Abstract
Set-theoretic control is a useful technique for dealing with the uncertainty introduced into power systems by renewable energy resources. Although set operations are computationally expensive in large systems, distributed approaches serve as a remedy. In this paper, we propose a novel consensus-based approach for set-theoretic frequency control in power systems. A robust controlled-invariant set (RCI) for the system is generated by composing RCIs for each bus in the network. The process of generating these sets uses a consensus-based approach in order to facilitate discovery of mutually compatible subsystem RCIs. Each bus seeks to maximize the size of its own RCI while treating the effects of coupling as an unknown-but-bounded disturbance. The consensus routine, which demonstrates linear convergence, is embedded into a backwards reachability analysis of initial safe sets. Results for a 9-bus test case show that simple model predictive controllers associated with the resulting RCIs maintain safe operation when the system is subjected to worst case (adversarial) fluctuations in net demand, where conventional controllers are shown to fail.
Introduction
The transition to a greener power grid introduces a significant paradox: while renewable resources like wind and solar offer increased control flexibility through power electronics, they also bring higher uncertainty and lower mechanical inertia compared to traditional fossil-fuel generators. Maintaining grid stability requires ensuring the system remains within a "safe set"—specific operational ranges for frequency and voltage.
Traditionally, stability is managed by simulating specific "credible contingencies." However, the continuous and stochastic nature of renewable fluctuations makes probabilistic modeling difficult. Set-theoretic control addresses this by designing for "unknown-but-bounded" disturbances. The primary challenge is the "curse of dimensionality"; calculating these safe sets for large, interconnected grids is computationally prohibitive.
Methodology: Distributed Consensus-Based RCI
We propose a scalable, distributed method to compute Robust Controlled-Invariant (RCI) sets by decomposing the grid into individual bus subsystems.
Subsystem Decomposition and Assume-Guarantee Reasoning
The grid is treated as a collection of interconnected subsystems. Each bus calculates its own safe set locally, treating the influence of neighboring buses as an unknown-but-bounded disturbance rather than a known variable.
Consensus Routine
Subsystems iteratively share their safe-set boundaries with neighbors to reach a "consensus" on the bounds of their mutual influence. This routine demonstrates linear convergence, allowing for efficient discovery of mutually compatible subsystem RCIs. The algorithm moves away from minimal safe sets toward maximal RCIs, prioritizing the widest possible range of safe operating conditions.
Robust Model Predictive Control (RMPC)
Once RCIs are established, a myopic Model Predictive Controller is assigned to each bus. By constraining the controller to remain within the pre-calculated RCI, long-term safety is guaranteed even under adversarial conditions.
Experimental Results
The approach was evaluated using a standard 9-bus test case featuring three generators and three loads. The system was subjected to adversarial fluctuations designed to push it out of its safe zone ($| \delta | \leq 10^\circ$ and $| \omega | \leq 0.6$ Hz).
The Robust MPC (RMPC) successfully maintained all buses within safety limits. In contrast, conventional controllers—specifically the standard Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) and a Baseline MPC that does not account for the RCI—consistently failed, allowing the system to drift into unsafe territory.
The consensus algorithm proved highly efficient, typically converging in just 3–4 iterations for the test case, demonstrating its potential for real-time application in larger network topologies.
Conclusion
This work demonstrates that treating physical coupling as a bounded disturbance allows high-dimensional grid control problems to be solved as a series of low-dimensional subproblems. While the current study utilizes linearized swing equations, the results clearly show that RCI-based controllers provide a robust buffer against adversarial disturbances that cause traditional controllers to fail. Future work will explore non-linear dynamics and methods to reduce conservatism by modeling correlations between disturbance sources.
Summary updated