Competition–colonization trade-off promotes coexistence of low-virulence viral strains

Samuel Ojosnegros, Edgar Delgado‐Eckert, Niko Beerenwinkel

TL;DR

This paper proposes a "competition-colonization trade-off" model to explain how different strains of RNA viruses can coexist within a host. Their simulations show that while fast-spreading, virulent "colonizer" strains dominate early infections, slower-growing but more efficient "competitor" strains eventually take over, leading to an overall decrease in viral virulence. This challenges previous models that predicted a general increase in virulence.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The evolution of viral virulence is a complex phenomenon that has puzzled scientists for decades. While it's understood that viruses can evolve to become more or less harmful to their hosts, the specific mechanisms driving this evolution, especially within a single host's body, are not fully clear. Previous models often assumed a direct link between virulence and a virus's ability to spread or reproduce, leading to predictions of increasing virulence over time. However, experimental observations, particularly with RNA viruses like Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus (FMDV), suggest a more nuanced picture. These viruses can diversify into different strains with varying virulence, and their interactions within a host's cells can be complex. This paper aims to reconcile these observations by exploring how a trade-off between a virus's ability to colonize new cells (spread quickly) and its ability to compete within already infected cells (reproduce efficiently) might drive the evolution of virulence and lead to the coexistence of different viral strains.

Methods

The researchers employed a well-established mathematical modeling approach: ordinary differential equations (ODEs) to simulate virus dynamics within a host. They adapted a standard SIR-type model to incorporate multiple viral strains and their interactions. The core innovation is the introduction of a "competition-colonization trade-off." This trade-off is mathematically represented by how efficiently a virus can produce progeny in coinfected cells. In their model:

  • Colonizers: These are the virulent strains (high virulence, a_i) that are good at spreading to new, uninfected cells.
  • Competitors: These are less virulent strains (low virulence, a_i) that are more efficient at replicating within cells already infected by other viruses (high c_ijk values).

They specifically modeled this trade-off by setting the intracellular competitiveness (c_ijk) to be inversely proportional to virulence (a_i). They also explored scenarios with and without a simplified immune response and extended their model from three viral strains to a more realistic scenario with 60 strains.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on mathematical modeling and simulations, using parameter values derived from previous experimental work with FMDV.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Biphasic Dynamics" of Viral Infection: The simulations reveal a two-phase process. Initially, virulent "colonizer" strains, with their rapid spread, dominate the viral population. However, as the infection progresses and more cells become coinfected, the less virulent but more competitive "competitor" strains gain an advantage and eventually outcompete the colonizers.
  • Coexistence and Attenuation: This competition-colonization trade-off leads to a stable coexistence of multiple viral strains at equilibrium, with a predominance of the less virulent, more competitive strains. This results in an overall "attenuation" of the viral population's virulence, meaning the infection becomes less severe than it might have been if only virulent strains dominated.
  • Immune System's Double-Edged Sword: Surprisingly, the introduction of a simplified immune response initially favored colonizers by reducing the overall viral load. This suggests that the immune system, by eliminating infected cells (patches), could inadvertently drive viral populations towards increased virulence in some scenarios, a finding that contrasts with the general attenuation observed without immune pressure.
  • Virulence as a Population Trait: The study emphasizes that viral virulence is not just a property of individual viruses but a dynamic characteristic of the entire viral population, shaped by the interactions between strains and the host environment.

Key Results

  • Stable Coexistence: The models consistently predict a stable steady state where multiple viral strains, with varying virulence, coexist.
  • Dominance of Competitors: At equilibrium, the less virulent, more competitive strains dominate the population.
  • Virulence Attenuation: The overall population virulence decreases over the course of the infection, contrary to predictions from models without this trade-off.
  • Impact of Strain Number: With a larger number of initial viral strains (60 vs. 3), fewer strains survive to coexist at equilibrium, suggesting that initial population heterogeneity plays a role in the final composition.
  • Immune Response Shift: In the presence of an immune response, the population can shift back towards higher virulence, with less virulent strains being driven to extinction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Immune Response: The immune response modeled is a simplified representation. Future work could incorporate more complex and specific immune mechanisms.
  • Absence of Mutation: The current model does not explicitly include viral mutation, which is a crucial factor in RNA virus evolution. The authors mention that preliminary simulations suggest mutation could lead to a redistribution of equilibrium abundances and broader variability.
  • Limited Coinfection: The model primarily considers single and double infections. Exploring higher orders of coinfection could provide further insights.
  • Ecological Analogy: The authors draw parallels to ecological succession, suggesting that viral infections can be viewed as dynamic ecological processes. Further exploration of this analogy could be fruitful.
  • Defective Interfering Particles: The role of defective interfering particles, which often require coinfection for replication and can contribute to attenuation, is highlighted as an area for further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

RNA viruses exist as genetically diverse populations displaying a range of virulence degrees. The evolution of virulence in viral populations is, however, poorly understood. On the basis of the experimental observation of an RNA virus clone in cell culture diversifying into two subpopulations of different virulence, we study the dynamics of mutating virus populations with varying virulence. We introduce a competition-colonization trade-off into standard mathematical models of intra-host viral infection. Colonizers are fast-spreading virulent strains, whereas the competitors are less-virulent variants but more successful within co-infected cells. We observe a two-step dynamics of the population. Early in the infection, the population is dominated by colonizers, which later are outcompeted by competitors. Our simulations suggest the existence of steady state in which all virulence classes coexist but are dominated by the most competitive ones. This equilibrium implies collective virulence attenuation in the population, in contrast to previous models predicting evolution of the population towards increased virulence.
BibTeX
@article{ojosnegros2012competitioncolonization,
  author = {Samuel Ojosnegros and Edgar Delgado‐Eckert and Niko Beerenwinkel},
  title = {{Competition–colonization trade-off promotes coexistence of low-virulence viral strains}},
  journal = {Journal of The Royal Society Interface},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1098/rsif.2012.0160},
}
Figure