Construction of efficient solid emitters with conventional and AIE luminogens for blue organic light-emitting diodes

Zujin Zhao, Shuming Chen, Chunmei Deng, Jacky W. Y. Lam, Carrie Y. K. Chan, Ping Lü, Zhiming Wang, Bingbing Hu, Xiaopeng Chen, Hoi Sing Kwok, Yuguang Ma, Huayu Qiu, Ben Zhong TangJournal of Materials Chemistry 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a new class of blue organic light-emitting diode (OLED) emitters based on fluorene derivatives. By strategically incorporating "aggregation-induced emission" (AIE) units, they overcome the common problem of luminescence quenching in solid films, leading to significantly improved device performance, particularly for the AIE-active material.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing efficient and stable blue emitters for OLEDs remains a significant challenge. Conventional organic luminophores often suffer from "aggregation-caused quenching" (ACQ) – their light emission intensity drastically decreases when they are in a solid film state (as used in OLEDs) compared to when they are dissolved in solution. This is due to intermolecular interactions and restricted molecular motion in the solid state, which promote non-radiative decay pathways. While various strategies exist to mitigate ACQ, they often have limited success or introduce undesirable side effects. This paper aims to address this by designing molecules that exhibit "aggregation-induced emission" (AIE), where luminescence is enhanced in the solid state.

Methods

The researchers synthesized a series of fluorene derivatives, named BArBCFs, by attaching different chromophoric units (pyrene, anthracene, triphenylamine, and tetraphenylethene) to a central fluorene core. The synthesis involved Suzuki coupling reactions. They then characterized these materials using various techniques:

  • Spectroscopy: UV-Vis absorption and photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy were used to study their optical properties in both solution and thin film states. Fluorescence quantum yields (ΦF) were measured.
  • Thermal Analysis: Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) were employed to assess their thermal stability and glass-transition temperatures (Tg).
  • Electrochemistry: Cyclic voltammetry (CV) was used to determine their electrochemical properties, including HOMO and LUMO energy levels.
  • Computational Chemistry: Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed to understand the electronic structure and molecular conformations.
  • Device Fabrication: Multilayer OLED devices were fabricated using these synthesized materials as the emissive layer. Their electroluminescence (EL) properties, including turn-on voltage, luminance, and efficiencies (power, current, and external quantum), were measured.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ACQ vs. AIE Strategy: The core idea is to leverage the AIE phenomenon to counteract ACQ. Molecules with conventional chromophores (like pyrene, anthracene, TPA) showed good solution emission but poor film emission (ACQ). In contrast, the molecule with a tetraphenylethene (TPE) unit (BTPEBCF) was weakly emissive in solution but became a strong emitter in the solid state (AIE).
  • Role of TPE Unit: The propeller-like structure of the TPE unit is crucial. In solution, its free intramolecular rotation quenches luminescence. In the solid state, this rotation is restricted, blocking non-radiative pathways and leading to enhanced emission.
  • Molecular Design for Blue Emission: The fluorene core, combined with carbazole substituents, provides a stable scaffold for blue emission. The choice of 2,7-substituents fine-tunes the electronic properties and conjugation.
  • Synergistic Effect: Combining ACQ-prone chromophores with AIE-active units (like TPE) on the same molecular backbone offers a promising route to efficient solid-state emitters.

Key Results

  • Synthesis: Four fluorene derivatives (BPyBCF, BAnBCF, BTPABCF, BTPEBCF) were synthesized with good yields (52–89%).
  • Optical Properties:
    • BPyBCF, BAnBCF, and BTPABCF showed high solution ΦF (75–94%) but significantly lower film ΦF (30–61%), indicating ACQ.
  • BTPEBCF exhibited very low solution ΦF (0.3%) but achieved 100% ΦF in the film state, demonstrating strong AIE.
  • Thermal Stability: All luminogens were thermally stable, with high glass-transition temperatures (Tg = 109–147 °C) and decomposition temperatures (Td = 396–478 °C).
  • OLED Performance:
    • Devices using BPyBCF, BAnBCF, and BTPABCF showed blue electroluminescence with moderate efficiencies (e.g., BPyBCF: 4.8 cd A⁻¹ current efficiency, 2.3% external quantum efficiency).
  • The BTPEBCF device, leveraging its AIE feature, achieved higher efficiencies: 7.9 cd A⁻¹ current efficiency and 2.9% external quantum efficiency.
  • Further device engineering (adding an electron-transporting layer) improved performance for all emitters.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: While the AIE-active BTPEBCF showed improved performance, its emission color was slightly redder (sky blue at 508 nm) compared to the other blue emitters. The paper notes that the TPA moieties in BTPABCF offered better hole-transporting capability than TPE units in BTPEBCF, leading to lower turn-on voltages for BTPABCF devices, but this was offset by ACQ.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further optimization of molecular design, particularly in balancing AIE properties with desired emission color and charge transport characteristics, could lead to even more efficient blue OLEDs. The study demonstrates the general applicability of combining ACQ and AIE units for designing solid-state emitters.

Summary updated

Abstract

9,9-Bis(9-heptyl-3-carbazolyl)fluorenes (BPyBCF, BAnBCF, BTPABCF, and BTPEBCF, where B = Bis, Py = pyrene, C = carbazole, F = fluorene, An = anthracene, TPA = triphenylamine, and TPE = tetraphenylethene) with different chromophoric units at the 2,7-positions are synthesized in moderate to high yields (52–89%) by Suzuki coupling reactions of 9,9-bis(9-heptyl-3-carbazolyl)-2,7-dibromofluorene with the corresponding arylboronic acid and utilized as active layers for the construction of blue organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). BPyBCF, BAnBCF and BTPABCF emit intense blue light with high fluorescence quantum yields (ΦF = 75–94%) in solution. However, they exhibit much lower ΦF values (30–61%) in the film state, revealing that aggregate formation has quenched their light emission. On the contrary, BTPEBCF is weakly emissive in solution (ΦF = 0.3%) but becomes a strong emitter (ΦF = 100%) when fabricated into solid film, demonstrating a phenomenon of aggregation-induced emission (AIE). Restriction of intramolecular rotation and suppression of intermolecular interactions due to the propeller-like tetraphenylethene unit are responsible for the AIE phenomenon. All the luminogens are thermally and morphologically stable, showing high glass-transition (Tg = 109–147 °C) and thermal-degradation temperatures (Td = 396–478 °C). Non-doped OLEDs using BPyBCF, BAnBCF, and BTPABCF as light-emitting layers are constructed, which give blue electroluminescence with maximum current (ηC,max) and external quantum (ηext,max) efficiencies of 4.8 cd A−1 and 2.3%. With the same device configuration, BTPEBCF shows higher ηC,max and ηext,max values of 7.9 cd A−1 and 2.9%, respectively, thanks to its AIE feature.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2011construction,
  author = {Zujin Zhao and Shuming Chen and Chunmei Deng and Jacky W. Y. Lam and Carrie Y. K. Chan and Ping Lü and Zhiming Wang and Bingbing Hu and Xiaopeng Chen and Ping Lü and Hoi Sing Kwok and Yuguang Ma and Huayu Qiu and Ben Zhong Tang},
  title = {{Construction of efficient solid emitters with conventional and AIE luminogens for blue organic light-emitting diodes}},
  journal = {Journal of Materials Chemistry},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1039/c1jm10221d},
}
Figure