Control of a Soft Robotic Arm Using a Piecewise Universal Joint Model

Zhanchi Wang, Gaotian Wang, Xiaoping Chen, Nikolaos M. Freris

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel control strategy for soft robotic arms by modeling them as a series of universal joints. They developed two controllers – one for precise trajectory tracking in joint space and another for accurate end-effector positioning in task space – demonstrating significant improvements in accuracy and speed over existing methods, even when interacting with external forces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soft robotic arms, with their inherent compliance and infinite degrees of freedom, are notoriously difficult to control precisely. Traditional rigid robot control methods often fall short due to the complex, continuous deformations and potential for instability arising from singularities in common modeling techniques like the Piecewise Constant Curvature (PCC) model. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a more robust and accurate control framework for these challenging systems.

Methods

The core of this work lies in the Piecewise Universal Joint (PUJ) model, previously developed by the authors. This model simplifies a soft arm segment into a universal joint, offering a more accurate representation than PCC, especially under external loads. Building upon this model, they introduce two distinct closed-loop controllers:

  • Configuration Space Controller: This controller focuses on precise trajectory tracking of the arm's joint angles. It utilizes a model-based approach that combines feedback (PID) with feedforward terms derived from the PUJ model's dynamics (inertia, Coriolis, gravity, stiffness, and damping). The dynamics are computed using a Newton-Euler recursive method.
  • Task Space Controller: This controller aims to position the arm's end-effector accurately in 3D space. It employs a stiffness-based approach, effectively creating a virtual spring between the current end-effector position and the desired target. The control signal is derived from the end-effector's positional error, converted into torque using the Jacobian matrix.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental validation using a custom-built soft robotic arm and simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PUJ Model's Efficacy: The paper strongly validates the PUJ model as a superior alternative to PCC for controlling soft robotic arms, particularly in dynamic scenarios and when dealing with external interactions.
  • Model-Based Control Advantage: Leveraging the PUJ model's dynamics significantly enhances control performance, leading to more accurate trajectory tracking and faster, more stable end-effector positioning compared to model-free or simplified baseline methods.
  • Unified Control Framework: The development of both configuration and task space controllers within the same PUJ modeling framework provides a comprehensive solution for controlling soft robotic arms in various applications.
  • Robustness to External Loads: The task space controller demonstrates remarkable robustness to external forces, maintaining performance even with varying payloads, which is crucial for real-world interactive tasks.

Key Results

  • Configuration Space Tracking: The proposed controller achieved a 70% reduction in average joint error compared to a baseline model-free PID controller in real-world experiments.
  • Task Space Positioning (Free Space): The settling time for the end-effector to reach a desired position was reduced by 51% compared to a previous simplified model-based controller.
  • Task Space Positioning (With Load): The mean steady-state error was reduced by 58% when the arm was subjected to external loads (up to 500g), demonstrating robust performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper acknowledges that the PUJ model, while an improvement, still relies on approximations (e.g., assuming planar deformation without twisting). The control performance is also dependent on the accuracy of the state estimation and the system identification of the arm's parameters.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further exploring the performance of the PUJ-based controllers for more complex interactive tasks. They also hint at future work involving more advanced control strategies and potentially extending the PUJ model to account for more complex deformations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The 'infinite' passive degrees of freedom of soft robotic arms render their control especially challenging. In this paper, we leverage a previously developed model, which drawing equivalence of the soft arm to a series of universal joints, to design two closed-loop controllers: a configuration space controller for trajectory tracking and a task space controller for position control of the end effector. Extensive experiments and simulations on a four-segment soft arm attest to substantial improvement in terms of: a) superior tracking accuracy of the configuration space controller and b) reduced settling time and steady-state error of the task space controller. The task space controller is also verified to be effective in the presence of interactions between the soft arm and the environment.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2022control,
  author = {Zhanchi Wang and Gaotian Wang and Xiaoping Chen and Nikolaos M. Freris},
  title = {{Control of a Soft Robotic Arm Using a Piecewise Universal Joint Model}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2201.01480},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.01480},
}
Figure