A Protocol to Address Ecological Redirection for Digital Practices in Organizations

Valentin Girard, Antoine Martin, Maud Rio, Romain CouilletarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction: The Techno-Solutionist Trap

The standard narrative of the "digital transition" suggests that technology is a primary tool for solving the climate crisis. However, digitalization itself is a massive driver of environmental degradation—accounting for up to 3.9% of global greenhouse gas emissions, consuming vast mineral resources, and generating millions of tons of e-waste.

Current policies often focus on optimization, which frequently leads to "rebound effects" where increased efficiency drives more consumption. This paper addresses the gap between theoretical "degrowth" concepts and practical organizational change, asking: How can an organization decide to stop using a specific technology when its members are deeply "attached" to it?

Methodology: The Four Phases of Redirection

The paper introduces a structured, four-phase protocol for Ecological Redirection, providing a sociological and design-led framework to identify, debate, and ultimately renounce unsustainable digital practices.

  1. Mapping of Attachments: Using ethnographic methods (direct observation, interviews, and questionnaires), researchers identify why members of an organization use specific tools. This maps "locks" (e.g., hierarchical obligations) and "levers" (e.g., autonomy) that influence technology use.
  2. Workshops: Stakeholders are educated on the systemic impacts of the digital sector and participate in "imagination exercises" to envision desirable futures that rely on less technology.
  3. Debate on Arbitrations: A democratic focus group (20-30 people) debates which digital practices should be kept, substituted, de-digitized, or completely renounced. This moves the decision from a technical one to a political/strategic one.
  4. Implementation of Closures: The final phase involves the practical, technical, and human work of dismantling or transforming the targeted practices.

Key Tools: The Attachment Graph and Taxonomy of Locks/Levers

A novel visualization tool introduced in this research is the Attachment Graph. It plots digital tools based on their environmental impact (vertical axis) versus the degree of stakeholder attachment (horizontal axis).

The Attachment Graph visualizes digital tools based on environmental impact and stakeholder attachment strength.

Furthermore, the research provides a robust taxonomy of "Locks and Levers" for digital redirection. "Locks" include factors like hierarchical obligation and fatalism, while "Levers" include aversion to technology and direct gains, such as simplicity or increased independence.

Taxonomy of Locks and Levers used to categorize organizational attachments to digital tools.

Discussion and Preliminary Results

The protocol is currently being tested in two case studies: an eco-village (low digital intensity) and a town hall (high digital intensity). Preliminary findings suggest that the protocol is effective at surfacing "invisible" attachments—dependencies that users don't realize they have until they are asked to imagine life without the tool.

A core insight is the concept of the "Negative Commons": the need to manage the "heritage" of the technosphere—waste, infrastructure, and dependencies—rather than simply walking away. For renunciation to be sustainable, it must be a democratic choice made by the people who actually use the tools.

Limitations and Future Work

The protocol is time-consuming and can be difficult to implement in organizations saturated with productive tasks. Additionally, the mapping phase is iterative, as true attachment levels often only become clear when a tool's existence is threatened. Scaling these radical policies within broader techno-industrial societies remains a challenge for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

The digitalization of societies raises questions about its sustainability and the socio-technical impacts it generates. Ecological redirection applied to organizations is a field of research aiming for achieving sustainability as a direction, rather than for technical means. Arbitration and renunciation to some digital usage and technologies are investigated. Ecological redirection is, however, not yet addressing concrete methodologies for its implementation in organizations. This paper therefore proposes a protocol to support stakeholders in the ecological redirection of their digital practices. This protocol is based on mapping attachments to digital tools through a multi-disciplinary survey. It then proposes increasing stakeholders' knowledge and skills to prepare a debate on the arbitration of renunciations, and finally, to operationalize the closure/transformation of targeted digital practices. This protocol will be tested in real conditions in different contexts. An empirical study is proposed to measure 1) the fluidity with which participants carry out the protocol, 2) the effectiveness of the protocol in terms of the redirection objective, 3) the socio-technical barriers to the redirection process. The paper concludes on the potential benefits for organizations to better understand both the barriers related to its ecological redirection and the transformative aim of such protocols. This will help them trigger large and radical policies towards a desirable and sustainable society.
BibTeX
@misc{girard2025protocol,
  author = {Valentin Girard and Antoine Martin and Maud Rio and Romain Couillet},
  title = {{A Protocol to Address Ecological Redirection for Digital Practices in Organizations}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2507.19078},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.19078},
}
Figure