Competition between folding and aggregation in a model for protein solutions

Moumita Maiti, Madan Rao, Srikanth Sastry

Abstract

We study the thermodynamic and kinetic consequences of the competition between single-protein folding and protein-protein aggregation using a phenomenological model, in which the proteins can be in the unfolded (U), misfolded (M) or folded (F) states. The phase diagram shows the coexistence between a phase with aggregates of misfolded proteins and a phase of isolated proteins (U or F) in solution. The spinodal at low protein concentrations shows non-monotonic behavior with temperature, with implications for the stability of solutions of folded proteins at low temperatures. We follow the dynamics upon "quenching" from the U-phase (cooling) or the F-phase (heating) to the metastable or unstable part of the phase diagram that results in aggregation. We describe how interesting consequences to the distribution of aggregate size, and growth kinetics arise from the competition between folding and aggregation.

Introduction: The Protein's Dilemma

Proteins face a fundamental choice: fold into their functional "native" state or clump together into potentially toxic aggregates, such as the Amyloid $\beta$ plaques associated with Alzheimer’s disease. While single-protein folding is a mature field of study, the competition between folding and aggregation—particularly at the high concentrations found in vivo—remains less understood. This research bridges that gap by investigating how a stable folded state influences the kinetics and thermodynamics of aggregation.

Methods: A Three-State Lattice Model

The study employs a three-dimensional (3D) lattice-gas model where each site on a cubic lattice is either empty or occupied by a protein in one of three states:

  1. Unfolded (U): High entropy, zero internal energy (random coil).
  2. Folded (F): The global energy minimum with very low entropy (native state).
  3. Misfolded (M): Intermediate energy and entropy. Crucially, only M-state proteins exhibit attractive interactions (strength $J$).

The model was analyzed using Mean-Field Theory to map the equilibrium phase diagram and Monte Carlo simulations to study "quenching" kinetics—the system's response to sudden temperature changes that drive aggregation. Parameters were calibrated using experimental values for Amyloid $\beta$ (1-42) to ensure biological relevance.

Thermodynamic Insights: The Reentrant Spinodal

The most striking thermodynamic discovery is the non-monotonic behavior of the "spinodal" line—the boundary of local stability. At low protein concentrations, lowering the temperature initially increases stability against aggregation before eventually leading to instability. This "bend" occurs near the folding temperature ($T_f$), suggesting that the presence of a stable folded state can temporarily shield the solution from clumping.

Phase diagram showing the regions of unfolded (U), folded (F), and misfolded (M) states, along with various quenching paths (1-8) used to study aggregation kinetics.

The initial state of the protein solution significantly dictates aggregation kinetics. Heating a cold, folded solution (F $\to$ M) delays aggregation compared to cooling a hot, unfolded solution (U $\to$ M). This delay occurs because the system must first overcome the energy barrier to "break" the stable folded proteins into the misfolded state.

Kinetic Results: Growth Laws and Distributions

Unlike standard aggregation models that predict exponential cluster size distributions, this model reveals a power-law distribution ($P(n, t) \sim n^{-3.5}$) at early stages. This behavior arises because the continuous conversion of U or F proteins into the M-state acts as a constant "source," mimicking open-system dynamics.

Cluster size distributions P(n,t) and mean aggregate size growth <n> over time, highlighting the power-law kinetics and different growth regimes.

The late-time growth of the mean aggregate size ($\langle n \rangle$) follows distinct power laws based on the limiting physical mechanism:

  • $\langle n \rangle \sim t$: Dominant when growth is diffusion-limited.
  • $\langle n \rangle \sim t^3$: Dominant when growth is limited by the rate of state conversion (U/F $\to$ M).
  • $\langle n \rangle \sim t^{3/2}$: Dominant when detachment/attachment dynamics prevail.

Furthermore, in metastable conditions, a "growth plateau" was observed where small aggregates (up to 30 monomers) form but resist immediate expansion, likely due to a protective "cloud" of U/F proteins surrounding the misfolded core.

Limitations and Future Directions

The current model assumes isotropic (spherical) interactions, whereas real protein aggregates often form highly ordered, anisotropic structures like fibrils. Future work will aim to incorporate:

  1. Anisotropy: Directional interactions to model linear fibril formation.
  2. Mixed Aggregates: Interactions between Unfolded and Misfolded states to explore more complex morphologies.
  3. Electrostatics: Charge interactions to better reflect the physical environment of cellular solutions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the thermodynamic and kinetic consequences of the competition between single-protein folding and protein-protein aggregation using a phenomenological model, in which the proteins can be in the unfolded (U), misfolded (M) or folded (F) states. The phase diagram shows the coexistence between a phase with aggregates of misfolded proteins and a phase of isolated proteins (U or F) in solution. The spinodal at low protein concentrations shows non-monotonic behavior with temperature, with implications for the stability of solutions of folded proteins at low temperatures. We follow the dynamics upon "quenching" from the U-phase (cooling) or the F-phase (heating) to the metastable or unstable part of the phase diagram that results in aggregation. We describe how interesting consequences to the distribution of aggregate size, and growth kinetics arise from the competition between folding and aggregation.
BibTeX
@article{maiti2010competition,
  author = {Moumita Maiti and Madan Rao and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Competition between folding and aggregation in a model for protein solutions}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal E},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1140/epje/i2010-10621-4},
}

Loading related content...

Figure