Conjugate and cut points in ideal fluid motion

Theodore D. Drivas, Gerard Misiołek, Bin Shi, Tsuyoshi Yoneda

Abstract

Two fluid configurations along a flow are conjugate if there is a one parameter family of geodesics (fluid flows) joining them to infinitesimal order. Geometrically, they can be seen as a consequence of the (infinite dimensional) group of volume preserving diffeomorphisms having sufficiently strong positive curvatures which 'pull' nearby flows together. Physically, they indicate a form of (transient) stability in the configuration space of particle positions: a family of flows starting with the same configuration deviate initially and subsequently re-converge (resonate) with each other at some later moment in time. Here, we first establish existence of conjugate points in an infinite family of Kolmogorov flows - a class of stationary solutions of the Euler equations - on the rectangular flat torus of any aspect ratio. The analysis is facilitated by a general criterion for identifying conjugate points in the group of volume preserving diffeomorphisms. Next, we show non-existence of conjugate points along Arnold stable steady states on the annulus, disk and channel. Finally, we discuss cut points, their relation to non-injectivity of the exponential map (impossibility of determining a flow from a particle configuration at a given instant) and show that the closest cut point to the identity is either a conjugate point or the midpoint of a time periodic Lagrangian fluid flow.

Introduction

In the 1960s, Vladimir Arnold revolutionized fluid dynamics by demonstrating that the motion of an ideal (inviscid and incompressible) fluid can be viewed as a geodesic on the group of volume-preserving diffeomorphisms, $\mathcal{D}_\mu(M)$. In this geometric formulation, the "curvature" of the space dictates the stability of the fluid: negative curvature causes nearby paths to diverge, leading to Lagrangian chaos, while positive curvature pulls them together.

A central challenge in this field is identifying "conjugate points"—moments where nearby fluid paths, starting from the same configuration, meet again. These points represent a form of "Lagrangian resonance," where different initial velocities lead to the identical particle configuration at a later time. This paper investigates which specific types of fluid flows exhibit these points and how they relate to classical hydrodynamic stability.

Geometric Framework and Methods

The study of fluid motion as a geodesic problem relies on the exponential map, $\exp_e$, which maps initial velocities in the tangent space $T_e \mathcal{D}_\mu^s$ to fluid configurations at a later time.

Geometric representation of the exponential map and conjugate points in the group of volume-preserving diffeomorphisms.

To identify conjugate points, the authors employ several rigorous mathematical tools:

  • The Index Form: By analyzing the second variation of the energy functional, the authors determine if a path minimizes distance. A negative index form indicates the existence of a conjugate point.
  • Curvature Criteria: A general criterion (Theorem 1) is established to identify conjugate points by finding a specific lower bound on the sectional curvature along a flow.
  • Spectral Analysis: For Kolmogorov flows—stationary solutions to the Euler equations—the authors analyze the eigenfunctions of the Stokes operator on a flat torus to test their conjugate point criterion.

Key Insights: Stability and Resonance

The research provides a deep link between Arnold’s classical stability criterion and Riemannian geometry.

Lagrangian Resonance and Kolmogorov Flows Conjugate points are interpreted as "relative Lagrangian stability." While most fluid paths diverge, positive curvature can "focus" a family of flows back together. The authors demonstrate that for almost any rectangular torus, an infinite family of Kolmogorov flows (defined by stream functions like $\psi(x, y) = -\cos(n\alpha x)\cos(my)$) will possess conjugate points. This suggests these flows are not "uniformly hyperbolic" and possess regions of transient stability.

Stability Forbids Conjugacy Conversely, on simple domains like a channel, disk, or annulus, if a flow is "Arnold stable" (Lyapunov stable in a specific norm), it is geometrically impossible for it to have conjugate points. This provides a geometric "signature" that distinguishes stable from unstable flows.

Results and Cut Points

The paper culminates in several key theorems:

  • Theorem 2: Confirms conjugate points for Kolmogorov flows under specific aspect ratio conditions.
  • Theorem 3: Proves the absence of conjugate points for Arnold stable flows on periodic channels, annuli, or disks.
  • Theorem 4: Characterizes the "closest cut point" to the identity. A cut point is the moment a fluid flow ceases to be the absolute shortest path between two configurations. The authors prove this point is either a conjugate point or the midpoint of a periodic loop in the fluid's configuration space.

Discussion and Future Work

While this work clarifies the geometric structure of specific flows, several questions remain. The authors speculate that all Kolmogorov flows that are not simple unidirectional shears possess conjugate points, but a universal proof is still needed. Additionally, while the results for Arnold stable flows hold for simple domains, it is unclear if this property extends to any compact manifold with a boundary. Future research may also explore the precise connection between these geometric properties and high-Reynolds number 2D turbulence, as well as the existence of conjugate points in vortices on elliptical domains.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{drivas2021conjugate,
  author = {Theodore D. Drivas and Gerard Misiołek and Bin Shi and Tsuyoshi Yoneda},
  title = {{Conjugate and cut points in ideal fluid motion}},
  booktitle = {Annales},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s40316-021-00176-4},
}
Figure