simulations of cell proliferation, we identify an emergent property that this filter can act as a tuning knob to control gene transcript expression, cell diversity, and the number and proportion of different cell types in a tissue. Our predictions are supported by comparison to single-cell RNA-seq data captured over embryonic development. Additionally, evolutionary genome analysis shows that fast-developing organisms have a narrow genomic distribution of gene lengths while slower developers have an expanded number of long genes. Our results support the idea that cell cycle dynamics may be important across multicellular animals for controlling gene transcript expression and cell fate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chakra2021control,
  author = {Maria Abou Chakra and Ruth Isserlin and Thinh Ngoc Tran and Gary D. Bader},
  title = {{Control of tissue development and cell diversity by cell cycle-dependent transcriptional filtering}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.64951},
}

Loading related content...

Figure