Consistent learning by composite proximal thresholding

Patrick L. Combettes, Saverio Salzo, Silvia Villa

TL;DR

This paper introduces a flexible regularization framework for generalized linear models that allows for incorporating various prior beliefs about model coefficients, including sparsity and hard constraints. They develop a novel algorithm that achieves consistent estimation and provides theoretical guarantees on its convergence rate, even in the presence of computational errors and relaxations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In machine learning and data science, a common task is to learn a functional relationship between input features and output values, often modeled using generalized linear models. A key challenge is to select appropriate regularization techniques that can incorporate prior knowledge about the model's coefficients (e.g., sparsity) while ensuring that the resulting estimators are statistically consistent (i.e., they converge to the true underlying function as more data becomes available). Existing methods often have limitations in the types of priors they can handle or in their theoretical guarantees regarding convergence rates, especially when dealing with inexact computations. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a more flexible regularization model and a robust algorithm with strong theoretical backing.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in a novel composite regularization model. This model allows for combining different types of priors on the coefficients:

  • Hard constraints: Enforced using indicator functions of closed intervals.
  • Sparsity: Promoted using support functions of intervals.
  • Stability: Achieved through convex functions that provide stability.

This flexible structure generalizes many existing regularization techniques like ridge regression, elastic net, and bridge regression. To solve the resulting optimization problem, the authors develop an "error-tolerant composite proximal thresholding algorithm." This algorithm is based on the forward-backward splitting method, a standard technique for solving composite optimization problems. What's new here is the algorithm's ability to handle:

  • Variable proximal parameters: Allowing for adaptive step sizes.
  • Relaxations: Introducing a form of averaging to improve convergence.
  • Computational errors: Explicitly accounting for inaccuracies in computing proximal operators.

The theoretical contributions include proving the statistical consistency of the estimators obtained by minimizing the regularized empirical risk and establishing new asymptotic properties for their proposed algorithm, including an $o(1/m)$ convergence rate for the objective function values.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical aspects and algorithmic development, using synthetic data implicitly through the definition of the probability measure $P$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified regularization framework: The composite regularization model elegantly unifies various sparsity-inducing and constraint-based priors, offering a powerful tool for incorporating domain knowledge.
  • Robustness to errors: The development of an error-tolerant algorithm is crucial for practical applications, as exact proximal operator computations are often intractable. This work provides theoretical justification for using such inexact algorithms.
  • Improved convergence rates: Achieving an $o(1/m)$ convergence rate for the objective function values, even with relaxations and errors, is a significant theoretical advancement over previous results that often required error-free computations or only guaranteed ergodic convergence.
  • Flexibility in thresholding: The ability to define custom thresholding operations through the choice of intervals $(D_k)$ and the exponent $r$ allows for fine-grained control over sparsity patterns.

Key Results

  • Statistical Consistency: The paper proves that the proposed estimators are consistent in a statistical sense, meaning they converge to the true underlying function as the sample size increases.
  • Algorithmic Convergence: The proposed error-tolerant forward-backward splitting algorithm is shown to converge. Specifically, it achieves an $o(1/m)$ convergence rate for the objective function values in the presence of variable proximal parameters, relaxations, and computational errors.
  • Coefficient Consistency: Under certain conditions, the paper also shows the consistency of the estimated coefficients in $l^2(K)$, which is important when the properties of the true coefficients are of interest.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the algorithm is theoretically sound, its practical implementation and computational cost for very large dictionaries ($K$) or high-dimensional data might still be a challenge. The paper does not delve deeply into the practical computational aspects beyond theoretical guarantees.
  • Assumptions: The theoretical results rely on specific assumptions about the data distribution ($P$), the dictionary, and the regularization parameters. Relaxing these assumptions could lead to broader applicability.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring Nesterov-like variants of the forward-backward splitting algorithm, which might offer further improvements. Additionally, investigating the performance of the proposed method on real-world datasets and comparing it with existing state-of-the-art methods would be a natural next step. The flexibility of the regularization model also opens doors for applications in various domains where incorporating specific prior knowledge is critical.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the modeling and the numerical solution of machine learning problems with prediction functions which are linear combinations of elements of a possibly infinite-dimensional dictionary. We propose a novel flexible composite regularization model, which makes it possible to incorporate various priors on the coefficients of the prediction function, including sparsity and hard constraints. We show that the estimators obtained by minimizing the regularized empirical risk are consistent in a statistical sense, and we design an error-tolerant composite proximal thresholding algorithm for computing such estimators. New results on the asymptotic behavior of the proximal forward-backward splitting method are derived and exploited to establish the convergence properties of the proposed algorithm. In particular, our method features a $o(1/m)$ convergence rate in objective values.
BibTeX
@article{combettes2018consistent,
  author = {Patrick L. Combettes and Saverio Salzo and Silvia Villa},
  title = {{Consistent learning by composite proximal thresholding}},
  journal = {Math. Program.},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1007/s10107-017-1133-8},
}
Figure