Computational Investigations of the Lithium Superoxide Dimer Rearrangement on Noisy Quantum Devices

Qi Gao, Hajime Nakamura, Tanvi P. Gujarati, Gavin O. Jones, Julia E. Rice, Stephen Wood, Marco Pistoia, Jeannette M. Garcı́a, Naoki YamamotoThe Journal of Physical Chemistry A 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Quantum chemistry studies of biradical systems are challenging due to the required multiconfigurational nature of the wavefunction. In this work, Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is used to compute the energy profile for the lithium superoxide dimer rearrangement, involving biradical species, on quantum simulators and devices. Considering that current quantum devices can only handle limited number of qubits, we present guidelines for selecting an appropriate active space to perform computations on chemical systems that require many qubits. We show that with VQE performed with a quantum simulator reproduces results obtained with full-configuration interaction (Full CI) for the chosen active space. However, results deviate from exact values by about 39 mHa for calculations on a quantum device. This deviation can be improved to about 4 mHa using the readout mitigation approach and can be further improved to 2 mHa, approaching chemical accuracy, using the state tomography technique to purify the calculated quantum state.

Introduction

Quantum chemistry is a primary candidate for demonstrating quantum advantage, as simulating molecular systems becomes exponentially difficult for classical computers as system size increases. However, current hardware resides in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, characterized by limited qubit counts and significant noise.

This study focuses on the dimerization of lithium superoxide ($LiO_2$), a critical process for understanding the efficiency and degradation of lithium-air batteries. These batteries offer significantly higher energy densities than conventional lithium-ion cells, but their commercialization is hindered by complex side reactions. Simulating the full $LiO_2$ dimer rearrangement would typically require 60 qubits, exceeding the capabilities of current reliable hardware.

Reaction pathway for the rearrangement of the lithium superoxide dimer from reactant to product.

Methodology

To address these hardware limitations, the researchers employed the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm. Key strategies included:

  • Active Space Reduction: By focusing on the Highest Occupied Molecular Orbital (HOMO) and Lowest Unoccupied Molecular Orbital (LUMO), the problem was reduced to a two-qubit active space.
  • Ansatz Selection: Several trial wavefunctions (ansätze) were evaluated, including UCCSD and heuristic forms like Ry and SwapRz. The Ry ansatz was selected for hardware implementation due to its lower CNOT gate count, which minimizes noise accumulation.
  • Error Mitigation: Readout error mitigation was applied via Qiskit to correct measurement inaccuracies.
  • Hardware Implementation: Experiments were conducted on the 20-qubit ibmq_poughkeepsie device.

Molecular geometries for the reactant (caged dimer), product (linear dimer), and transition state were pre-optimized using classical Density Functional Theory (DFT) at the B3LYP-D3 level.

Key Results and Discussion

On an ideal quantum simulator, VQE results perfectly matched Full Configuration Interaction (Full CI) benchmarks for the selected active space. On physical hardware, raw results initially showed energy overestimations of 14–33 mHa.

VQE convergence (a-c) and final energy profiles (d) comparing unmitigated and mitigated experimental results against exact values.

As shown in Figure 4, applying readout error mitigation significantly improved accuracy. For the product state, the error dropped to approximately 2 mHa, nearing the threshold for "chemical accuracy." The calculated energy barrier on hardware (with mitigation) was 14 mHa, compared to the exact value of 18 mHa.

A notable advantage of VQE is its ability to automatically optimize electronic spin states. Unlike classical methods where researchers must pre-define spin multiplicity (e.g., singlet vs. triplet), VQE allows the spin state to evolve naturally during the optimization process.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that strategic active space reduction allows complex chemical reaction pathways to be explored on current NISQ devices. While the two-qubit model captures the essential physics of the $LiO_2$ rearrangement, higher precision for industrial applications will require larger active spaces and more qubits. Future efforts will focus on advanced error suppression techniques, such as state tomography and purification, to bridge the gap between current hardware performance and the requirements for precise battery design.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum chemistry studies of biradical systems are challenging due to the required multiconfigurational nature of the wavefunction. In this work, Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is used to compute the energy profile for the lithium superoxide dimer rearrangement, involving biradical species, on quantum simulators and devices. Considering that current quantum devices can only handle limited number of qubits, we present guidelines for selecting an appropriate active space to perform computations on chemical systems that require many qubits. We show that with VQE performed with a quantum simulator reproduces results obtained with full-configuration interaction (Full CI) for the chosen active space. However, results deviate from exact values by about 39 mHa for calculations on a quantum device. This deviation can be improved to about 4 mHa using the readout mitigation approach and can be further improved to 2 mHa, approaching chemical accuracy, using the state tomography technique to purify the calculated quantum state.
BibTeX
@article{gao2021computational,
  author = {Qi Gao and Hajime Nakamura and Tanvi P. Gujarati and Gavin O. Jones and Julia E. Rice and Stephen Wood and Marco Pistoia and Jeannette M. Garcı́a and Naoki Yamamoto},
  title = {{Computational Investigations of the Lithium Superoxide Dimer Rearrangement on Noisy Quantum Devices}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry A},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpca.0c09530},
}
Figure