Constructing Gradient Controllable Recurrent Neural Networks Using\n Hamiltonian Dynamics

Konstantin Rusch, John W. Pearson, Konstantinos C. Zygalakis

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) architecture, the Hamiltonian RNN, that leverages Hamiltonian dynamics to achieve controllable gradients. This allows the network to effectively learn long-term dependencies in sequential data without suffering from the common vanishing or exploding gradient problems, outperforming existing state-of-the-art methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) are powerful tools for processing sequential data, but they struggle with learning long-term dependencies. This difficulty arises from the "vanishing or exploding gradient" problem, where gradients become either too small or too large during training, hindering the network's ability to learn from past information. While solutions like LSTMs and GRUs exist, they can be computationally expensive and still susceptible to exploding gradients. This paper aims to address this fundamental challenge by proposing a new RNN architecture that inherently controls gradient behavior.

Methods

The core innovation is the Hamiltonian Recurrent Neural Network (Hamiltonian RNN). This architecture is built upon the connection between dynamical systems and neural networks, specifically by approximating a Hamiltonian system using symplectic integrators. Hamiltonian systems are known for their favorable long-term stability properties. By discretizing such a system with a symplectic method (the Leapfrog method is used), the authors derive a recursive formula for the RNN. A key hyperparameter, the step-size $\epsilon$ of the integrator, directly influences the norm of the hidden state gradient. The paper theoretically shows that by setting $\epsilon$ inversely proportional to the sequence length $N$, the gradient norm can be kept at $O(1)$, thus preventing vanishing or exploding.

Datasets

The paper uses the following datasets for evaluation:

  • Self-generated datasets: For a Gaussian mean classification problem and a disturbed sequential XOR problem. These are designed to test the network's ability to learn and retain information over varying sequence lengths.
  • MNIST: The standard MNIST dataset is used to classify handwritten digits, reformulated as a sequential learning problem.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hamiltonian Dynamics for Gradient Control: The paper demonstrates that the inherent properties of Hamiltonian systems can be harnessed to create RNNs with controllable gradients, a significant departure from traditional approaches.
  • Hyperparameter $\epsilon$ as a Gradient Controller: The step-size $\epsilon$ of the symplectic integrator acts as a direct knob to control the hidden state gradient, offering a principled way to manage gradient behavior.
  • Optimal $\epsilon$ Scales with Sequence Length: A crucial finding is that the optimal choice for $\epsilon$ to maintain $O(1)$ gradients is inversely proportional to the sequence length ($ \epsilon = O(N^{-1}) $). This provides a practical heuristic for tuning the network.
  • Efficiency Gains: The Hamiltonian RNN requires significantly fewer parameters and learning iterations compared to LSTMs and even the Antisymmetric RNN, especially for longer sequences.

Key Results

  • Gradient Control: The Hamiltonian RNN successfully maintains hidden state gradients close to $O(1)$ for a range of $\epsilon$ values, preventing vanishing or exploding gradients.
  • Performance on Sequential Tasks:
    • In the shock preservation experiment, the Hamiltonian RNN converged significantly faster (almost an order of magnitude) than the Antisymmetric RNN and LSTM, especially for longer sequences (up to $N=5000$). It also required far fewer parameters.
  • In the sequential XOR problem, the Hamiltonian RNN and Antisymmetric RNN performed similarly and outperformed the LSTM in terms of convergence speed and parameter count.
  • On the sequential MNIST task, the Hamiltonian RNN achieved the highest accuracy (94%), outperforming both the Antisymmetric RNN (87%) and LSTM.
  • Optimal Hyperparameter Heuristic: Numerical experiments confirmed the theoretical finding that the optimal $\epsilon$ scales as $O(N^{-1})$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Noise Sensitivity: The paper acknowledges that while energy conservation in Hamiltonian systems is attractive, complete conservation of information might be detrimental in the presence of noisy data. Future work could explore applying the Hamiltonian RNN to very noisy datasets.
  • Data-Poor Regimes: The authors observed that Hamiltonian RNNs perform well even in data-poor regimes (fewer training samples than parameters). Future research could investigate how the Hamiltonian design contributes to good generalization properties in such scenarios.
  • Hyperparameter Optimization: While the Hamiltonian RNN offers a heuristic for $\epsilon$, other hyperparameters still require optimization. The paper notes that the Antisymmetric RNN, in contrast, requires computationally intensive grid searches.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recurrent neural networks (RNNs) have gained a great deal of attention in\nsolving sequential learning problems. The learning of long-term dependencies,\nhowever, remains challenging due to the problem of a vanishing or exploding\nhidden states gradient. By exploring further the recently established\nconnections between RNNs and dynamical systems we propose a novel RNN\narchitecture, which we call a Hamiltonian recurrent neural network (Hamiltonian\nRNN), based on a symplectic discretization of an appropriately chosen\nHamiltonian system. The key benefit of this approach is that the corresponding\nRNN inherits the favorable long time properties of the Hamiltonian system,\nwhich in turn allows us to control the hidden states gradient with a\nhyperparameter of the Hamiltonian RNN architecture. This enables us to handle\nsequential learning problems with arbitrary sequence lengths, since for a range\nof values of this hyperparameter the gradient neither vanishes nor explodes.\nAdditionally, we provide a heuristic for the optimal choice of the\nhyperparameter, which we use in our numerical simulations to illustrate that\nthe Hamiltonian RNN is able to outperform other state-of-the-art RNNs without\nthe need of computationally intensive hyperparameter optimization.\n
BibTeX
@misc{rusch2019constructing,
  author = {Konstantin Rusch and John W. Pearson and Konstantinos C. Zygalakis},
  title = {{Constructing Gradient Controllable Recurrent Neural Networks Using\textbackslash\{\}n Hamiltonian Dynamics}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1911.05035},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1911.05035},
}
Figure