Abstract
While the environmental footprint of the digital sector is well-documented, the industry continues to expand despite calls for "digital sobriety." This paper investigates the systemic barriers to digital de-escalation, identifying "ratchet effects"—social, technological, and political mechanisms—that make digital expansion feel irreversible. By synthesizing concepts from archaeology, sociology, and systems thinking, the authors propose a framework for "ecological redirection" that moves beyond technical optimization toward a collective renunciation of hyper-complex infrastructures.
Introduction
The digital sector's growth is often framed as a matter of individual choice or technical efficiency. However, digital technology has evolved into a "Large Technological System" (LTS) deeply embedded in societal functions. In their research, Valentin Girard, Maud Rio, and Romain Couillet argue that we are caught in a web of systemic complexity that makes "hitting the brakes" on digitization exceptionally difficult. This paper seeks to understand the forces that keep us locked into this trajectory and how we might begin to untangle them.
Methodology
This study is a research clarification based on a systemic literature analysis. The authors synthesized concepts from diverse fields, including Joseph Tainter’s archaeological theories on societal collapse, Ivan Illich’s sociological critiques of technology, and Donella Meadows’ systems thinking. To build their conceptual framework, they conducted a structured search across major academic databases.
As shown in Table 1, the researchers distilled a vast initial pool of results into a focused corpus of 15 articles that specifically bridge the gap between computing, complexity, and degrowth, supplemented by 16 books and various reports.
The Complexity Trap
A central pillar of the authors' argument is the relationship between complexity and its benefits. Drawing on Joseph Tainter’s theory, they illustrate that while increasing complexity initially solves problems and provides societal benefits, it eventually reaches a point of diminishing marginal returns.
In the digital context, this means that the infrastructure required to maintain our current level of service (C3) may actually provide fewer net benefits (B1) than a simpler system (C1), while simultaneously making the society more brittle and vulnerable to collapse. Degrowth is thus presented as a strategy for voluntary simplification to restore resilience.
The Ratchet Effect
The paper identifies three "ratchets" that prevent societies from reverting to simpler technological states:
- Social Ratchet: Habits and the "affective condensation" users feel toward their devices, combined with the fact that social participation (banking, government) often requires digital tools.
- Technological Ratchet: Network effects and path dependence, where the widespread adoption of a platform makes it nearly impossible for individuals to leave.
- Political Ratchet: The use of complexity by elites to maintain power and legitimacy, making the rollback of tech-provided "comforts" politically hazardous.
Strategies for Digital De-escalation
To overcome these systemic barriers, the authors propose two primary strategies:
- Cosmolocalism: A model that shares digital knowledge globally as a "commons" while decentralizing the physical production and use of tools to meet local needs.
- Protocols of Renunciation: A process of "ecological redirection" where communities map their attachments to digital tools and collectively decide which infrastructures to abandon to regain autonomy.
Conclusion
Digital degrowth is not merely about using less technology; it requires a fundamental shift in how we view our relationship with complexity. While the "behavioral ratchet" of individual convenience remains a significant hurdle, the authors call for a new field of study focused on "detachment." Researchers must move away from designing "better" technology and instead develop methods that help societies disengage from hyper-complex infrastructures without losing their means of subsistence.
Summary updated