Abstract
The continuum-armed bandits problem involves optimizing an unknown objective function given an oracle that evaluates the function at a query point. In the most well-studied case, the objective function is assumed to be Lipschitz continuous and minimax rates of simple and cumulative regrets are known under both noiseless and noisy conditions. In this paper, we investigate continuum-armed bandits under more general smoothness conditions, namely Besov smoothness conditions, on the objective function. In both noiseless and noisy conditions, we derive minimax rates under both simple and cumulative regrets. In particular, our results show that minimax rates over objective functions in a Besov space are identical to minimax rates over objective functions in the smallest Holder space into which the Besov space embeds.
Introduction
The continuum-armed bandit problem, also known as black-box or 0th-order optimization, is a fundamental challenge in machine learning and statistics. It models scenarios where an agent seeks to find the global maximum of an unknown objective function by sequentially querying its values. Traditionally, the difficulty of this task is characterized by the smoothness of the function, often modeled using Hölder spaces. However, many real-world functions exhibit non-uniform smoothness—being flat in some regions and highly irregular in others.
In non-parametric regression, Besov spaces are used to model such functions, and spatially adaptive methods like wavelets can exploit these variations to achieve faster learning rates. This paper investigates whether similar gains are possible in the bandit setting: can we achieve a "speedup" in optimization by assuming the objective function lies in a Besov space?
Methods
The research employs a minimax framework to determine the fundamental limits of optimization performance. The methodology relies on several key technical pillars:
- Wavelet Characterization: Besov spaces are defined using an orthonormal wavelet basis, allowing for a precise decomposition of function smoothness across different scales and locations.
- Embedding Theorems: The analysis utilizes mathematical embeddings to relate Besov spaces $B^\sigma_{p,q}$ to Hölder spaces $C^s$, showing that a Besov space embeds into a Hölder space with exponent $s = \sigma - d/p$.
- Information-Theoretic Lower Bounds: To establish that no algorithm can exceed certain performance thresholds, the author applies Fano’s Lemma. This involves constructing "worst-case" function sets that are difficult for any optimizer to distinguish.
Key Insights and Ideas
A central finding of this work is that optimization is fundamentally more constrained than regression. While regression benefits from data across the entire domain to learn the function's shape, optimization is focused solely on the global maximum.
The study reveals a "No Free Lunch" result for Besov spaces in the bandit context: the spatial adaptivity that empowers wavelets in image processing or regression provides no asymptotic benefit for optimization. If a function is "jagged" or less smooth in even a small part of its domain, an optimizer must search with high precision, negating the benefits of smoothness elsewhere. Consequently, the minimax rate for a Besov space is identical to the rate for the smallest Hölder space into which it embeds.
Furthermore, the paper identifies a "phase transition" between noiseless and noisy optimization. In the noiseless regime, the optimal error decreases rapidly until it reaches the noise floor $\eta$, at which point the convergence slows to the characteristic "noisy" rate.
Key Results
The paper provides comprehensive minimax rates for both Simple Regret (the error of the final estimate) and Cumulative Regret (the total loss over time):
- Noiseless Setting: For a Besov space $B^\sigma_{p,q}$, the minimax simple regret scales as $T^{1/p - \sigma/d}$.
- Noisy Setting: The rates align with known Hölder rates for the exponent $s = \sigma - d/p$. For instance, simple regret scales approximately as $(T/\log T)^{-\frac{s}{2s + d}}$.
These results unify previous specialized studies on Sobolev spaces and Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces (RKHS) into a single, cohesive theoretical framework.
Conclusion and Future Work
While this work establishes the statistical limits of continuum-armed bandits in Besov spaces, several avenues for future research remain. For cumulative regret where the smoothness parameter $s > 1$, a gap persists between the proven lower bounds and existing upper bounds. The author suggests that current algorithms may be sub-optimal in this regime.
Additionally, while wavelets do not offer a statistical advantage, they may provide computational benefits through fast wavelet transforms, particularly in high-dimensional settings. Finally, incorporating shape constraints like convexity could potentially bypass the limitations identified in this general smoothness analysis.
Summary updated